What's new

Why Peshawar attack drew more outrage over Assam

Because Peshwar attack was done by Muslims, the Western mainstream media don't post about other terrorist acts but those committed by the Muslims. If those people were killed by any Islamist groups, there would be plenty of condemning from Western media, there would be hash tags on Twitter, Obama would make a speech of how it was inhumane and must be dealt with an iron fist.

I wish that was not the case, but sadly this is the truth. It seems Indian media itself is not much interested in the story.

We are talking about Indians. Indians felt more bad than Pakistanis it seems. There were condolences messages on every electronic and social media stating how those terrorists could kill those cute and fair children.


Yes who were killed by Christian Bodo terrorists.

Btw I am going to post a thread on real religious demographics of India. Do post in there.
In Tharparkar, Sindh over 300 infants and young children lost their lives. So is it any less of a tragedy than Peshawar, NO. In both cases we are loosing young children, but it seems Pakistanis were more moved by the violent barbaric attack, as compared to steady rise in casualties in Tharparkar. Human mind works in weird way, the sheer scale of tragedies might not be enough to move us, may be the Pakistani society at large feels more connected to children in Peshawar, than those in Tharparkar.
Same might be the case for Indian society.

I am not much familiar with the insurgency in that part of India, but haven't this been going on for sometime now. But it seems as it turned communal or was it always communal. I do remember reading sometime ago about local tribals grievances with the mining industry and federal government for destroying their live hoods.


82 as of today. Unofficialy 150+!
Sad.
Our private media is very insensitive and TRP centric. Money comes before ethics for them.

Media is a business, and like every business it is driven by profits. Plus the media might want to play down on the importance of this attack to not shed any negative light at India. In any case it is doing great disservice to Indian society. Stop putting too much faith in these jokers.
 
. .
Media does not cover, tribals you know. Their status falls down, they will cover only rich chaps. Idiots! Plus there could be some govt. policy to keep it low profile due to sensitive modus operandi of security forces.
In a democracy its not acceptable. When the news is out, whats there to keep low profile? In India over 20,000 rapes are reported but our media highlights only 2-3 cases occurring in metro cities. The matters are such that if you try to bring such matters to the fore, you will be branded anti social and what not.
 
.
In a democracy its not acceptable. When the news is out, whats there to keep low profile? In India over 20,000 rapes are reported but our media highlights only 2-3 cases occurring in metro cities. The matters are such that if you try to bring such matters to the fore, you will be branded anti social and what not.

Well, that is due to when Media is give extra leverage over news to TRP and extra freedom, then this is ought to happen.
 
.
Because Peshwar attack was done by Muslims, the Western mainstream media don't post about other terrorist acts but those committed by the Muslims. If those people were killed by any Islamist groups, there would be plenty of condemning from Western media, there would be hash tags on Twitter, Obama would make a speech of how it was inhumane and must be dealt with an iron fist.

in Peshwar attack victims are also Muslims.
 
. .
One question...
Why are such activities kept low profile?
I rarely ever hear news regarding terrorist in india except for your western borders in blame games...
 
.
Simply put,for most Indians,the bodo attacks occurred in the distant frontiers of India,the colonies of India that are not really Indian in their world view.The people aren't really fully Indian or not "upmarket" or good enough to fit into the mainstream of Indian society.So apart from the formalities of "RIP" or expressing supposed outrage,it didn't matter much to most of "Proper India" or "true Indians".Assam and the rest of Indian colonies are akin to Andaman and nicobar Islands and lakshadweep,too distant and inferior to be bothered with or cared for.Except for reminding and demonstrating their hold over them.
These tribals (adivasis) were savages anyway,killing and eating each other all the time.So why bother with them?Do the bare formalities and be done with it.

While the Peshawar attacks occurred to a people and in a place seen as renegade parts of "proper India",misguided family to be guided back.These pakistani kids were upmarket and real subcontinentals to deserve the reaction they got

Floods in kashmir inspire national spotlight with big shot movie stars organising solidarity fundraisers for kashmir.Floods in Assam?Same bare minimum formalities dear.No more,these savage colonies deserve no more,while the crown of J&K must be pampered and by extension the Pakistanis,for they are more Indian than these colonies and the savage natives.
 
.
WTF IS THIS ? Dick measuring contest . forget foreign media our own mainstream media hardly give any importance to NE and other far from delhi related news.
 
.
-No Kailash Sathyarthi saying take me hostage and spare the kids.
-No Malala condemning the killing of children -No hashtags like the ones we had seen during the Peshawar attack -Headlines which state outrage in Assam and not outrage in India.
-No candle light marches outside the India Gate
-No SMS campaigns on television seeking support for the victims Irony: Peshawar attack vs Assam attack

All this despite the death count in Assam shooting up to 82 of which 23 were women and 18 very innocent children whose lives were cut off even before they could even understand what this world is about. Were the victims not high profile:

The Peshawar attack was no doubt a horrific one and while we must completely condemn the killings in all possible ways, one must also not forget that what happened in Assam was nothing short of barbaric. The problem is that the victims were Advasis who do not fit the definition of the up market people. Does this incident not hurt the conscience of the so-called conscience keepers of the nation who are outraged?
Irony: Peshawar attack vs Assam attack When the Peshwar attack is took place, there were scores of hashtags supporting the victims and families. While there is no harm in raising ones' voice against meaningless violence a though ought to be spared for the children who lost their lives in Assam as well. they were as innocent as those kids in Peshawar.


More outrage during the exodus:
When there was a massive exodus two years back when students left various cities to return home there was such a major outrage across the nation. People came out in the open expressing solidarity and there were several debates condemning those who were rumour mongering in a bid to scare away these people. While every incident attempting to terrorise people needs to be condemned in a big way the idea is not to be selective while doing so. Cause is fine, but why kill? There are various explanations that have been given and the reasons explained for this attack. However under no circumstance can violence be justified whether it is killing a man, woman or child. The allegation against the tribals by the militants is that they had been supporting the security forces and hence this was one of the reasons for the attack-the other one being it was revenge. However this attack was more to demonstrate the strength of the organization which was dwindling in numbers.

An outfit which started off with 3500 people has just around 400 today. Moreover there was a new set of cadres who had come back from Myanmar after training. The intelligence says that they had to show their capability and ensure that terror is spread. Only by spreading terror can are such forces relevant. State has failed, centre needs to act: The Union Government has decided to take up this issue very seriously. It is clear that the state government has failed and even when concentrating its own security, it did so in expected areas.

Since yesterday the Assam police have been saying that they had focused on the Muslim dominated areas instead and there was hardly any presence of security personnel in the tribal belts that were hit. For the union government it is big a challenge ahead and it needs to bring all the groups under one roof and get them to talk before finding a lasting solution to the problem. The home minister will visit Assam which is under red alert and take stock of the situation before returning and discussing the issue with the Prime Minister and the National Security Advisor.
@oye_natta

Why Peshawar attack drew more outrage over Assam - Oneindia
Well that is also shocking bollywood has also become deaf and dumb on this. Indian media is more busy on J&K elections than Assam quite strange ?
 
.
Simply put,for most Indians,the bodo attacks occurred in the distant frontiers of India,the colonies of India that are not really Indian in their world view.The people aren't really fully Indian or not "upmarket" or good enough to fit into the mainstream of Indian society.So apart from the formalities of "RIP" or expressing supposed outrage,it didn't matter much to most of "Proper India" or "true Indians".Assam and the rest of Indian colonies are akin to Andaman and nicobar Islands and lakshadweep,too distant and inferior to be bothered with or cared for.Except for reminding and demonstrating their hold over them.
These tribals (adivasis) were savages anyway,killing and eating each other all the time.So why bother with them?Do the bare formalities and be done with it.

While the Peshawar attacks occurred to a people and in a place seen as renegade parts of "proper India",misguided family to be guided back.These pakistani kids were upmarket and real subcontinentals to deserve the reaction they got

Floods in kashmir inspire national spotlight with big shot movie stars organising solidarity fundraisers for kashmir.Floods in Assam?Same bare minimum formalities dear.No more,these savage colonies deserve no more,while the crown of J&K must be pampered and by extension the Pakistanis,for they are more Indian than these colonies and the savage natives.
While I agree with the sentiments, its a bit extreme view.
 
.
We are talking about Indians. Indians felt more bad than Pakistanis it seems. There were condolences messages on every electronic and social media stating how those terrorists could kill those cute and fair children.


Yes who were killed by Christian Bodo terrorists.

Btw I am going to post a thread on real religious demographics of India. Do post in there.

That's what you like to tell yourself. Besides, how on earth can you even use the social media as a metric to compare condemnations between nations? That's just so sick. The vast majority of 180 million Pakistanis actually condemned the Peshawar attack. Get your facts right and stop turning this into some sort of contest.
 
.
While I agree with the sentiments, its a bit extreme view.
Extreme?nah!!I have put it down far too polished and softly.Any more and it would be PC(in India's case 'national integrity' bullshit) and irrelevant.
 
.
In a democracy its not acceptable. When the news is out, whats there to keep low profile? In India over 20,000 rapes are reported but our media highlights only 2-3 cases occurring in metro cities. The matters are such that if you try to bring such matters to the fore, you will be branded anti social and what not.

WTF IS THIS ? Dick measuring contest . forget foreign media our own mainstream media hardly give any importance to NE and other far from delhi related news.

Well that is also shocking bollywood has also become deaf and dumb on this. Indian media is more busy on J&K elections than Assam quite strange ?

India media isn't a sovereign entity.

Baptist Church Funds CNN IBN.Gospel of Charity Funds NDTV.Christian Council Funds TIMES.Joshua Society Funds The Hindu.
 
.
Situations were different .Peshawar attack was in live stream.Entire medias was there for scrutinizing each aspects.
In India you can find that same media history during 26/11 Mumbai attacks.
Our irresponsible media just aired entire thing including NSG ops.In turn entire world was watched it may be several times than that of the Peshawatr attack
Here in Assam attack was started after
6 pm in a remote area even Govt couldnt findout the real casuality.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom