What's new

The holy city is fast becoming a Las Vegas for pilgrims

Madali

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 28, 2015
Messages
2,717
Reaction score
23
Country
Iran, Islamic Republic Of
Location
Iran, Islamic Republic Of
City in the sky: world's biggest hotel to open in Mecca | Art and design | The Guardian

Four helipads will cluster around one of the largest domes in the world, like sideplates awaiting the unveiling of a momentous main course, which will be jacked up 45 storeys into the sky above the deserts of Mecca. It is the crowning feature of the holy city’s crowning glory, the superlative summit of what will be the world’s largest hotel when it opens in 2017.

With 10,000 bedrooms and 70 restaurants, plus five floors for the sole use of the Saudi royal family, the £2.3bn Abraj Kudai is an entire city of five-star luxury, catering to the increasingly high expectations of well-heeled pilgrims from the Gulf.

Modelled on a “traditional desert fortress”, seemingly filtered through the eyes of a Disneyland imagineer with classical pretensions, the steroidal scheme comprises 12 towers teetering on top of a 10-storey podium, which houses a bus station, shopping mall, food courts, conference centre and a lavishly appointed ballroom.

Located in the Manafia district, just over a mile south of the Grand Mosque, the complex is funded by the Saudi Ministry of Finance and designed by the Dar Al-Handasah group, a 7,000-strong global construction conglomerate that turns its hand to everything from designing cities in Kazakhstan to airports in Dubai. For the Abraj Kudai, it has followed the wedding-cake pastiche style of the city’s recent hotel boom: cornice is piled upon cornice, with fluted pink pilasters framing blue-mirrored windows, some arched with a vaguely Ottoman air. The towers seem to be packed so closely together that guests will be able to enjoy views into each other’s rooms.

“The city is turning into Mecca-hattan,” says Irfan Al-Alawi, director of the UK-based Islamic Heritage Research Foundation, which campaigns to try to save what little heritage is left in Saudi Arabia’s holy cities. “Everything has been swept away to make way for the incessant march of luxury hotels, which are destroying the sanctity of the place and pricing normal pilgrims out.”

Advertisement
The Grand Mosque is now loomed over by the second tallest building in the world, the Abraj al-Bait clocktower, home to thousands more luxury hotel rooms, where rates can reach £4,000 a night for suites with the best views of the Kaaba – the black cube at the centre of the mosque around which Muslims must walk. The hotel rises 600m (2,000ft) into the air, projecting a dazzling green laser-show by night, on a site where an Ottoman fortress once stood – razed for development, along with the hill on which it sat.

The list of heritage crimes goes on, driven by state-endorsed Wahhabism, the hardline interpretation of Islam that perceives historical sites as encouraging sinful idolatry – which spawned the ideology that is now driving Isis’s reign of destruction in Syria and Iraq. In Mecca and Medina, meanwhile, anything that relates to the prophet could be in the bulldozer’s sights. The house of Khadijah, his first wife, was crushed to make way for public lavatories; the house of his companion Abu Bakr is now the site of a Hilton hotel; his grandson’s house was flattened by the king’s palace. Moments from these sites now stands a Paris Hilton store and a gender-segregated Starbucks.

“These are the last days of Mecca,” says Alawi. “The pilgrimage is supposed to be a spartan, simple rite of passage, but it has turned into an experience closer to Las Vegas, which most pilgrims simply can’t afford.”



Along the western edge of Mecca, the Jabal Omar development, which will accommodate 100,000 people. Photograph: Jabal Omar Development
The city receives around 2 million pilgrims for the annual Hajj, but during the rest of the year more than 20 million visit the city, which has become a popular place for weddings and conferences, bringing in annual tourism revenue of around £6bn. The skyline bristles with cranes, summoning thickets of hotel towers to accommodate the influx. Along the western edge of the city the Jabal Omar development now rises, a sprawling complex that will eventually accommodate 100,000 people in 26 luxury hotels – sitting on another gargantuan plinth of 4,000 shops and 500 restaurants, along with its own six-storey prayer hall.

The Grand Mosque, meanwhile, is undergoing a £40bn expansion to double the capacity of its prayer halls – from 3 million worshippers currently to nearly 7 million by 2040. Planned like a vast triangular slice of cake, the extension goes so far back that most worshippers won’t even be able to see the Kaaba.

“It is just like an airport terminal,” says Alawi. “People have been finding they’re praying in the wrong direction because they simply don’t know which way the mosque is any more. It has made a farce of the whole place.”
 
