Sever ties with India, Pakistan tells Afghanistan

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Oh ! thats why You Made Life of Afghanis like "Hell" by Supporting and Creating Taliban , Which you don't want in Pakistan ?????? ......

I think they recognized your "Brother" policy .

Afghan taliban have local support.. while TTP doesnt.. also does ur defination of brotherhood apply to srilanka and bangladesh aswell?

 

[INDIC]

Go read history and then come to me

Why exactly should we have done anything for charity specially fight a whole war ? The Afghans shouldn't have invited USSR into Afghanistan to fight against fellow Afghans and directly threatening us with their presence so close to our borders ... Pakistan was never interested in that sorry excuse for a country ever before , only when it invited the Soviets did we interfere by taking help of the same Afghans and providing them with weapons and training backed by the Americans and Saudis ... Funny , you kids , never mention them ?

USSR was just an excuse, America was invited by Pakistan 6 months before Soviet troops entered Afghanistan.

So, stop your bs claims that Pakistanis have done great charity work for Afghanistan when Pakistan was the greatest beneficiary of Soviet-America rivalry in Afghanistan.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Tell me , when was the time it was anything close to being stable ? When ?

Afghans have been fighting within themselves for the last 200 years ... Where do you the Muhajirs come here in between , kiddo ? The same old racism at work again , huh ?

Quote me examples from history where different ethnicities were at civil war in Afghanistan for last two hundred years?

 

[Secur]

So, stop your bs claims that Pakistanis have done great charity work for Afghanistan when Pakistan was the greatest beneficiary of Soviet-America rivalry in Afghanistan.

How childish of you , go read my post again ... Where do you see me mentioning that we did them some " charity " by helping them fight the Soviet war ? The same Afghans fought against the same ...

 

[INDIC]

Afghan taliban have local support.. while TTP doesnt.. also does ur defination of brotherhood apply to srilanka and bangladesh aswell?

If TTP don't have local support, why Pakistan army failed to tame them even with 5500 airstrikes in mere 4 years in FATA. Infact, infact TTP has fully utilized Pakistan government incompetence to solve problems of Pashtun people.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Afghanistans older twin brother.

Pakistan is 65 year old while Afghanistan is centuries old so Pakistan is younger brother.

 

[QMAN]

We have a pretty good idea of who needs whose help , thank you ...

Well if we are the only culprit in this whole thing , perhaps you should ask Kabul to not ask for our assistance and see if they can get the Taliban in the negotiations

I think today you need more negotiations with Taliban ! than Afghanistan .

 

[Secur]

Quote me examples from history where different ethnicities were at civil in Afghanistan for last two hundred years?

So , actually , civil war only started when the Soviets arrived , make yourself clear first ?

Tell me , who invited the Soviets and for what ?

Who took over from Daoud Khan and why ?

Why were the communists asking for help in the first place if they had local support ?

Why was Afghanistan always so lets say fuc-ked up ?

I think today you need more negotiations with Taliban ! than Afghanistan .

That is why except for North Waziristan , every single area is under our control , kid ...

Whilst except for Kabul , what even lies in Karzai's control , nobody knows

If TTP don't have local support, why Pakistan army failed to tame them even with 5500 airstrikes in mere 4 years in FATA.

We give full credit for that to the Indian consulates operating in Afghanistan hence the need to ask Mr Karzai to shut them otherwise maybe he wont even be able to escape from Kabul ...

One must check his recent statements

 

[INDIC]

How childish of you , go read my post again ... Where do you see me mentioning that we did them some " charity " by helping them fight the Soviet war ? The same Afghans fought against the same ...

Most of the Pakistanis claim the same thing of doing charity work for Afghans. Afghans had their priority for which they fought but Pakistan was the greatest beneficiary of all this mess in Afghanistan. Afghans spilled their blood and Pakistan counted the American or Arab aid and military assistence.

Thing only went bad for Pakistan with the recent rise of TTP.

 

[Secur]

Most of the Pakistanis claim the same thing of doing charity work for Afghans. Afghans had their priority for which they fought but Pakistan was the greatest beneficiary of all this mess in Afghanistan. Afghans spilled their blood and Pakistan counted the American or Arab aid and military assistence.

Thing only went bad for Pakistan with the recent rise of TTP.

Most of the Pakistanis claim charity of helping Afghan refugees ( till now ) later , not of the war itself ... Afghans had their priority , so did we ... How exactly did we benefit by destabilization in our neighborhood which mind you would have happened sooner or later even if we had not intervened ?

More than 40 000+ Pakistanis have lost their lives in this WOT , have some shame , kid ...

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

So , actually , civil war only started when the Soviets arrived , make yourself clear first ?

Tell me , who invited the Soviets and for what ?

Who took over from Daoud Khan and why ?

Why were the communists asking for help in the first place if they had local support ?

Why was Afghanistan always so lets say fuc-ked up ?



That is why except for North Waziristan , every single area is under our control , kid ...

Whilst except for Kabul , what even lies in Karzai's control , nobody knows



We give full credit for that to the Indian consulates operating in Afghanistan hence the need to ask Mr Karzai to shut them otherwise maybe he wont even be able to escape from Kabul ...

One must check his recent statements

You didnt give me examples from two year hundred years, i am waiting.
Our Pakistan experienced worst of bloody civil war just 25 years after its creation and lost its east wing .

 

[QMAN]

That is why except for North Waziristan , every single area is under our control , kid ...

Whilst except for Kabul , what even lies in Karzai's control , nobody knows

So Ghost of Taliban attack In Sindh , Karachi , Peshawar , Islamabad

you r still in dream , At least next 25 years US drone will be upon Afghanistan sponsored by Pakistan so In result Talibad will offer Return "Gift" for That to Pakistan.

look like first target of taliban today is Pakistan not Afghanistan

 

[INDIC]

give full credit for that to the Indian consulates operating in Afghanistan hence the need to ask Mr Karzai to shut them otherwise maybe he wont even be able to escape from Kabul ...

One must check his recent statements

What is the proof that India is supporting TTP? Like finding wine bottles or Bollywood cds in these areas. Bollywood cds are available in every corner of Pakistan just like aata-daal sold in the market place.

 

[Secur]

You didnt give me examples from two year hundred years, i am waiting.
Our Pakistan experienced worst of bloody civil war just 25 years after its creation and lost its east wing .

I am just thinking how many examples of civil war in Afghanistan should I indeed give when I cant even remember when was the last time it was even stable Can you tell me that ?

I know , but is that the point of discussion here , I do not think so ... No part of Afghanistan was thousands of miles away like us , unfortunately for you ...

What is the proof that India is supporting TTP?

Where is the proof for accusations you make even when your leaders sneeze , kid ?

I am sure the Pakistan Govt would have provided it to your Govt by now , Mr Hagel's statement came as a little surprise , didn't it ? Want me to get it for you ?

From the Americans , the Indians , love so much

 

[INDIC]

Most of the Pakistanis claim charity of helping Afghan refugees ( till now ) later , not of the war itself ... Afghans had their priority , so did we ... How exactly did we benefit by destabilization in our neighborhood which mind you would have happened sooner or later even if we had not intervened ?

More than 40 000+ Pakistanis have lost their lives in this WOT , have some shame , kid ...

You are forgetting you got more than 20 billion aid from America. Leaving aside the refugee crisis, Pakistan harvested lots of benefit except the rise of TTP.