What's new

Indian Astrophysicist’s Theory That ‘Black Holes Don’t Exist’ Gets Confirmed By NASA

thesolar65

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 3, 2012
Messages
4,922
Reaction score
-12
Country
India
Location
India
Meet Abhas Mitra, an Indian astrophysicist, who proved that black holes don’t really exist.
mitra_650_020514022754.jpg

Image Source

According to him, the black holes are actually ultra hot balls of fire like our Sun and they don’t really exist. And NASA has confirmed it.

NASA announced that two of its space telescopes caught a supermassive black hole in the midst of a giant eruption of X-ray light. This giant eruption seemed to have been triggered by the eruption of a huge corona (charged particles) from the “black hole”.

Which left many scientists puzzled: If nothing can exit a black hole, how could a corona come out of it?

With this question puzzling the scientists, it confirms Abhas Mitra’s theory.

Who is Abhas Mitra?
blackhole_2.jpg

Image Source

Till recently, he was the head of theoretical astrophysics at the BARC (Bhabha Atomic Research Centre), in Mumbai and at present he is the Adjunct Professor at the Homi Bhabha National Institute.

Here are the further explanations of his theory.
As a massive star contract to the size of a black hole, the radiation trapped within the extremely hot star must exert an outward force to counter the gravitational pull resulting into a state of eternal contraction with an infinitesimally slow rate. Thus, instead of true black holes predicted by Einstein’s theory, we proposed that massive stars end up as balls of fire — termed Magnetospheric Eternally Collapsing Objects or MECOs.

And NASA’s present theory can be explained by this MECO paradigm. Gas streams pulled inward by gravity get extremely hot by friction and may radiate X-rays. Our best example of a magnetised ball of fire is our Sun which is surrounded by a tenuous aura of plasma called Corona.

Instabilities associated with this magnetised plasma result in intermittent eruptions from the Sun in the form of solar flares and coronal mass ejections. While a true black hole cannot possess any intrinsic magnetic field, there can be magnetic field associated with the disk or gas surrounding a MECO.

This latest astrophysical observation by NASA should prompt astrophysicists to take a closer look at the MECO paradigm.

Indian Astrophysicist’s Theory That 'Black Holes Don’t Exist' Gets Confirmed By NASA

@Skull and Bones @Aminroop
 
I read about it and was intrigued. I thought he was a professor of some sort. But if he's been the head of astrophysics at BARC, now that's a very heavy weight physicist right there. Will be interested in seeing where this goes.
 
How these discovery has effect on Einstein's General Theory of Relativity ?
 
How these discovery has effect on Einstein's General Theory of Relativity ?

Actually not just theory or relativity but all physical laws break down when you apply them to black holes. So you should be concerned about physics in general :D

Meet Abhas Mitra, an Indian astrophysicist, who proved that black holes don’t really exist.
mitra_650_020514022754.jpg

Image Source

According to him, the black holes are actually ultra hot balls of fire like our Sun and they don’t really exist. And NASA has confirmed it.

Wait what ? they are hot balls but they don't exist ? How can something which doesn't exist have some defined property ?

NASA announced that two of its space telescopes caught a supermassive black hole in the midst of a giant eruption of X-ray light. This giant eruption seemed to have been triggered by the eruption of a huge corona (charged particles) from the “black hole”.

Which left many scientists puzzled: If nothing can exit a black hole, how could a corona come out of it?


well black holes do emit light and gamma rays and other charged particles. This has always been known. Those who weren't aware of it, read about Quasars ! In fact a quasar
can be so bright that it can dwarf massive galaxies put together.



With this question puzzling the scientists, it confirms Abhas Mitra’s theory.

Who is Abhas Mitra?
blackhole_2.jpg

Image Source

Till recently, he was the head of theoretical astrophysics at the BARC (Bhabha Atomic Research Centre), in Mumbai and at present he is the Adjunct Professor at the Homi Bhabha National Institute.

Here are the further explanations of his theory.
As a massive star contract to the size of a black hole, the radiation trapped within the extremely hot star must exert an outward force to counter the gravitational pull resulting into a state of eternal contraction with an infinitesimally slow rate. Thus, instead of true black holes predicted by Einstein’s theory, we proposed that massive stars end up as balls of fire — termed Magnetospheric Eternally Collapsing Objects or MECOs.

And NASA’s present theory can be explained by this MECO paradigm. Gas streams pulled inward by gravity get extremely hot by friction and may radiate X-rays. Our best example of a magnetised ball of fire is our Sun which is surrounded by a tenuous aura of plasma called Corona.

Instabilities associated with this magnetised plasma result in intermittent eruptions from the Sun in the form of solar flares and coronal mass ejections. While a true black hole cannot possess any intrinsic magnetic field, there can be magnetic field associated with the disk or gas surrounding a MECO.

This latest astrophysical observation by NASA should prompt astrophysicists to take a closer look at the MECO paradigm.

Indian Astrophysicist’s Theory That 'Black Holes Don’t Exist' Gets Confirmed By NASA

How is this theory different from Hawking radiation theory ?
 
Interesting .... would love to hear what Stephen Hawking has to say about this
 
Back
Top Bottom