It kind of beats the reason for haj if you are gonna live in such things....beats the purpose of so called shoulder to shoulder with a commoner


“These are the last days of Mecca,” says Alawi. “The pilgrimage is supposed to be a spartan, simple rite of passage, but it has turned into an experience closer to Las Vegas, which most pilgrims simply can’t afford.”

I was under the impression people go to pilgrimiage was to be humble not to indulge in over ratted hotels

Planned like a vast triangular slice of cake, the extension goes so far back that most worshippers won’t even be able to see the Kaaba.

It is further disgusting that they have sold land for hotels up close to the kabbah but made those who go for pilgrimage to move backwards...Just shows where their priorities are...
 
"Habib Zain Al Abideen, the Saudi deputy minister of municipal and rural affairs, head of all the kingdom's hajj-related construction projects, calls the hajj "a good opportunity to visit Mecca and Medina, do some shopping, make a vacation out of it."

Taking his advice in a Topshop less than 100 yards from the Grand Mosque one day in December was Fatima, a twenty-something housewife. Trying to decide between the pink silk-screened tank-top and the lycra scoop-neck blouse, she stood in front of the mirror, frantically holding one and then the other over her black abaya robe. Her friend urged her to hurry up, flashing a Visa card to pay for her stretch jeans and oversized sunglasses at the register so they could make it to the Grand Mosque in time for prayers. But Fatima had been waiting all year to splurge at Topshop. "The store is closing soon," she snaps at her friend. "You can pray any time."
 
"Habib Zain Al Abideen, the Saudi deputy minister of municipal and rural affairs, head of all the kingdom's hajj-related construction projects, calls the hajj "a good opportunity to visit Mecca and Medina, do some shopping, make a vacation out of it."

Taking his advice in a Topshop less than 100 yards from the Grand Mosque one day in December was Fatima, a twenty-something housewife. Trying to decide between the pink silk-screened tank-top and the lycra scoop-neck blouse, she stood in front of the mirror, frantically holding one and then the other over her black abaya robe. Her friend urged her to hurry up, flashing a Visa card to pay for her stretch jeans and oversized sunglasses at the register so they could make it to the Grand Mosque in time for prayers. But Fatima had been waiting all year to splurge at Topshop. "The store is closing soon," she snaps at her friend. "You can pray any time."

Are you trying to imply that all other the shit for brain useless Muslims are any better? No, besides Western Muslims and some Palestinians the rest of you are useless brainless corrupt trash. You're a lost cause.

Look at you fucking clowns, you dedicate your lives to demonizing Saudi Arabia. Get a fucking life and improve the region and it's failed political and social systems.
 
Once again, the stench of money adulterates every aspect of human life, even in Mecca.
 
Obvious troll thread and a typical Guardian article. I think that they have written 10 of such articles about "Makkah disappearing" or turning into "Las Vegas" in just the last 2-3 years.

If making NECESSARY expansions of Al-Masjid Al-Haram due to the enormous and ever growing demand of pilgrims during hajj and umrah suddenly turns Makkah into "Las Vegas" then so be it.

The comparisons are moronic. Las Vegas is a 150 year old city located in the middle of nowhere solely intended for gambling and entertainment. No religious importance for anyone.

Makkah on the other hand is a 3000 year old city that is in constant progress and always been that. Moreover the home city of 2.5 million people and the most sacred city for 1.7 billion people.


Get over it. Makkah was and still is in bad need of modernization. We live in the year 2015. Hotels are necessary to host the ever growing number of pilgrims and there is a demand for high quality hotels. There are hundreds upon hundreds of hotels that the average pilgrim from Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Nigeria can afford to stay in.

Makkah's new Emir has many ambitious projects for Makkah in the near future and I am sure that most of the projects will become a success.

Lastly I never knew that modernization was "haram" let alone hotels, shops, residential complexes or even skyscrapers.:lol:

There will always be people who cry meanwhile thousands upon thousands of pilgrims welcome the changes with open arms.

Besides Makkah is one big construction work currently. Most of the projects won't finalize until 2025 so let's wait with judging the "final work" shall we?

In 30 years time I suspect that more expansions will be necessary. The number of Muslims and people wanting/being able to afford a hajj or umrah trip are hardly decreasing each year, rather the opposite.


Our Farsi troll (thread starter) is as usual obsessive about affairs in the Arab world. Being an Iranian I would think that you would have enough to worry about.

This thread explains everything in detail.

"Makkah and Madinah News and Updates"

Also I suggest reading up on the history of this Irfan al-Alawi and his agenda.

