What's new

US senators struggle to define victory in Afghanistan

Joined
Jul 7, 2014
Messages
1,767
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
WASHINGTON: Key US senators, who visited Pakistan and Afghanistan this week, appear divided on how to win the Afghan war: some prefer a military victory before negotiations, others seek a political solution.

There is, however, one common thread in their statements published in the US media on Saturday: Pakistan needs to do more to force the Taliban to accept a political solution.

Senator John McCain, who headed this five-member US Senate delegation, said the visit convinced him that the Unites States needs to have a new strategy to win in Afghanistan and that “the strongest nation on Earth should be able to win this conflict.”

But Senator Elizabeth Warren, one of the two Democrats in the team, stressed the need for focusing on a political solution and accused the Trump administration of neglecting diplomatic efforts to win this war. She also urged Pakistan to do more.

“While they have taken positive steps, we told Pakistani leaders they must do more to eliminate safe havens and terrorist groups in the region,” she tweeted.

The Senate delegation, which met senior Pakistani and Afghan officials as well as commanders of the US-led Nato forces in Afghanistan, is expected to share its observations with the Trump administration. The delegation also visited South Waziristan.

Senator Warren, a rising Democratic star who is considered a serious candidate for the next presidential election, said she also discussed Pakistan’s role in the war against terrorism when with the army chief, Gen. Qamar Javed Bajwa, when she met him in the Pakistani capital last week.

“I met with Pakistan Army Chief Gen. Bajwa to discuss the critical role Pakistan must play in countering terrorism in the region,” she tweeted. She also talked about the delegation’s July 3 visit to South Waziristan.

“In South Waziristan, Army and local leaders showed us how USAID’s development projects are making a real difference in people’s lives,” she tweeted.

Senator McCain, who told reporters in Kabul last week that the United States should reconsider its relations with Pakistan if it does not stop supporting the Haqqani network, is now demanding a substantial increase in the US military presence in Afghanistan. Senator Lindsey Graham, also a Republican and a former presidential candidate like Mr McCain, supported this demand.

He said the old strategy of a gradual decrease in the US military presence in Afghanistan did not work because it did not focus on defeating the Taliban.



Published in Dawn, July 9th, 2017
 
.
There is not even the possibility of an American military victory, and the Taliban know it. Why should they negotiate?
 
.
The Americans can go to hell. Pakistan cannot do anything. Fight your own crappy war in afghanistan and while you at it take some Afghan refugees into your country as well. Pakistan is done fighting YOUR war. Also, stop making use of Pakistani ports and roads to supply goods to Afghanistan.

Also, Pakistan and the US don't have a relationship. The Americans are kidding themselves by claiming that they are going to rethink the relationship when there is none.
 
.
The title says it all, what the heck is victory in Afghanistan?
Keeping the Taliban out of Kabul, a "manageable" number of bombings and deaths, does anyone think there will be in the future a peaceful democratic Afghanistan or is a simmering civil war with a low body bag count acceptable?

There is not even the possibility of an American military victory, and the Taliban know it. Why should they negotiate?

possible yes probable no, no one in the US wants to put the men and effort into Afghanistan to win but they don't want to do another Vietnam, pack up leave and allow the Taliban to say they kick the yanks out. It makes sense for the Taliban to "wait them out" in the hope that one day a president will be so sick of the problem that they blame it all on Bush Obama and Trump and pull out. Say when Bernie wins the next election ;)

The Americans can go to hell. Pakistan cannot do anything. Fight your own crappy war in afghanistan and while you at it take some Afghan refugees into your country as well.

It might be "Americas war" but its Pakistan's back yard if the yanks leave who do you think has to pick up the pieces and deal with the Taliban running the country next door, careful what you wish for.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom