Will new consitutional solve our problems?

[Hyde]

2/3 majority in KPK, 40-50% seats in central punjab with decreasing trend if PMLN govt performs (at the back of moementum they have with large reserves/export growth & spending), south punjab electables will wait & see, balochistan people will vote as usuall for their electables, sindh is lost cause

PMLN-PPPP will yet again form a colaition govt(as i predicted in 2018, i was wrong simply because JTK came into the picture & elite forced PPP/PMLN not to do so because of grantees given to elite by JTK and aleem khan)

Now PTI may loosw KPK as well if JUI insists it wants KPK
But that will cause alot of instability so i doubt it will be acceotable to elite

However if khan is going to cause trouble then his party will be banned he will be killed off and KPK will be handed over to JUI

Dont blame the elite herw..they are doing this because of support of middle class who prefer short term relief instead of the future of their kids or grand kids

Slave mentality is what will keep the elite and what has kept the british for 200 years and then the elite prospering

I see Karachi and Hyderabad voting for PTI

And interior Sindh will be PPP with solid competition from PTI

Balochistan will vote as usual, but PTI will grab more than 2 seats this time around

PTI is very popular in KPK and Punjab right now, and PML-N will face a setback. Overall, PTI may still not form the government as they will be short of majority but I have no doubt in my mind that they will come out as the single largest the party once again.

The serious setback will be for PML-N and MQM whereas JUI-F and ANP will gain extra seats reducing the number of seats for PTI from KPK

@Topic

Let's stick with the existing system and try to improve on that. The only change I would like to see is if the difference between single largest party and the second largest party is bigger than 20% then in case the largest party is ousted with VONC then fresh elections should be automatically triggered.

 

[Mentee]

There is no way he can penetrate die hard supporters of PMLN in central punjab
I have been saying that in this forum since 2011(we voted for him in 2013 )

Sure he has some following and was able to get 30 seats in central punjab but 30% dont win you govts..70% does ..
JTK was able to collect free candidates ans turn PTI into majority oarty post 2018 elections but that doesnt change the fact that oeginally PMLN clean sweeped central punjab in 2018

Interior sindh and balochistan didn't even bother giving a second look to pti , sigh !

 

[Falconless]

Here are my suggestions for corrections needed

1. Federal cabinet can appoint ministers from outside Parliament after they are vetted by a senate committee.

2. All the civil services are federalised to make resource allocation easier

3. Rangers,FC,FIA, ASF, Islamabad Police and ANF are reorganised into a Pakistan Federal Constabulary and Pakistan Border Force (Rangers)

4. Constitutional duties of provinces are defined and if they fail on them the Federal Government takes direct control (UK Devolution model)

5. President is given the power to dissolve Parliament, put judges on trial and appoint services chiefs.

6. Environmental Protection, Tax collection, water allocation, agricultural policies are moved back to the federal government.

7. Municipal governments are guaranteed by the constitution.

 

[Olympus81]

Control the corrupt politicians, generals and judges.

Half of the problems will be solved. Systems don’t matter, end of the day people run it.

And go for Local Government rather than focusing too much on provincial government.

 

[OldenWisdom...قول بزرگ]

Constitution is but an outline... A marker of outlook, aspirations of people, bonds amongst them... taking cue from their own history, narrative, precedence, esteemed and established best practices their common cause and finally their direction.

It is learned and learning, on native discourse and deliberations.
And most importantly it need not be a written outline.
But there is a disconnect.

Pakistan has no such discourse, no narrative and no precedence. It is not an evolving process, nor system.

It was an established system and order handed down, lock stock and barrel. Even it's current laws and legislation are hand me down...
So, it will never self correct or reorient...
Instead it recoils, as designed, when it feels threatened... and threatened it feels because it is alien, an imposition on people it is foisted upon ...
Pakistanis will feel the real brunt and vengefulness of this structure as it feels threatened and recoils even further. It is not for, of or by the people... which is why even a grand majority put together cannot replace it with one more a reflection of it's people, nature and aspirations. To and off their Faith...

So, try you must as failure isn't really an option.
They'll throw fits and tantrums, hiss and frown... more they do, truer you are!

 

[Super Falcon]

With new politicians only
But we don't have genius minds to create new constitution

Our nation believe in short term short sightness running only we are not serious passion required which we don't have