@Horus please take a close look at how this thread develops. I sense a lot of butthurt and potential trolling.
 
Last edited:
I smell jealousy.

Muslim population is going to cross 2 billion by the middle of this century. OIC economies continue to grow, the number of Hujjaj will be in tens of millions. If we don't need infrastructure for that, I don't know what else would cut it.
 
I smell jealousy.

Muslim population is going to cross 2 billion by the middle of this century. OIC economies continue to grow, the number of Hujjaj will be in tens of millions. If we don't need infrastructure for that, I don't know what else would cut it.

Muslim population of 2 billion, 1.6 billion of that eventual 2 billion will be of useless morons who prioritize laziness, jealousy, showing off, drama, falsehood, etc....

You're born in the West, so from our perspective with the potential in the Muslim world we see, the future will be great. That's not the case though, because they don't all think like us. So maybe in far future but near future.
 
I smell jealousy.

Muslim population is going to cross 2 billion by the middle of this century. OIC economies continue to grow, the number of Hujjaj will be in tens of millions. If we don't need infrastructure for that, I don't know what else would cut it.

Madali has probably never even visited Makkah nor those critical of all the infrastructural projects many of which are absolutely necessary. If they had visited they would have understood that those old "slums" that are deemed as being heritage are not suited for living in the modern age.







I am sure that the people living in those quarters (many of them illegal migrants, especially Burmese) love it and it is sure as hell pretty as well.

VS

"Below is just an example not any final render"

hx9n.jpg


The only thing that I am critical of is the Abraj Al-Bait. I am not fully sold. On the other hand it won't stand alone and it looks out of place today but wont' do that in 10 years time.

Also there is plenty of heritage in the outskirts of Makkah and typical mountain Hijazi towns/villages with old architecture. As well as Islamic and pre-Islamic heritage.

Wait until all the gigantic projects are finished before passing judgement. Anything else is idiotic.

Also please educate me on why modern infrastructure, hotels, a few skyscrapers etc. are "haram".

Anyway people are free to voice their opinion.

@Mosamania this is your territory as well brother. Put some sense into some of them.
 
Last edited:
The "un-affordable" argument is invalid, since most of these hotels are going to be reserved by Hajj companies who manage the whole trip for pilgrims even before they set foot in KSA, there are no pilgrims who come without a plan then and try to find "affordable" accommodations.

But of course, Shiites and Shiites sympathizers wouldn't care about that, since they want more of this:


Stampede at Saudi Hajj kills 244 | Daily Mail Online

Hajj stampede kills 35

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/01/13/international/middleeast/13mecca.html

They want more people to die in stampedes, they want them to sleep on the streets. How dare the Saudis try to make it a more pleasant experience, and the Hajj easier to perform for pilgrims of all ages.

They would want Mecca to stop expanding and have less accommodations for Pilgrims, since it means more Muslim deaths, and more Shiite pilgrims to Qom and Karbala.

They don't want this:

10926796_924717260894966_7532269084820367179_o.jpg


CFGyxhDVIAAUg1a.jpg:large


492735983570.jpg


BsEAg3-CMAAKWGI.jpg:large


jamarat3.jpg


Sumou_Makkah_Gate_Masterplan.jpg


image1.jpg


image4.jpg


The Grand Mosque, meanwhile, is undergoing a £40bn expansion to double the capacity of its prayer halls – from 3 million worshippers currently to nearly 7 million by 2040. Planned like a vast triangular slice of cake, the extension goes so far back that most worshippers won’t even be able to see the Kaaba.

Lol at this, so if we try to expand the Mosque vertically we will be accused of trying to "undermine" the Kaaba and "overwhelm" Pilgrims with gigantic structures.

If we do it Horizontally, we will be accused of: "the extension goes so far back that most worshippers won’t even be able to see the Kaaba."

well, I have the proper response to that:

It's OUR city and we will do whatever the hell we want with it, and if ANYONE don't like what we're doing with own goddamn city, he can go and smash his head against a wall. :-)
 
Last edited:
Previously alleged "destroyed" Ottoman era Porticoes being refitted in Haram after restoration.

11150474_10153329131069153_8932433584299444416_n.jpg


11241430_10153329131084153_913912434537668682_n.jpg


11377181_10153328965434153_7179607822486036561_n.jpg


10406738_10153328965429153_4035794227681430845_n.jpg


All restoration and cleaning of these priceless Abbasid/Ottoman era artifacts (Some are more than 1200 years old) were done by a specialized Turkish company.

74587.JPG


74583.JPG


24187402.jpg


74594.JPG


 

Back
Top Bottom