What's new

Zero foreign investment till date in Modi’s smart cities mission

endyashainin

BANNED
Joined
Jul 9, 2015
Messages
614
Reaction score
-2
Country
United States
Location
United States
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com...modis-smart-cities-mission/article9061126.ece


Zero foreign investment till date in Modi’s smart cities mission

New Delhi, September 1:

Almost two years ago, the Narendra Modi government announced the 100 Smart Cities Mission to transform urban India. But, till date, not a single dollar has come in as foreign investment for the mission.

On an RTI query filed by BusinessLine on how much foreign funding Indian cities identified under this mission have garnered, the Ministry of Urban Development said that “no investment has been received”.

This is despite Urban Development Minister M Venkaiah Naidu’s visits abroad to attract investments, apart from talks with visiting foreign delegations here.

Moreover, on the size of foreign investment, which the government expects to receive under this mission, the RTI reply stated, “No study has been done by the Ministry of Urban Development in this regard.”

The Cabinet has approved ₹48,000 crore, that is ₹100 crore per city per year for five years for the mission. States have to match this amount and gather funds via public-private-partnership and convergence from other schemes.

“Foreign investment can’t flow just like that. It will come in the form of technology which is a difficult task. Municipalities and city leaders will need to come up with PPP projects where investors can come in after all approvals are in place. There is a deficit of such projects at the moment,” said Pratap Padode, Founder, Smart Cities Council India. The Council is a consortium of smart city practitioners and experts.

Naidu had visited the US in July and Berlin in May to attract investments for smart cities and other urban missions. Germany had earlier agreed to associate with Bhubaneswar, Kochi and Coimbatore through technical and financial assistance, a statement had said. In November 2014, a 35-member delegation went to the Smart City Congress in Barcelona, apart from Naidu visiting Singapore to pitch for investments.

Only two MoUs signed
While several countries have expressed keenness in the mission, only two MoUs have been signed till date. The US Trade and Development Agency (USTDA) inked an MoU for Vishakhapatnam, Allahabad and Ajmer, and the French Agency for Development signed a pact to assist Nagpur, Chandigarh and Oulgaret.

The USTDA on Thursday said few US firms and State government have begun to identify the planning and investments required to grow and modernise Visakhapatnam.

(This article was published on September 1, 2016)
 
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com...modis-smart-cities-mission/article9061126.ece


Zero foreign investment till date in Modi’s smart cities mission

New Delhi, September 1:

Almost two years ago, the Narendra Modi government announced the 100 Smart Cities Mission to transform urban India. But, till date, not a single dollar has come in as foreign investment for the mission.

On an RTI query filed by BusinessLine on how much foreign funding Indian cities identified under this mission have garnered, the Ministry of Urban Development said that “no investment has been received”.

This is despite Urban Development Minister M Venkaiah Naidu’s visits abroad to attract investments, apart from talks with visiting foreign delegations here.

Moreover, on the size of foreign investment, which the government expects to receive under this mission, the RTI reply stated, “No study has been done by the Ministry of Urban Development in this regard.”

The Cabinet has approved ₹48,000 crore, that is ₹100 crore per city per year for five years for the mission. States have to match this amount and gather funds via public-private-partnership and convergence from other schemes.

“Foreign investment can’t flow just like that. It will come in the form of technology which is a difficult task. Municipalities and city leaders will need to come up with PPP projects where investors can come in after all approvals are in place. There is a deficit of such projects at the moment,” said Pratap Padode, Founder, Smart Cities Council India. The Council is a consortium of smart city practitioners and experts.

Naidu had visited the US in July and Berlin in May to attract investments for smart cities and other urban missions. Germany had earlier agreed to associate with Bhubaneswar, Kochi and Coimbatore through technical and financial assistance, a statement had said. In November 2014, a 35-member delegation went to the Smart City Congress in Barcelona, apart from Naidu visiting Singapore to pitch for investments.

Only two MoUs signed
While several countries have expressed keenness in the mission, only two MoUs have been signed till date. The US Trade and Development Agency (USTDA) inked an MoU for Vishakhapatnam, Allahabad and Ajmer, and the French Agency for Development signed a pact to assist Nagpur, Chandigarh and Oulgaret.

The USTDA on Thursday said few US firms and State government have begun to identify the planning and investments required to grow and modernise Visakhapatnam.

(This article was published on September 1, 2016)
What about local investments? large housing projects in Pakistan often have land owners, industrialists etc pumping in money, look at Bahria Town as an example.
Rarer cases like Zulfiqarabad have foreign investments in them.
 
What about local investments? large housing projects in Pakistan often have land owners, industrialists etc pumping in money, look at Bahria Town as an example.
Rarer cases like Zulfiqarabad have foreign investments in them.


Modi wants SMART cities. India doesn't have the technology or the money to build these smart cities. India has to attract both foreign capital and technology. So far, nothing has gotten off the ground.
 
Modi wants SMART cities. India doesn't have the technology or the money to build these smart cities. India has to attract both foreign capital and technology. So far, nothing has gotten off the ground.
Best way to go ahead is to construct basic infrastructure ie: roads, pippipelines, sewer systems, signal boosters for network, then welcome local investors to make housing colonies, then welcome international investment in the cities, Rome wasn't built in a day.

BTW are there any conceptual layouts for a Smart City?.
 
Modi wants SMART cities. India doesn't have the technology or the money to build these smart cities. India has to attract both foreign capital and technology. So far, nothing has gotten off the ground.
I don't really know what is a smart city....
 
A smart city has a sewage system, I believe.
I think first a city has to have basic infra, then based on that a smart city can be built....

Do you think cashless payment powered by Alipay is one part of smart life in a smart city?
I can literally do that in my city.

In Guiyang, the capital of Southwest China's Guizhou Province, they are using big data in the process of policy making, interaction between administration and industries, efficient and automatic logistics, community building, eco-system maintenance, etc

This is an interesting interview....

From my perspective, I think smart city is about a way of life, a policy making process, smart energy consumption strategies, etc. All of them are underpinned by basic infra.
An expo in Guiyang
About how to plan a smart community using big data

Another one is coming
屏幕快照 2016-09-20 15.20.48.png
 
Modi wants SMART cities. India doesn't have the technology or the money to build these smart cities. India has to attract both foreign capital and technology. So far, nothing has gotten off the ground.

How about smart villages with latrines? I am sure India has the technology and money to do it. You do what you can afford to do in the first place instead of dreaming all day long and do nothing.
 
Last edited:
I don't really know what is a smart city....
http://smartcities.gov.in/ Visit the site and read the details :)

Best way to go ahead is to construct basic infrastructure ie: roads, pippipelines, sewer systems, signal boosters for network, then welcome local investors to make housing colonies, then welcome international investment in the cities, Rome wasn't built in a day.

BTW are there any conceptual layouts for a Smart City?.
Smart city in Gujrat is already in progress...
http://www.hindustantimes.com/india...rban-future/story-URBqED1wGFG09KAXq6S3VO.html
an_aerial_view_of_a_site_under_construction_at_the_gujarat_international_finance_tec-city_at_gandhinagar_in_gujarat_MOWR.jpg

gift-smart-city-rg_660_022415071756.jpg

Smart_city3.jpg
 
Having read it from start to end, dunno what kind of characteristics this commercial centre has.....
Having basic infra such as stable grid and pipeline does not make it smart....
By smart means :
1. 24x7 Uninterrupted Electricity
2. 24x7 uninterrupted High-speed broadband
3. 24x7 CCTV cameras
and other basic stuff like you said.
If these are implemented, then next steps will renewable electricity and other things
Currently we have cities which are not properly planned, thus resulting into congestion, traffic jams, and water-logging
P.S Modi is also interested in getting Hyperloop from Tesla. Till now nothing is concrete about that though.
 
Cities with such features can only be called as "Normal Cities". I see nothing smart here.
Not in India though. We don't have centralised data center city based, neither 24x7 monitoring system all over city
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom