What to do with Taliban

[Rain]

To terminate the evil! kill their idealogical mothers. like the pro taliban mulla, JI JUI and SSA. I am surprised to see al those who support talibans like JI and ASSP and their affiliates enjoying great fredom of movement, propaganda and fund raising.

It is time to start fight on idealogical front also.

 

[Man of Thoughts]

You all have not understand the point of this thread.......

Let us consider we defeat them by our force but some of them surely run away at the time and will come back to start all this again.......One of them deid and the other one is already there to replace him and cat mouse chase started again

 

[seekers]

You all have not understand the point of this thread.......

I think you don't want to understand any solution.
You talk about roots, but don't want to look in past. This is seed of sectarism which was sown in zia regime.Saudia arabia is key financier and supporter of this parasite which is now grown into tall tree. Now they have many branches like TTP,TTA,LT,LJ,SSP......ETC.
Life of this tree is funding from Saudia arabia , Gulf and now also from inside sympathizer.
This tree would no more survive after curbing a funding water from these sources.
Jzaib!Moreover is not possible of your choice

 

[Last Hope]

Hmmmm....
Interesting topic.

but the question was from Our PoV.
so,
What I feel is,

We must take over them with any means we could, War, Talks, Shaheens or ANYWAY.

Try to make them change instead of killing them.

(We must NOT forget that life is just a temporary test and once it goes wrong, there is no way to come back and hell is the place were we will stay all the time i.e. Forever. (That is up to God, the most merciful))

Even they, like all of us are human.
Just the thing is that they are blindfolded by extreme religeous views.
They must be given a chance.
If not, then they shoudl all be given the work of public servents and labors so that at least the country would benifit.

Of course, that is my PoV,
Feel free to argue about it

 

[Man of Thoughts]

I think you don't want to understand any solution.
You talk about roots, but don't want to look in past. This is seed of sectarism which was sown in zia regime.Saudia arabia is key financier and supporter of this parasite which is now grown into tall tree. Now they have many branches like TTP,TTA,LT,LJ,SSP......ETC.
Life of this tree is funding from Saudia arabia , Gulf and now also from inside sympathizer.
This tree would no more survive after curbing a funding water from these sources.
Jzaib!Moreover is not possible of your choice

This is what i want to hear But we cannot kill all deobands..........

What we have to do is to educate our new generation about this.
Lets consider gulf will not support them but what's the proof of this that no one new will fund them...???

And one more thing suicide bombers are mostly from Pakistan's backward areas..... Saudi Arabia or Gulf did'nt send their people..

 

[The Clarifier]

Taliban are poisonous to our religious views in Pakistan and our society overall. They cannot be killed, but they can be contained. It is a matter of time until their ideologies trickle into our society so we must:

1. Use media effectively inside Pakistan about what is right and what is wrong.

2. Don't say Taliban won't talk. If they talk to Pakistan, they might think we can help them solidify their position in Afghanistan. This is what Musharraf said too.

3. Education. Remember, Taliban recruits are generally not educated about Islam and fall for the trap.

4. Empowerment. Ties with point 3.

'nuff said.

 

[Bill Longley]

if your son gets bad, would you terminate him

I will only narrate a hadith

Prophet(PBUH) said "Dont hate person, hate his evil"
i dont know why some of us while exhibiting extremism try to prove them selves moderate

pity on their thinking

no matter how bad Taliban are. If they challenge Writ of govt fight with them with all the might but if they leave their ways and become ordinarry citizens . well they are Pakistanies and if not of seeker or his alike they are my brothers and I will feel mercy for them. they are my People.

 

[somebozo]

long term changes have to be bought with education particulary strong primary education where a focus is built on industry and economy rather than religion and civics.

 

[seekers]

This is what i want to hear But we cannot kill all deobands..........

What we have to do is to educate our new generation about this.
Lets consider gulf will not support them but what's the proof of this that no one new will fund them...???

And one more thing suicide bombers are mostly from Pakistan's backward areas..... Saudi Arabia or Gulf did'nt send their people..

I have not present any strategy of killing any sects people.Deobandi could never be died with hunger if not receive money from Middle east.
Militant would must loose interest in war after loosing the major financier,because they fighting for money and power not for Islam.
Saudis are the people who cant even fight with their enemy to protect their own country, they use to call their God father US. in such scenario(like in Gulf war), then how is it possible they send people??.
You are living in some other world.
Even a Taliban not send their own boys for suicide attacks.Madressas are their first nurseries where parent leave their leftover child(most problem child use to send here),poverty is one factor.
Mullahs are the first teacher of suicide bomber . After passing a suicide capability test they send them into practical training unit.
Here they also offer some handsome money to parents of suicide bombers.
This is Big money game which can't survive longer on local funds.
Petro power is even dominant over Super power. World has not hear any inquiry against 8 out of Nine Saudi hijackers of 911.

 

[divya]

if your son gets bad, would you terminate him

I will only narrate a hadith

Prophet(PBUH) said "Dont hate person, hate his evil"
i dont know why some of us while exhibiting extremism try to prove them selves moderate

pity on their thinking

no matter how bad Taliban are. If they challenge Writ of govt fight with them with all the might but if they leave their ways and become ordinarry citizens . well they are Pakistanies and if not of seeker or his alike they are my brothers and I will feel mercy for them. they are my People.

Good and give refuge to the same brothers because of whom the mother in the neighbourhood lost her son, the soldier got shaheed fighting so that one day you will spit on his grave this way. Dude the deal is simple give up arms wanna join politics respect the constitution of Pakistan and find legal ways for it and if not PA has got some big guns and who can tell that better than indians about what guns they have..

 

[naumananjum]

First try to finish all
then there are many options to stop them rise again

 

[Bill Longley]

Good and give refuge to the same brothers because of whom the mother in the neighbourhood lost her son, the soldier got shaheed fighting so that one day you will spit on his grave this way. Dude the deal is simple give up arms wanna join politics respect the constitution of Pakistan and find legal ways for it and if not PA has got some big guns and who can tell that better than indians about what guns they have..

bibi I stand by what i said.
For me my country man is important. if my brother mend his ways and join main stream I will stand by him weather Its me alone

a pakistani is billion times more precious to me then an indian or afghan

 

[monitor]

To terminate the evil! kill their idealogical mothers. like the pro taliban mulla, JI JUI and SSA. I am surprised to see al those who support talibans like JI and ASSP and their affiliates enjoying great fredom of movement, propaganda and fund raising.

It is time to start fight on idealogical front also.

taliban was created by your own isi and america too had support for taliban .now when this frankentain start killing your own people in name of jihad you start understanding what you had created .i do believe that if pakistan start integrating the relatively young taliban to your society by giving them true islamic teaching and ideology behaind jihad and make opportunity for employment this mess can be removed from pakistani society . beside this political understanding between different parties is also important instead of blaming each other.

 

[divya]

bibi I stand by what i said.
For me my country man is important. if my brother mend his ways and join main stream I will stand by him weather Its me alone

a pakistani is billion times more precious to me then an indian or afghan

Of course everyone should be given a chance that on the government terms but not the appeasement. Taliban do not deserve the policy of appeasement. they should be given chance either have it or have the PA.

 

[naumananjum]

To terminate the evil! kill their idealogical mothers. like the pro taliban mulla, JI JUI and SSA. I am surprised to see al those who support talibans like JI and ASSP and their affiliates enjoying great fredom of movement, propaganda and fund raising.

It is time to start fight on idealogical front also.

strongly agreed to your point