What's new

US says India’s security concerns in Afghanistan same as Pakistan’s

Alicia Wells, the state department’s highest ranking official for South Asia, recounted India’s commitment to spend $3 billion in Afghanistan.(Reuters File)


The US on Thursday said India has as many legitimate security interests in Afghanistan as Pakistan, days after President Donald Trump announced his South Asia policy that required New Delhi to play a larger role in the war-torn country.

“Just as Pakistan has very real and legitimate security interests in Afghanistan, so does India,” Alicia Wells, the state department’s highest ranking official for South Asia, said at a congressional hearing. She was responding to a question about Pakistan worrying about a larger for India in Afghanistan.

“We would like to see, and appreciate, constructive economic investment in Afghanistan’s stability and institutional stability,” she said, recounting India’s commitment to spend $3 billion in Afghanistan, and highlighted work done, including the construction of its new parliament building.

Wells was testifying before a subcommittee of the House of Representatives’ foreign affairs committee, which is considering the state department’s budgetary proposals for South Asia for 2018.

Equating India’s security concerns in Afghanistan to that of Pakistan could add to the disquiet already felt in Islamabad over Trump’s new policy of inviting New Delhi to play a larger role in the region.

On the recent Doklam stand-off between India and China, Wells refused to take sides. The US, she said, supports stable and peaceful relations globally, and among all countries, including India and China. The US goal in the “Indo-Pacific region is every nation should be able to work together, to uphold international norms, and to prosper,” she said.

Wells was asked whether India was willing to “stand up to China” and whether there was anything in the budget to enable US to strengthen security ties with India that could be “beneficial in checking China’s unwarranted territorial claims” through the rest of Asia.

In response, she said that while the US generally supports “a prosperous India that plays a leading global role... both China and India are leading powers but our relationship with India stands on its own” because it is based on democratic values, close political and economic relations, and growing military ties.
 
Does India share a common border with Afghanistan? If the answer is No than there can never be a parallel between the security concerns of India and Pakistan neither can they be the same.
IC814-KANDAHAR_REUTERS.jpg
 
India's only concern in Afghanistan is prevent the Afghan people from becoming Pakistan's football like Pakistan has been trying since the time of ZA Bhutto and Zia Ul Haq.
 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Airlines_flight_814_hijacking

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_11
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_175
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_175
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_93


there is no need for common borders for us to have shared security concerns.

Pakistan has also suffered from jihad attacks from groups based in Afghanistan but that is more to do with the good and bad taliban game they have played.
 
Does India share a common border with Afghanistan? If the answer is No than there can never be a parallel between the security concerns of India and Pakistan neither can they be the same.

'Never' is too strong a word in geopolitics.

Remember, India shared a border with Afghanistan for thousands of years till only about 70 years ago. We still share a lot of cultural ties.

Also recall that Pakistan ceased to exist in 1971 i.e. the borders in India's neighborhood changed again in less than 25 years after 1947.

Suffice to say our border with Afghanistan has been dynamic and can and hopefully will change again. Probably another few decades.
 
Does India share a common border with Afghanistan? If the answer is No than there can never be a parallel between the security concerns of India and Pakistan neither can they be the same.
Gong by your logic:
  • Does Pakistan share any border with Palestine?
  • Does Pakistan share any border with any Arab Countries?

International relations are not governed by how many borders you share.. its about how many common interest areas you share...
 
Gong by your logic:
  • Does Pakistan share any border with Palestine?
  • Does Pakistan share any border with any Arab Countries?

International relations are not governed by how many borders you share.. its about how many common interest areas you share...

Pakistan doesn't share a border with China also.

Our territory that has been forcibly occupied by Pakistan since 1947 shares a border with Pakistan. Pakistan doesn't.

On the other side there's Tibet, a free country occupied by China.

So Pakistan and China are thousands of miles apart.

Two occupied territories share borders. Pakistan and China do not.
 
Alicia Wells, the state department’s highest ranking official for South Asia, recounted India’s commitment to spend $3 billion in Afghanistan.(Reuters File)


The US on Thursday said India has as many legitimate security interests in Afghanistan as Pakistan, days after President Donald Trump announced his South Asia policy that required New Delhi to play a larger role in the war-torn country.

“Just as Pakistan has very real and legitimate security interests in Afghanistan, so does India,” Alicia Wells, the state department’s highest ranking official for South Asia, said at a congressional hearing. She was responding to a question about Pakistan worrying about a larger for India in Afghanistan.

“We would like to see, and appreciate, constructive economic investment in Afghanistan’s stability and institutional stability,” she said, recounting India’s commitment to spend $3 billion in Afghanistan, and highlighted work done, including the construction of its new parliament building.

Wells was testifying before a subcommittee of the House of Representatives’ foreign affairs committee, which is considering the state department’s budgetary proposals for South Asia for 2018.

Equating India’s security concerns in Afghanistan to that of Pakistan could add to the disquiet already felt in Islamabad over Trump’s new policy of inviting New Delhi to play a larger role in the region.

On the recent Doklam stand-off between India and China, Wells refused to take sides. The US, she said, supports stable and peaceful relations globally, and among all countries, including India and China. The US goal in the “Indo-Pacific region is every nation should be able to work together, to uphold international norms, and to prosper,” she said.

Wells was asked whether India was willing to “stand up to China” and whether there was anything in the budget to enable US to strengthen security ties with India that could be “beneficial in checking China’s unwarranted territorial claims” through the rest of Asia.

In response, she said that while the US generally supports “a prosperous India that plays a leading global role... both China and India are leading powers but our relationship with India stands on its own” because it is based on democratic values, close political and economic relations, and growing military ties.
Sorry for my language, but what ffing bullshit is this????

So now we have the same security concerns in Bhutan that India does and hence are now a party to any disputes in that area!! See how ludicrous that is!!

Just say India is now an ally and hence we are speaking up for her. But the USA should realise and know that she has lost the war and is now just laying turds all over the place.
 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Airlines_flight_814_hijacking

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Airlines_Flight_11
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_175
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_175
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_93


there is no need for common borders for us to have shared security concerns.

Pakistan has also suffered from jihad attacks from groups based in Afghanistan but that is more to do with the good and bad taliban game they have played.
I didnt ask for the links. I knew what it was. Your point was?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom