Was the decision to distribute spoils made by the state or a council presided by the commander of the army? If it's by the state then i'd like source for that
Either way even going with the flow of your argument then even after being given to someone she'll have the status of a slave ergo she...
If you're familiar with anti-Islam polemics then you'll get an idea on where he gets his arguments from which shows one facet of him...the pact of Umar was a giveaway for me, this is often brought up as a fear mongering tool in right wing circles...he's been pushing a narrative against Muslims...
Ji bilkul bilkul :cheers:
I've got a few acquaintances (sensible I must say) in Shiv Sena who's not comfy with what he did, they're trying to change things for the better step by step basically
Yes but retaliation should be within the diameter of permissibility
Non consensual sexual relationships with war captives/slave girls isn't allowed, Umar sentenced someone to death for raping a war captive who was given to him (the someone) to take care of
You do realize that Islamic laws didn't come in a jiffy right? He had his opinion and own character but he had a prescriptive law and morality to follow and that's what he followed in Jerusalem as well as in your example he eventually followed what was ordered (assuming the incident is true)...
It wasn't individual nor is it absurd, if you've read history both jewish tribes which were expelled worked as a community against the Muslims, even going by your logic the "decent majority" (not the individuals) could've easily worked something out with the Muslims (the obvious winners to-be)...
Millions? Meccan population was around 30000 to 50000, same for Medina...forget "millions", or a million or half a million even a quarter of a million would be too much of an estimate
They initiated war against Muslims, btw in the context of that time being expelled wasn't inhumane (they had...
It was one of the many theologically motivated massacres the Jews faced in Europe, basically to summarize it for you back then due to the New Testament's portrayal of the Jews and the Pharisees from the beginning to the climax where Jews conspired to convince Pilate to crucify the Christ as well...
Sigh that's why I believe IQ tests should be obligatory at the verification stage
Btw halfwit let me remind you that you posted a quote and the basis of my reply was related to that quote and @jamahir claim about Europe
Halfwit read again or you probably need a better brain, who's taking...
What's so "unreal" about it? The Jewish golden age in Europe happened during Muslim rule halfwit and as a bonus guess where they ran to after the reconquista, i'm adding this coz that's the most obvious example to what @jamahir alluded to about Europe
King Manu is some legendary fellow believed to be the first human and he's one of the proposed (as per hindus ofc) possible authors of Manusmriti (the text he's citing)
More like a mix of Adam and Noah from an Abrahamic lense, considering the flood in the Matsya
It varied considerably in different territories and republics, sometimes as high as western Europe, sometimes considerably much lower and those with lower rates didn't fluctate much during the years compared to those with higher ones
That's heartbreaking, all I'm thinking right now is what...