SPACE WAR: ARE WE READY?

[gslv mk3]

Again, India's largest test was only 20 kt (though claimed to be 45 kt).

That's nothing more than a basic fission bomb. It's not even boosted fission.

Nowhere close to the yield of a Thermonuclear device, which is hundreds of times more powerful.

BS again..

 

[Nilgiri]

Last time you said that, it ended with 1962.

And we followed it up with 67 when we are good and ready.

Its been more than 60 years since 1962......surely Vietnam and Philippines can be dealt with in just a few days?

Why the big wait. Occupy every single island in the south china sea just like the paracels. Let's see if you have what it takes to back up your dull repetitive nagging claims.

You are conveniently skirting the yield of the US W76 warhead I see. Cmon Han boy, lets see you explain yourself out of that one.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

China fission bomb test in December 1966: 300 kilotons yield.

China first Thermonuclear test in June 1967: 3.3 megatons yield.

Though America's first Thermonuclear test (Ivy Mike) had a yield of 10 megatons. Damn.

Whereas India's "super hydrogen bomb" had a 20 kt yield, same as a basic fission bomb.

You would not buy a car that has never been tested, yet you'll put the safety of your motherland in the hands of platforms that have never been tested.

 

[gslv mk3]

China fission bomb test in December 1966: 300 kilotons yield.

China first Thermonuclear test in June 1967: 3.3 megatons yield.

Though America's first Thermonuclear test (Ivy Mike) had a yield of 10 megatons. Damn.

Whereas India's "super hydrogen bomb" had a 20 kt yield, same as a basic fission bomb.

You would not buy a car that has never been tested, yet you'll put the safety of your motherland in the hands of platforms that have never been tested.

Chinese troll logic.Ignored.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

You are conveniently skirting the yield of the US W76 warhead I see. Cmon Han boy, lets see you explain yourself out of that one.

The W76 is a miniaturized thermonuclear warhead designed for an MIRV weapon (Trident 2) that carries many warheads.

And still this miniaturized warhead designed for MIRV has massively more power than India's very first "thermonuclear test", that had the same yield as a basic fission bomb.

 

[Nilgiri]

You would not buy a car that has never been tested, yet you'll put the safety of your motherland in the hands of platforms that have never been tested.

Tell us where you live, so we can test the 200kt above you first hand. Then you can write the glorious reality in your little red book, if you are still in one piece that is.

You can go out with a real bang and save us your dull repetitive trolling.

The W76 is a miniaturized thermonuclear warhead designed for an MIRV weapon (Trident 2) that carries many warheads.

And still this miniaturized warhead designed for MIRV has massively more power than India's very first "thermonuclear test", that had the same yield as a basic fission bomb.

So:

A) you have finally admitted there are warheads in the vicinity of 45 kt (as opposed to your claim they have to be 100 or 1000 times more).

B) You admit miniaturisation. Use that glorious Han IQ of yours to think if its possible the other way.

 

[Irfan Baloch]

Indians can send a to mars you dimwit...

Meanwhile your country still can't develop sounding rockets

So STFU.

responding to flame bait is haram in all worldy darhams of internet

 

[gslv mk3]

responding to flame bait is haram in all worldy darhams of internet

Okay,deleted

 

[Echo_419]

What's the point of not testing something?

Would you buy a car that has never been tested? How about a multi-billion dollar missile project?

A test like that can cause a mahyem in space

 

[Nilgiri]

A test like that can cause a mahyem in space

Mr glorious Han is referring to the fact China did an ASAT test some years back (attracting ire of the whole world since it increased space debris by a humongous amount)....so he feels India needs to prove something as well in the same fashion. Hence his trolling.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Tell us where you live, so we can test the 200kt above you first hand. Then you can write the glorious reality in your little red book, if you are still in one piece that is.

You can go out with a real bang and save us your dull repetitive trolling.


So:

A) you have finally admitted there are warheads in the vicinity of 45 kt (as opposed to your claim they have to be 100 or 1000 times more).

B) You admit miniaturisation. Use that glorious Han IQ of yours to think if its possible the other way.

A deliberately miniaturized W76 designed for MIRV still has a 100 kt yield. That's after it was deliberately miniaturized for MIRV, and miniaturization of warheads is a very difficult thing to do. Which is why so few countries have proven MIRV technology (and India is not one of them).

And it's still 5 times more powerful than your 20 kt test, which is nothing more than a basic fission bomb. Not even boosted fission.

You didn't test it for the same reason you're not testing ASAT, or 10,000+ km range ICBM's. Either you don't have the capability, or you're trying to appease America.

Again, you wouldn't buy a car that has not been tested. But you'll put your motherland in the hands of defensive platforms that have not been tested.

 

[Nilgiri]

and miniaturization of warheads is a very difficult thing to do.

They teach you this in Chairman Mao school or something? I agree its difficult, the reverse isn't however!

And it's still 5 times more powerful than your 20 kt test, which is nothing more than a basic fission bomb. Not even boosted fission.

The main test was obviously to prove the design of the primary and a small limited secondary. If you know anything about the Teller-Ulam design, you would know this is easily scaleable given India's established and expanding tritium production and access to supercomputing at the time (mid - late 90s).

The test was really only to establish the precise efficiency of the interstage. Scaling up the size of the secondary would only be constrained by the size of the primary....hence the 200kt "limit" (which is just the official number, you are free to fantasize how big or small it really is).. India simply decided to test the important things, and leave the rest to speculation by her enemies. Guess you are going to have to go all in to figure out if we have a real hand. Till then you are free to keep parroting your incessant trolling. This will be my last reply on the matter.

 

[gslv mk3]

Which is why so few countries have proven MIRV technology (and India is not one of them).

India's 200 kt TN warhead is said to weigh around 400 kgs - You'll see MIRV being tested in a few years.

 

[Nilgiri]

Hopefully under Modi, India does another test, this time a fully capable 200 kt of the established warhead arsenal + megaton test if possible (though not required).

Modi can do this before the next national elections to ensure victory.

 

[Bhasad Singh Mundi]

What's the point of not testing something?

Would you buy a car that has never been tested? How about a multi-billion dollar missile project?

ASAT tests are biggest contributor to space debris. That is the reason why responsible states in spite of having ASAT tech capability do not conduct such tests. if tomorrow France, Germany, England, Japan and India start testing their ASATs, we can say good bye to space exploration.

Russian Satellite Hit by Chinese Anti-Satellite Test Debris

But MOTR hasn't been launched yet, isn't it?

Already operational and tracking