Book Review - THE INDIA DOCTRINE (1947-2007)

Discussion in 'Bangladesh Defence Forum' started by MBI Munshi, Jan 3, 2009.

  1. MBI Munshi

    MBI Munshi PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2007
    Messages:
    8,494
    Ratings:
    +5 / 5,015 / -0
    Country:
    United Kingdom
    Location:
    Bangladesh
    THE INDIA DOCTRINE

    (1947-2007)

    Review by A.K. Zaman

    It is almost two years since the first edition of The India Doctrine appeared on Bangladesh bookshelves to wide acclaim and appreciation. The newly revised edition now titled The India Doctrine (1947-2007) is an astonishing work of exceptional depth and analysis and is probably the first book of its kind not only in Bangladesh but also in South Asia as a whole. It is indeed a stupendous effort by Barrister MBI Munshi. While I had a few words of criticism for the original version of the book which appeared to me to be fragmentary and a little disjointed this revised edition is an exceptional work and its various parts have been finely consolidated and is also far better written and organized. As the author reminds us, he had almost two years to write this revised edition and it was certainly time well spent as the language and style is now much easier to follow and effortless to comprehend.

    The Bangladesh Defence Journal (BDJ) has published the book at a price of Tk. 1200 or roughly $17 and is 636 pages in length. Of those pages one third consists of end notes and references which number in their thousands leaving in no doubt the strong evidentiary grounds on which Barristers Munshi’s thesis is based. The book also contains a useful foreword by the editor of BDJ, Mr. Abu Rushd, who earlier wrote the ground breaking ‘RAW in Bangladesh.’ Mr. Rushd in his foreword contrasts the original version of ‘The India Doctrine’ and the present edition stating that, “The first edition was a turning point in political and historical writing in Bangladesh. The second edition continues this trend with further elaboration of issues … covered in the earlier book but on very recent events such as the causes behind the cancellation of elections in 2007 and new material on the 1971 liberation war and India’s motivations in assisting [an] emergent Bangladesh.”

    Mr. Rushd further elaborates on the importance of the book in the context of South Asia’s geo-strategic realities, “The book is certainly a must read for those interested in South Asian affairs, geo-strategy, intelligence, and the political, diplomatic and economic influences of an increasingly important region of the world which contains almost a sixth of the world population, two nuclear powers and several more in the near vicinity. The book will hopefully inspire others to explore the subject of Indian hegemony and expansionism and also allow policy-makers in the West to better comprehend the risks of permitting an unrestrained India to dominate the region.” The last remark seems particularly relevant in light of the Mumbai terror attacks in December 2008 and the increasingly hostile attitude taken by India towards its neighbour Pakistan who it accuses of having direct involvement in the incident although only a few weeks earlier a Col. Srikant Pirohit had been apprehended for supplying explosives to Hindu fanatics to carry out similar outrages.

    Mr. Rushd concludes that the book should hopefully, “educate the policy-makers and military planners in Bangladesh about possible threats emanating from our neighbour and the consequences of New Delhi’s influence in our internal affairs as well as the principal cause of instability.” This is probably even more pertinent after the overwhelming victory of the Awami League (AL) party in the recently concluded 2008 national elections. The AL has often aligned itself with the interests of New Delhi in both foreign and internal matters and this has aggravated tensions within the country. It would be wise for the AL leaders to take some lessons from this book and adopt a more cautious attitude to New Delhi since our own history shows that a two-thirds majority in parliament is no guarantee of longevity or permanence in power especially when deeply held views about our national interest are constantly and arrogantly offended.

    The obvious reason for publishing this new edition is that the original book had many gaps and overlooked many significant issues principally due to the time limitations placed on the author. Barrister Munshi states in his opening remarks in the preface that, “By all accounts the first edition of ‘The India Doctrine’ was a book incomplete. While it covered the essentials of the periods 1947 and 1971 fairly well it managed to convey only a fraction of the notable events and incidents that were to take place during 2006 and which were to reach a climax in 2007. The years 2006-2007 had much less of the cruelty, violence and bloodshed associated with 1947 and 1971 but nevertheless represents a significant period of transition that witnessed a revival of great power politics in South Asia that was to significantly affect the terms of the India Doctrine.” This short period indeed witnessed immense and often tragic and horrendous events that will undoubtedly have lasting effects on the South Asian perspective and psyche.

