Zakir Naik: Pakistan should not have been created

[SarthakGanguly]

Nehru played double game. Facade of secularism helped Hindu India retain many areas with majority non-hindus. British officials at that time were at bed with cunning Nehru/Hindus.

Ideally there should have been 7 Pakistans out of Hindustan.

even more drastic version of this map was needed. Nothing is lost yet, 180 million Indian muslims can make another Pakistan in coming decades or even 100 years from now.

Oh my God! That Rehmet Ali's fantasy again!!!

 

[MAS9]

Not Talking about BD you can keep it, I m talking about Hyderabad, Junagarh states and other areas.

We want Kashmir, let em have other states

 

[Kabira]

S

So today I got the root cause of problem. It is hatred Pak has for Hindu Bania. (They are currently running the worlds economy to counter them they are importing chinese)
in past I was of opinion that PAK army is the cancerous problem.

world economy? I meant baniya from Pakistan region is running Indian economy along with gujjus.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Not Talking about BD you can keep it, I m talking about Hyderabad, Junagarh states and other areas.

Why not all of India? Why not the whole world?

Sovereignty ONLY belongs to whom?

 

[MAS9]

Oh my God! That Rehmet Ali's fantasy again!!!

Time will tell

 

[Basel]

We want Kashmir, let em have other states

To have all Muslims of India Pakistan will require all it's occupied areas.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

We want Kashmir, let em have other states

Best part is that you can WANT anything. You can WANT everything. Only way you (or anyone) can get or has ever got is by might.

Have the strength to redraw borders. All these wasteful exercises will be unnecessary.

 

[Śakra]

Why? You want to turn all of Pakistan into a huge ethnic battlefield like Karachi? The best revenge India could give Pakistan is export another 30 million Muslims to Pakistan and watch how Pak would implode into a ethnic war and chaos. Send 100 million and Pak would suffer a catastrophic break up within months. That is a fact.

If the partition was properly done in 1947 we wouldn't see the tensions that exist currently. We would both be in a better place.

NOPE. Not one step more.

Too bad. If you're so inclined to live in the Himalayas Pandits can move to HP, UK, or the 7 sisters.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Before opening your mouth put ethnic mind set behind and put Pakistan first, and Google the map of occupied areas India have since 1947 which went with Pakistan, KPK is very small in size compared to those areas.

Okay. No idea which province you are from but you can take all 200 million Muslims in India but as far K-Pk they can stay out. While your at it why not take in Somali Muslims, Rohinga Muslims, Chadian Muslims, Nigerian Muslims. In fact you should take in any Muslims from anywhere if your are a good Muslim 'brother'. Unless you place Indian Muslims at higher level then (are they Allah's chosen) other Muslims.

Ps. I just made a perfunctory visit but think about what I said. You either think with your secular hat or religious hat. You can't fckin choose as you wish. If you think with the Muslim hat then you should let any Muslim from anywhere on earth - all Muslims are Muslims period. You can't play the Muslim card and then just discriminate against some Muslims but favour others. All are equal in Allah's eyes. All should e equal to your charity.

 

[waz]

This isn't a surprise. The vast majority of Indian Muslims think the same thing, I'd even say virtually all.
Anyway, it's his opinion.

 

[Kabira]

Oh my God! That Rehmet Ali's fantasy again!!!

Pakistan was fantasy before 1934

 

[Tea addict]

We, the majority of India, don't want anymore muslims in our country. Why would we want to purposely annex 500 million more of them?

Give them two more generations and they won't be like what they are today..you and @SarthakGanguly are just pessimists who think they will remain "non muslim haters" .

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Time will tell

Yes, our civilization may very well become extinct. Chances are still there that we end up as the Copts, the Yazidis, the Anatolians, Greeks, Persians etc.

Give them two more generations and they won't be like what they are today..you and @SarthakGanguly are just pessimists who think they will remain "non muslim haters" .

I am a realist. Even an optimist.

The hatred (that is not the right word here) is rooted in faith. Greater the education, greater the 'hate'. We see that already.

 

[Basel]

If the partition was properly done in 1947 we wouldn't see the tensions that exist currently. We would both be in a better place.



Too bad. If you're so inclined to live in the Himalayas Pandits can move to HP, UK, or the 7 sisters.

Basically British created fault lines to use it in future, you are right, if partition was done properly then there would have been no hostility and wars between India and Pakistan and it would have been prosperous for both.

 

[MAS9]

Yes, our civilization may very well become extinct. Chances are still there that we end up as the Copts, the Yazidis, the Anatolians, Greeks, Persians etc.

We never justify those barbaric acts.

Though I highly doubt Hinduism will grow as fast as Islam