ہے خاکِ فلسطیں پہ یہودی کا اگر حق ہسپانیہ پر حق نہیں کیوں اہلِ عَرب کا

[Chughtai Khan]

ہے خاکِ فلسطیں پہ یہودی کا اگر حق
ہسپانیہ پر حق نہیں کیوں اہلِ عَرب کا

 

[Imran Khan]

عربیوں سے پوچھ لیں انہوں نے ہی دھندہ شروع کیا تھا ۔

 

[Chughtai Khan]

If you understand the context intended, you can replace اہل عرب as Muslims being the custodians of المُلک للّہ & the flag of توحید. Before competing with them in any field, you'd have to come out of these internal rifts, whatever they may be.

عربیوں سے پوچھ لیں انہوں نے ہی دھندہ شروع کیا تھا ۔

 

[Imran Khan]

If you understand the context intended, you can replace اہل عرب as Muslims being the custodians of المُلک للّہ & the flag of توحید. Before competing with them in any field, you'd have to come out of these internal rifts, whatever they may be.

no need to do it as arabs are one identity and Muslim are many identities . there is no requirement that a Muslim must be arab . anyone can be a muslim . this poetry is for arabs not Muslims .

 

[Chughtai Khan]

Iqbal never intended it to highlight discord between اہل عرب & Non-Arab Muslims, which comes in mind today because of Arab world's blind eyes towards oppression anywhere in the world, let alone Palestine. The very crux of the poem is taunting the Britishers & French for occupation of Palestine & Aleppo. اہل عرب is mentioned just to refer to the Muslim residents of Jerusalem, while Iqbal is defending that if Jews claim their right on Jerusalem as their ancestral homeland, then اہل عرب are rightful owners of Hispania, being the land of their forefathers!

While defending our causes, we must not highlight the division among ourselves, rather defend them as a unanimous front!

no need to do it as arabs are one identity and Muslim are many identities . there is no requirement that a Muslim must be arab . anyone can be a muslim . this poetry is for arabs not Muslims .

 

[Imran Khan]

Iqbal never intended it to highlight discord between اہل عرب & Non-Arab Muslims, which comes in mind today because of Arab world's blind eyes towards oppression anywhere in the world, let alone Palestine. The very crux of the poem is taunting the Britishers & French for occupation of Palestine & Aleppo. اہل عرب is mentioned just to refer to the Muslim residents of Jerusalem, while Iqbal is defending that if Jews claim their right on Jerusalem as their ancestral homeland, then اہل عرب are rightful owners of Hispania, being the land of their forefathers!

While defending our causes, we must not highlight the division among ourselves, rather defend them as a unanimous front!

and what make you think pelastinans are different then other arabs ? if there was oil and pelastine was rich as Kuwait and UAE they have been treating non arabs like kuwait and UAE too . ohhh lets have one example as pelastine herself face occupation and suppress pain violence what are thier views for kashmir sir ?

 

[Chughtai Khan]

and what make you think pelastinans are different then other arabs ? if there was oil and pelastine was rich as Kuwait and UAE they have been treating non arabs like kuwait and UAE too . ohhh lets have one example as pelastine herself face occupation and suppress pain violence what are thier views for kashmir sir ?

You're twisting it again highlighting the internal discord & division, where unity is needed. I don't defend the mighty Arab giants being silent against oppression & doing literally nothing for the Islamic cause.
But the fact remains that the Unity of Muhammadans is the need of hour!

And while defending our causes, there must be No idols of Arabs, Turks, Iranis or Pakistanis etc.

 

[Imran Khan]

n

You're twisting it again highlighting the internal discord & division, where unity is needed. I don't defend the mighty Arab giants being silent against oppression & doing literally nothing for the Islamic cause.
But the fact remains that the Unity of Muhammadans is the need of hour!

And while defending our causes, there must be No idols of Arabs, Turks, Iranis or Pakistanis etc.

o sir i just asked simple question WHAT ARE VIEWS FOR KASHMIR IN PELSTINE .

 

[X-ray Papa]

n

o sir i just asked simple question WHAT ARE VIEWS FOR KASHMIR IN PELSTINE .

Whats your view for rohingyas in burma?

 

[X-ray Papa]

they can go to hell

In that case, China is your only friend.

 

[Chughtai Khan]

n

o sir i just asked simple question WHAT ARE VIEWS FOR KASHMIR IN PELSTINE .

What one Muslim should have for another in oppression! With huge Indian support to Israeli apartheid & oppressive regime, the Palestinians would surely support Kashmiri Freedom Struggle.

 

[Imran Khan]

In that case, China is your only friend.

we both have common interests . there is no friend of pakistan . countries are not humans they don't have friends wives brothers sisters mother in law .

What one Muslim should have for another in oppression! With huge Indian support to Israeli apartheid & oppressive regime, the Palestinians would surely support Kashmiri Freedom Struggle.

with huge support to india by pelastine

 

[X-ray Papa]

we both have common interests . there is no friend of pakistan . countries are not humans they don't have friends wives brothers sisters mother in law .

Thats what i meant, other than china, there's no country that is willing to support pakistan interest.

 

[Chughtai Khan]

Geostrategic alliances of countries have nothing to do with religious ideologies and has everything to do with common national interests!

 

[El Sidd]

they can go to hell

That may mean your hometown. The tribal mindset of yours at display is evidence enough as to why South Punjab has not seen any significant human development in 2000 years.