    The author next deals quite comprehensively with the internal struggles within India and its new alliance with the United States built upon the tenuous foundations of the nuclear agreement passed amidst intense opposition, particularly in India. The author explores how this new strategic relationship affects the regional balance and includes reference to China and Russia and the wider geo-strategic imperatives of the United States and India. The author then surveys the influence of the India doctrine and Forward Policy on the South Asian neighbourhood and the internal conflicts this incited in many countries of the region (i.e. Sri Lanka, Nepal, Sikkim, Pakistan and Bangladesh). The next few chapters on the liberation war and Indian propaganda have been completely redone and large segments rearranged to fit more logically the shape, context and logic of the book. New material and information is incorporated into chapters 4-8 and recent developments on the CHT insurgency and peace agreement is rendered in the last of these chapters.

    From a Bangladesh perspective the most controversial sections of the book will probably be Chapters 9 and 10 that deal with India’s project to have Bangladesh declared a failed state. The chosen method to achieve this objective has been through propaganda with the labeling of Bangladesh as a ‘hotbed’ of Islamist terrorism. The media campaign orchestrated by India has been so successful that many voters in the 2008 elections actually believed this nonsense not realizing that such malicious canards were being propagated by Indian intelligence (i.e. RAW) via our local media. Another method favoured by India to have Bangladesh rendered a failed state is through economic sabotage and as Barrister Munshi explains, “For India to secure its political and military supremacy and control over the South Asian region it has become necessary for it to continuously maintain and protect her lead over other economies even by unfair means such as sabotage, fomenting and encouraging political instability in neighbouring countries and most obviously through propaganda.” However, it is interference in the political sphere that India has been most successful in undermining Bangladesh’s democratic institutions and Barrister Munshi traces the chaotic events surrounding the transfer of power to a caretaker government in 2006 to the release of Sheikh Hasina from custody in June 2008 with each event being heavily influenced by external actors and in particular India. Barrister Munshi provides a convincing argument and analysis on all the above issues and his contribution to the book stands as an extraordinary achievement that will set the standard for such works in Bangladesh and probably elsewhere in South Asia. The 557 pages written by Barrister Munshi will hopefully gain widespread readership in Bangladesh since the issues raised in the book are incredibly important to the continued independence and integrity of the nation against the hegemonic and domineering tendencies of India. The chapters written by the author will likely stand out as the most important to be written on South Asian affairs for the last 60 years at least. It presents a completely new perspective on South Asia rarely seen in writing from this region and hardly discussed in western literature on the subject.

    The final two chapters of the book are authored by two Pakistanis and this is a major development on the first edition which had no chapters on Pakistan and this is probably the only collaboration between writers of both countries on this type of subject matter. Chapter 11 of the book is titled ‘The Peace Charade’ and is written by Mr. Ahmed Quraishi. Mr. Quraishi is a prominent media personality in Pakistan and his background as an investigative journalist, columnist, roving reporter and head of a private, independent think tank are all very impressive and raise his credentials as a highly respected and informed writer. According to Mr. Quraishi, India had by early 2008 been conducting a massive intelligence operation with Pakistan as its target. Afghanistan was being used by New Delhi as a springboard and the Islamists were the tools of this operation. Israel is said to have provided help and the US position as Pakistan’s ally is described as somewhat ambiguous. This brief summary sets the tone for a very interesting and well researched chapter with its premise based on the discovery of a document that reveals a conspiracy ‘to break the stranglehold of the intelligence agencies, the bureaucracy and the military in Pakistan’ as these are believed by India to be responsible for keeping the Kashmir issue alive. Chapter 12 of the book is written by Dr. Prevaiz Iqbal Cheema who has an outstanding academic career. He obtained and M. Litt in Strategic Studies from Aberdeen University and a Ph.D. from Quaid-i-Azam University in Pakistan. He has been a teacher for almost 28 years with posts held in Pakistan, Australia, Singapore and the United States. His excellent and lucidly argued chapter discusses the Kashmir dispute and Pakistan-India relations. His chapter initially discusses the origin and nature of the Kashmir dispute highlighting the policies of both India and Pakistan followed by a discussion on the internationalization of the dispute. Finally the paper focuses on the new developments that have impacted upon the dispute and the current status of Indo-Pak relations. Dr. Cheema concludes his survey of the issues by commenting that, “Without the resolution of [the] Kashmir dispute, not only India and Pakistan would never enjoy proper fruits of peace and cooperation but South Asia would also be deprived of much desired peaceful environment.” It is, therefore, unfortunate that India has not shown the requisite sincerity in negotiations for this sensible and desired outcome for regional peace and security.

    Overall, this book, The India Doctrine (1947-2007), is an extraordinary and astounding effort requiring not only immense dedication but also a significant amount of courage, boldness and resolution. Writing in the hostile and threatening atmosphere created by India in Bangladesh and Pakistan the writers have shown admirable willpower and fortitude. The book not only deserves success but also our respect.

    http://www.shodalap.com/AKZ_india.htm
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 12
  2. Prodigy17

    Prodigy17 FULL MEMBER

    Joined:
    Oct 31, 2008
    Messages:
    432
    Ratings:
    +0 / 92 / -0
    Congratulations to Mr Munshi for undertaking such outstanding project. I wish you had included a chapter written by Mr Ikram Sehagal in this book on how he was proved wrong in his thinking that lasting peace with India was possible for Pakistan through friendship. I regard him highly because of his analytical thinking amongst Pakistani defence contributors. He has openly acknowledged that he was wrong on thinking on the lines of friendship with India.
    Also, i heard him speak very high of Mr Munshi and his book under discussion. Can't wait to get my hands on his work which has so much significance for common Bangladeshis and Pakistanis to understand the regional situation. Congrats again sir.......
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 2
  3. TopCat

    TopCat ELITE MEMBER

    Joined:
    Nov 20, 2008
    Messages:
    11,269
    Ratings:
    +0 / 6,548 / -3
    Country:
    Bangladesh
    Location:
    Bangladesh
    Why not you put this book online??? Everybody will have a chance to look at it... If you need some help in hosting that.. I could put that in my server...
    Good Luck
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 4
  4. rubyjackass

    rubyjackass SENIOR MEMBER

    Joined:
    Nov 29, 2008
    Messages:
    3,623
    Ratings:
    +2 / 2,031 / -2
    Country:
    India
    Location:
    India
    Yeah!!!
    You could please do that.
    Atleast a free copy for me would be good.:what:
    I will review the book if I get one.
    Please consider this.
    Writing a book is one hell of a task.
    I must congratulate you on completing such a great project.
    Cheers!!!
     
  5. Al-zakir

    Al-zakir SENIOR MEMBER

    Joined:
    Nov 3, 2008
    Messages:
    7,407
    Ratings:
    +1 / 5,993 / -9
    Country:
    Bangladesh
    Location:
    United States
    congratulation Munshi Bhai. Keep up the good work.
     
  6. MBI Munshi

    MBI Munshi PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2007
    Messages:
    8,494
    Ratings:
    +5 / 5,015 / -0
    Country:
    United Kingdom
    Location:
    Bangladesh
    Thanks for all your kind comments. I think I will wait a awhile before putting the contents on the internet. However, the first edition is already on the internet and can be found on Bangladesh Strategic and Development Forum -

    Bangladesh Strategic & Development Forum

    There is also a bangla translation of the first edition but that is already sold out. Will try to get more printed soon.
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 2
  7. Goodperson

    Goodperson SENIOR MEMBER

    Joined:
    Dec 26, 2005
    Messages:
    2,860
    Ratings:
    +0 / 471 / -0
    India bashing looks like bread and butter for some. Why not write a book on development and positives of own country.
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 10
  8. ahmeddsid

    ahmeddsid SENIOR MEMBER

    Joined:
    Dec 23, 2008
    Messages:
    1,196
    Ratings:
    +0 / 361 / -0
    Good to see that someone is making fame bashing India in the country where Chunky Pandey was a sensation!
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 10
  9. MBI Munshi

    MBI Munshi PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2007
    Messages:
    8,494
    Ratings:
    +5 / 5,015 / -0
    Country:
    United Kingdom
    Location:
    Bangladesh
    Putting India in its place is a step towards development and progress for Bangladesh.
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 5
  10. leonblack08

    leonblack08 SENIOR MEMBER

    Joined:
    Dec 9, 2008
    Messages:
    2,529
    Ratings:
    +0 / 1,091 / -0
    Congratulations Mr.Munshi.
    It is good that we can read it from BDSDF.
     
    Last edited: Jan 4, 2009
  11. MBI Munshi

    MBI Munshi PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2007
    Messages:
    8,494
    Ratings:
    +5 / 5,015 / -0
    Country:
    United Kingdom
    Location:
    Bangladesh
    Thanks. You will find the first edition on BDSDF. The new edition is too big. Almost 640 pages.
     
  12. Vinod2070

    Vinod2070 BANNED

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2007
    Messages:
    10,553
    Ratings:
    +12 / 7,659 / -14
    Country:
    India
    Location:
    India
    Wrong thinking. Bangladesh can only develop in co-operation with India. There is no other way.

    Second, you are too small to even look at India much less putting it in it's place.

    I hope the new democratically elected government increases co-operation with India and takes strong action against all corrupt people.
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 2
  13. Raquib

    Raquib SENIOR MEMBER

    Joined:
    Mar 14, 2008
    Messages:
    895
    Ratings:
    +0 / 339 / -0
    thats never gonna happen...'cause co-operating with India in other words means being under India's command...that was one of the reasons Awami League was rejected by the people of Bangladesh in 2001 election...Now, Awami League came to power and I hope they wouldnt do it again...

    That is why Awami League has included a new promise to the people of Bangladesh...just read the high-lights...
    This was posted by idune on another thread...


    Here are some from list of things Awami league promised delivering, people will be counting…...no slip and sliding

    1) 10 taka retail price for per kg rice
    2) Free fertilizer for farmers
    3) Arrange Job for every able person
    4) No law against Islam and Islamic faith
    5) No sell out to India which include:
    No transit, transshipment
    No use of Bangladeshi territory by indian law enforcement or defense forces
    Not selling BD maritime economic zone by accepting indian equal distance
    formula.
    Not opening Bangladesh border and market further for indian export
    Not disabling or reducing Bangladesh military and defense capability
    according to indian prescription.
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 2
  14. Raquib

    Raquib SENIOR MEMBER

    Joined:
    Mar 14, 2008
    Messages:
    895
    Ratings:
    +0 / 339 / -0
    Congratulations Mr. Munshi...:enjoy::enjoy::enjoy:
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 1
  15. idune

    idune ELITE MEMBER

    Joined:
    Dec 14, 2008
    Messages:
    10,710
    Ratings:
    +4 / 9,027 / -8
    Country:
    Bangladesh
    Location:
    United States
    Your arrogant comments (as an indian) defining what Bangladesh can or Can not do, vindicate Mr Munshi’s book. That’s the arrogance and hegemonistic agenda we have been talking about and Mr. Munshi has so accurately exposed in his effort. As unfortunate as it is, most indians and indian policy makers holds same arrogance and hegemonistic agenda on Bangladesh.



    That’s what book is for, small person making big stride. More importantly make big impact by informing and educating large audience. Its good to see frustration and feeling of caught red handed written all over your face.

    We are all aware of master-client relationship between Awami league and India. Infect 2 hrs long indian high commission sermon on indian demands to Hasina has confirmed your wish.
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 10