What's new

Turkey defies warnings and cuts interest rates

dani191

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 10, 2017
Messages
4,756
Reaction score
-9
Country
Israel
Location
Israel
Please use the sharing tools found via the share button at the top or side of articles. