What's new

Why China-specific mountain strike corps has been downsized? Cong asks Modi govt

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
Why China-specific mountain strike corps has been downsized? Cong asks Modi govt
PublishedMay 16, 2015|Byadmin
SOURCE : TNN

22sd2.jpg


Congress on Thursday asked Modi government to answer why the China-specific “mountain strike corps” of Army has been slashed by half ahead of Prime Minister’s visit to Beijing.

Three weeks ago, defence ministry decided to downsize the 90,000-strong army force that was announced by UPA to act as a counter to the expanding Chinese military capabilities and intrusions. It was to be raised over seven years at a budget of Rs 64,478 crore. Now, the force would have 35,000 soldiers and the cut has been attributed to “severe fund shortage”.

“Congress wants to know if the country’s defence preparedness will be compromised by this decision and whether there is a shifting of goalpost on this key strategic issue?” AICC spokesman Randeep Surjewala asked.

With PM Modi on his first trip to China, Surjewala said Congress stands for good relations with neighbours based on “equality, protection of mutual national interests and innate belief in the principles of co-existence”.

Urging Modi to address the fundamentals during his stay in Beijing, Surjewala reminded that China has committed over $46 billion of investment in Pakistan including Azad Kashmir. “Does it not interfere with India’s sovereign claim over the territory and whether it amounts to balancing out India in geo-political arena?” he said.

The Congress spokesman wondered why BJP chief Amit Shah cancelled his scheduled meeting with Dalai Lama ahead of Modi’s visit.

Surjewala said “stapled visas” continue to rile India, recalling that minister of state Kiren Rijiju, who hails from Arunachal Pradesh, was asked to not attend the banquet hosted by PM Modi for the visiting Chinese President last year. He added that on the day Modi arrived in China, media reports there showed maps with Arunachal and Aksai Chin as Chinese territory. “Will the PM take up the issue strongly with the Chinese leadership?” he asked.

He urged PM Modi to take up with his hosts the Indian concerns about multiple dams being constructed on Brahmaputra river in China, Chinese intrusions in India, trade imbalance and market access for Indian pharma and IT sectors.

Congress said the PM appears determined to finalize $10 billion of Chinese investment for mega industrial parks and the home ministry has reduced the deadline for security clearances from 90 days to 30 days. “Government should tell the people if security clearances are not being compromised with,” Surjewala asked.
 
I am quite critical to further increase the numbers in the IA... The current infantry divisions are already not equipped as they should be for the 21st century.
As I stated in previous thread that we should transfer 50,000 soldiers in marine corps under navy & reduce IA size to 1 million, which would give IA some breathing space in CAPEX, officers no. etc.
Currently IA get 53 % share of defence budget which mostly goes in Salary , administrative & operational expenses.
1 million armed to teeth army is lot better than 1.3 million army equipped with WW2 era gadgets.
 
This number game doesn't matter as much in 5-10 years scale considering that army platoons and divisions are grown in phases and war games practiced to hammer out the tactical changes needed to army organization vis-a-vi doctrines.

Considering that in coming 10 years india will have a 35000 strong lean and agile force in the form of 3rd strike corps, other parallel modernization projects running elsewhere in army would considerably free up manpower. These officer positions can be gradually shifted to the strike corps and the govt gets to control the operational costs of the process under control.
 
China gave Modi an order so Modi followed it. We just buy out Indian politicians. Just like MMS before.
 
Why China-specific mountain strike corps has been downsized? Cong asks Modi govt
PublishedMay 16, 2015|Byadmin
SOURCE : TNN

22sd2.jpg


Congress on Thursday asked Modi government to answer why the China-specific “mountain strike corps” of Army has been slashed by half ahead of Prime Minister’s visit to Beijing.

Three weeks ago, defence ministry decided to downsize the 90,000-strong army force that was announced by UPA to act as a counter to the expanding Chinese military capabilities and intrusions. It was to be raised over seven years at a budget of Rs 64,478 crore. Now, the force would have 35,000 soldiers and the cut has been attributed to “severe fund shortage”.

“Congress wants to know if the country’s defence preparedness will be compromised by this decision and whether there is a shifting of goalpost on this key strategic issue?” AICC spokesman Randeep Surjewala asked.

With PM Modi on his first trip to China, Surjewala said Congress stands for good relations with neighbours based on “equality, protection of mutual national interests and innate belief in the principles of co-existence”.

Urging Modi to address the fundamentals during his stay in Beijing, Surjewala reminded that China has committed over $46 billion of investment in Pakistan including Azad Kashmir. “Does it not interfere with India’s sovereign claim over the territory and whether it amounts to balancing out India in geo-political arena?” he said.

The Congress spokesman wondered why BJP chief Amit Shah cancelled his scheduled meeting with Dalai Lama ahead of Modi’s visit.

Surjewala said “stapled visas” continue to rile India, recalling that minister of state Kiren Rijiju, who hails from Arunachal Pradesh, was asked to not attend the banquet hosted by PM Modi for the visiting Chinese President last year. He added that on the day Modi arrived in China, media reports there showed maps with Arunachal and Aksai Chin as Chinese territory. “Will the PM take up the issue strongly with the Chinese leadership?” he asked.

He urged PM Modi to take up with his hosts the Indian concerns about multiple dams being constructed on Brahmaputra river in China, Chinese intrusions in India, trade imbalance and market access for Indian pharma and IT sectors.

Congress said the PM appears determined to finalize $10 billion of Chinese investment for mega industrial parks and the home ministry has reduced the deadline for security clearances from 90 days to 30 days. “Government should tell the people if security clearances are not being compromised with,” Surjewala asked.
Because the UPA cleared an absurdly large force with ZERO planning or roadmap to fund and equip this force. They went for the headline "GoI clears MSC" but did not stipulate how such a force could be properly implemented.


The new GoI is simply un-f*cking the situation. 35,000 well equipped mountain warriors armed with M777, backed by Ch-47Fs, C-130Js, LCHs,Ah-64Es and C-17s is a mean mean force.


Bloody politicians.
 
Because the UPA cleared an absurdly large force with ZERO planning or roadmap to fund and equip this force. They went for the headline "GoI clears MSC" but did not stipulate how such a force could be properly implemented.


The new GoI is simply un-f*cking the situation. 35,000 well equipped mountain warriors armed with M777, backed by Ch-47Fs, C-130Js, LCHs,Ah-64Es and C-17s is a mean mean force.


Bloody politicians.
SSB and BSF could act as Light Infantry forces as a Stopgap.
 
New equipment and infrastructure is fare more important than more troops. More troops will not bring new capabilities with them.

The army has suffered horribly under 10 years of the Congress being in power. The congress sat on the following:

New rifles
New body Armour
Spike ATGM (Modi did this)
new light helos (Modi did this)
M777 (Modi did this)
Apache
Chinook
IFV
and the list goes on.

All this talk about Modi not getting things done is complete BS. In defense he is getting more done in 1 years than the congress did in the last 5 -10 years.
 
New equipment and infrastructure is fare more important than more troops. More troops will not bring new capabilities with them.

The army has suffered horribly under 10 years of the Congress being in power. The congress sat on the following:

New rifles
New body Armour
Spike ATGM (Modi did this)
new light helos (Modi did this)
M777 (Modi did this)
Apache
Chinook
IFV
and the list goes on.

All this talk about Modi not getting things done is complete BS. In defense he is getting more done in 1 years than the congress did in the last 5 -10 years.
Add in OROP (new GoI said will be done in a few weeks/months), a national war memorial (this alone should be enough to shame the Congress- 10 years and they did NOTHING on this, NOTHING- words cannot express what a sickening act of ineptitude this was) 3 new tri-service commands that the UPA sat on for 5 years, FICV etc etc
 
well what is the threat assessment there? for instance i know that there are "incursion" problem, but that's not something you solve with a strike corps, thats more for border patrol, so if the threat of actual conflict in the short to medium term is low then the money might be better spent on the navy or the economy. china did this in the 80s as the soviet threat waned and relations with the west waxed, it spend all it had on the economy.
 
Three weeks ago, defence ministry decided to downsize the 90,000-strong army force that was announced by UPA to act as a counter to the expanding Chinese military capabilities and intrusions. It was to be raised over seven years at a budget of Rs 64,478 crore.

Now, the force would have 35,000 soldiers and the cut has been attributed to “severe fund shortage”.

What is the deal with this "severe shortage of funds"?
 
What will they do there without proper equipment and gear? Wrestle?
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Military Forum Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom