What's new

US defended cluster bomb used on Yemeni city.

Steakhouse

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Oct 6, 2014
Messages
933
Reaction score
-1
Country
Angola
Location
American Samoa
US defends cluster bomb transfers

3 hours ago


.
Smoke billows as supporters of exiled Yemeni President Abedrabbo Mansour Hadi continue to clash with Shiite Huthi rebels in the Khor Maksar neighbourhood of the southern Yemeni city of Aden, on May 3, 2015 (AFP Photo/Saleh Al-Obeidi)
Washington (AFP) - The United States defended its supplies of cluster munitions Sunday, pointing to restrictions on the transfers, after Human Rights Watch said the bombs had been used by the Saudi-led coalition in Yemen.

HRW said it had gathered photographs, video and other evidence indicating that cluster munitions had been used in coalition air strikes against the Huthi rebel stronghold of Saada province in Yemen's northern mountains in recent weeks.

It said that analysis of satellite imagery suggested that the weapons had landed on a cultivated plateau, within 600 meters (yards) of populated areas.

"We take all accounts of civilian deaths due to the ongoing hostilities in Yemen very seriously," a US Defense Department official told AFP.

"We call upon all sides to comply with international humanitarian law and to take all feasible measures to minimize harm to civilians."

The official said Washington was "looking carefully" into the HRW report's claims.

HRW said that the munitions used in Yemen appeared to be the CBU-105 Sensor Fuzed Weapons manufactured by the Textron Systems Corporation and supplied to both Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates by the United States in recent years.

The weapon is banned by the Convention on Cluster Munitions but Washington permits its use and export because it boasts an unexploded ordnance rate of less than one percent.

The US Defense Department official pointed to that policy to highlight Washington's "stringent requirements."

"In addition, recipients of such transfers must commit that cluster munitions will only be used against clearly defined military targets and will not be used where civilians are known to be present or in areas normally inhabited by civilians," the official added.

"This is obviously a critical element of the policy."

Cluster munitions are prohibited by a 2008 treaty adopted by 116 countries, but not by Saudi Arabia and its coalition partners or the United States.

The rebels and their allies in the armed forces have captured large swathes of the country since overrunning the capital Sanaa in September.
 
. . .
The title is misleading, the US will not defend the use of CBU (Cluster Bomb Unit) as the US is NOT one of the signatory to outlaw the use of Cluster Bomb. There are nothing illegal for the US to defend.

As to why SA uses cluster bomb, who knows, maybe they used them for psychological factors, or maybe they use it because of their dud rate, which is less than 1%, but in the end, even SA did not sign the convention, you can call them inhumane, but they have every right to use them...
 
.
The title is misleading, the US will not defend the use of CBU (Cluster Bomb Unit) as the US is NOT one of the signatory to outlaw the use of Cluster Bomb. There are nothing illegal for the US to defend.

Which also mean the US should not be judged by China, Russia, Iran, India, Pakistan, Brazil, Saudi Arabia (who stands accused of using said munitions) or any other non-signatory. Saudi Arabia doesn't have to defend its position either, it isn't a signatory to the Convention on Cluster Munitions:

863px-Cluster_Munitions_Convention.svg.png


Signatories to the Convention (blue), States Parties (purple), and non-signatories (white).

There's a lot of white on that map, a lot of nations that have refused to forgo cluster munitions. Why should the US be defending itself for Saudi Arabia's actions?
 
Last edited:
.
If anything, the CBU-105 still is one of the safest Cluster units in terms of collateral damage. With the skeets programmed to explode if they dont find any targets after a set height barrier is crossed. Not even the latest LGBs have this feature.
 
.
Which also mean the US should not be judged by China, Russia, Iran, India, Pakistan, Brazil, Saudi Arabia (who stands accused of using said munitions) or any other non-signatory. Saudi Arabia doesn't have to defend its position either, it isn't a signatory to the Convention on Cluster Munitions:

863px-Cluster_Munitions_Convention.svg.png


Signatories to the Convention (blue), States Parties (purple), and non-signatories (white).

There's a lot of white on that map, a lot of nations that have refused to forgo cluster munitions. Why should the US be defending itself for Saudi Arabia's actions?

Bear in mind, no one on the Blue or Purple complaint about this, you can literally see their ulterior motive.

I'll say, let's export more CBU :)

If anything, the CBU-105 still is one of the safest Cluster units in terms of collateral damage. With the skeets programmed to explode if they dont find any targets after a set height barrier is crossed. Not even the latest LGBs have this feature.

They don't call then smart bomb for nothing, I was once given a 60 second heads up to get away out of the blast zone of a JDAM, I ran about 400 meters and the bomb exploded 600 meter behind me lol. Now tell me which country can achieve this kind of accuracy for their bomb, CBU or LGB or otherwise...
 
.
W
Which also mean the US should not be judged by China, Russia, Iran, India, Pakistan, Brazil, Saudi Arabia (who stands accused of using said munitions) or any other non-signatory. Saudi Arabia doesn't have to defend its position either, it isn't a signatory to the Convention on Cluster Munitions:

863px-Cluster_Munitions_Convention.svg.png


Signatories to the Convention (blue), States Parties (purple), and non-signatories (white).

There's a lot of white on that map, a lot of nations that have refused to forgo cluster munitions. Why should the US be defending itself for Saudi Arabia's actions?
When iran accused of using such weapons
 
.
When iran accused of using such weapons

When did I say Iran used cluster munitions? I said (and highlighted) Saudi Arabia being accused of using cluster munitions in Yemen. But it's not a signatory to the Convention on Cluster Munition, which I also highlighted several major non-signatories, thus Saudi Arabia is under no legal obligation to not use cluster munitions or defends its practice.
 
.
Bear in mind, no one on the Blue or Purple complaint about this, you can literally see their ulterior motive.

I'll say, let's export more CBU :)



They don't call then smart bomb for nothing, I was once given a 60 second heads up to get away out of the blast zone of a JDAM, I ran about 400 meters and the bomb exploded 600 meter behind me lol. Now tell me which country can achieve this kind of accuracy for their bomb, CBU or LGB or otherwise...
Well iran and Russia boast such precision even better with some of their missiles .
 
.
Well iran and Russia boast such precision even better with some of their missiles .

it is not boast, but I actually was the receving end of one of the JDAM. they can talk all the way they want between Iran and Russia, but if I don't see it, I don't believe it
 
.
it is not boast, but I actually was the receving end of one of the JDAM. they can talk all the way they want between Iran and Russia, but if I don't see it, I don't believe it
Well do you doubt precision of iskander missile and about iran you can search for the persian gulf missile and see how that balistic missile hit a small ship from 300km away.
 
.
Well do you doubt precision of iskander missile and about iran you can search for the persian gulf missile and see how that balistic missile hit a small ship from 300km away.

again, I don't believe in anything I can not see....

That's why I have no religion...
 
. . .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom