Viewpoint of a Swati IDP - Is he right ???

[Mujahid]

Viewpoint of a Swati IDP - Is he right ???

 

[Patriot]

I agree with him that Army should have taken these bastards way before but the guy is forgetting one thing is that it's local who provided support to these bastards in the name of Islamic Brotherhood.They're worried about Pakistan Army killing civillians.GOD forbid if Talibans get near Islamabad (As he said Talibans are pushtoons and powerful they can come to Islo) then he will know exactly how civillians are kiled in war ruthlessley when America bombs drop over his house.I can't blame him but i think our media played a huge role in brainwashing of these people.Look how he said Army killed 17000 students in Lal Masjid.That son of a ***** Mr Zia-ul-**** fucked Pakistan..If this is what opinion of majority of Pushtoons then no doubt Pakistan will become a failed state sooner or later.

 

[BSF]

You have a Banaras in Karachi ?
or did i misread something?

"Upar se bomb barsatey hai ..nechey se gole daltey hai "

Nice dialog.
Very touching video

 

[Conscientious objector]

ql_QnGvKH-0[/media] - Refugees from Buner in Landhi, Karachi (Part 2)

 

[waraich66]

SWAT IDP's are confused and could not identify who is their friend and who is enemy.


TTP or TNSM are group of greedy mullahs, using their arms for terrorism and also tried to hijack SWAT in the name of islam.

Army has done great job and shall continue uptill all Jehadi greedy mullah and terrorist TTP flushed out from our soil.

Pakistan should try to get UN ,GCC ,EU and US aid to facilitate and rehablitate SWAT IDP's ASAP.

 

[Conscientious objector]

Oh so now the IDP's are confused and don't know what they're talking about do they?


So much for all the horror stories.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Oh so now the IDP's are confused and don't know what they're talking about do they?


So much for all the horror stories.

Oh there are plenty of horror stories along with people who are upset about the fact that they are displaced from their homes.

You just choose to ignore the horror stories caused by the Taliban and call them propaganda.

 

[Conscientious objector]

Oh there are plenty of horror stories along with people who are upset about the fact that they are displaced from their homes.

You just choose to ignore the horror stories caused by the Taliban and call them propaganda.

And what of the interviews with the IDP's who say they didn't have a problem with the Taliban,and that the only reason they left was because of the indiscriminate shelling?

The horror stories could (as I believe they are) easily be propaganda as the government has every motivation to make up such stories for propaganda purposes.But the interviews with the IDP's who say they had no trouble from the Taliban cannot be concoctions for the obvious reasons.

 

[Faruqi]

And what of the interviews with the IDP's who say they didn't have a problem with the Taliban,and that the only reason they left was because of the indiscriminate shelling?

The horror stories could (as I believe they are) easily be propaganda as the government has every motivation to make up such stories for propaganda purposes.But the interviews with the IDP's who say they had no trouble from the Taliban cannot be concoctions for the obvious reasons.

So are you suggesting that all of the horror stories about the Taliba are false? There are so many of those stories and they far outnumber those which are pro-Taliban, most people from the Valleys seem to be supporting the army or are taking no sides, as shown by the interviews. These interviews aren't just carried out by Pakisani journalists, but also by credible sources, such as Al Jazeera. There are definitely those who supported the Taliban, but it seems after what the Taliban did to them, their numbers decreased. If you have no evidence that those interviews were faked, then you don't have any point and your post is unnecessary. All you're doing is spreading a conspiracy theory.

 

[Conscientious objector]

If you have no evidence that those interviews were faked, then you don't have any point and your post is unnecessary. All you're doing is spreading a conspiracy theory.

I could say the same about all stories of the so called atrocities carried out by the Taliban to you.

 

[Faruqi]

I could say the same about all stories of the so called atrocities carried out by the Taliban to you.

You're the one suggesting that videos were faked, not me. I asked you to prove that they were faked. You don't seem capable of proving this, therefore I believe that most of the videos showing people who've suffered due to Taliban are genuine. From what is being shown, most people seem to be anti-Taliban. If you can prove otherwise, then good, but it seems you can't.

 

[PAFAce]

I could say the same about all stories of the so called atrocities carried out by the Taliban to you.

Listen to what the interviewing woman has to say. Do you need more proof of this video's lack of impartiality? Obviously there will be people who have their own theories about this war, you'd be hard pressed to find any issue on which there is 100% agreement, but you must look at the majority view. The best tools for this are the hundreds of interviews on private television condemning the Taleban, and the reluctance of the IDPs to go back to their homes due to fear of Telabn persecution.