What's new

Why the failure of Nirbhay is bad news for India

Rangila

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
2,211
Reaction score
-2
Country
Venezuela, Bolivarian Republic Of
Location
Argentina
It is common knowledge now that India's long-range cruise missile Nirbhay had to be aborted and the missile destroyed midair in accordance with range safety rules last Friday.


The literal reason the flight had to be aborted was due to the failure of its guidance system developed by Research Centre Imarat (RCI) at Hyderabad. The missile had traveled a distance of 128-km but could not take the required turn at the waypoint and instead nose-dived. It was then put on the self-destruct mode. The failure analysis is underway. Missile guidance control law especially the one used in Nirbhay (Deviated Pursuit Technique) is one of the most complex technologies to master.


This failure will push the missile's operational clearance every further.



The land-attack cruise missile has been under development for a decade now and is designed to be launched from air, land or sea. It has a top speed of Mach 0.7 and is configured to fly at low altitudes to avoid enemy radar detection, and also has “loitering capabilities” to identify battlefield targets.

The third failed test is particularly bad news for India’s INS Arihant. The indigenous SSBN was scheduled to test-fire the Nirbhay this month, but it is unclear whether the test will proceed now. The setback is critical to the success of India able to field a weapon which has extended range.

The other weapons being developed with a similar role, though not a cruise missile, is the K-15 Sagarika (K-Series of Missiles) Submarine Launched Ballistic Missile (SLBM) with a range of around 700 km. This would mean that a vessel has to move in closer to enemy shores making it vulnerable to detection and possible attack.

The second weapon in the strategic K series of SLBM's is the K-4 which has a range of 3,000 km. The twelfth and final development trial of the missile missile was tested from a pontoon submerged 30 feet deep in January 2013. Once operational, this SLBM will form a crucial leg of India’s nuclear triad, and also the most credible and hardest to detect. The longer range K-4 will complement the shorter range K-15.

Nirbhay’s with a range of over a 1,000 kilometers makes it a more suitable weapon for the INS Arihant, and stealth being the fundamental attribution to an SSBN will then not be compromised. In other words, Nirbhay gives the submarine enough standoff distance to fire while remaining hidden deep in the Indian Ocean, or within territorial waters.

Therefore, the success of Nirbhay as one among the nuclear delivery systems will give a significant boost in the completion of India's objective to complete an effective Nuclear Triad deterrence. It is worthy to note, that the purpose of having a three-branched nuclear capability is to significantly reduce the possibility that an enemy could destroy all of a nation's nuclear forces in a first-strike attack; this, in turn, ensures a credible threat of a second strike, and thus increases a nation's nuclear deterrence.
 
After the highly successful second test, the failure once again is a dismal news. We need to work hard to complete the development of this missile and operationalized it. This is a potent weapon and shall add more teeth to our arsenal.
 
After the highly successful second test, the failure once again is a dismal news. We need to work hard to complete the development of this missile and operationalized it. This is a potent weapon and shall add more teeth to our arsenal.


Forget what hurt you, but never forget what it "taught" you.
 
Feelings hurt vs Knowledge gained.
What is beneficial?

All my life I have learnt from my mistakes. Thats why I am where I am today.
Turn your wounds into wisdom.


Or ask Uncle Sam to give you a Tomahawk cruise missile to copy---just like they donated 4 of them to Pakistan----that can also help and expedite things.
 
Excessive pessimism. Its a developmental test. They tried something new so failure was a possibility. Its comforting for common masses when their states lie to them, I am more comfortable with transparency.

Any respectable country has had multiple failures with guidance development for cruise missiles. When I say respectable I only mean I respect countries that consider their people worthy of the truth.
 
The giver knoweth best!

Lot of difference between an organ donor and an orgasm donor.
Isn't it that you receive an organ with your legs down and an orgasm WITH YOUR LEGS UP?????Sorry could not resist. On a serious note this is a failure and these things happen. i would not worry too much and keep trying. It might be a minor component or something very trivial as it seems that the first test was successful.
A
 
Well, that's what developmental trials are for. This is a mission critical missile, you cant import your way out of this one. No one will give you a 1000+km cruise missile, that's nuclear capable. This will be armed to every branch of the military and the land attack capability of every major frigate and destroyer in the IN and also future subs. Better luck to the scientist.
 
Or ask Uncle Sam to give you a Tomahawk cruise missile to copy---just like they donated 4 of them to Pakistan----that can also help and expedite things.

We know that US is is so kind to you...But we are not pakistan or china.
 
then ask mama bear to give it to you .. just like brahmos a.k.a p-800 oniks.. :cheers:

ohhh... AID base guy...In the same time we are not beggar ...??...Try to find more information more about Brahmos.
 
Feelings hurt vs Knowledge gained.
What is beneficial?

All my life I have learnt from my mistakes. Thats why I am where I am today.
Turn your wounds into wisdom.

Well said.
 
Back
Top Bottom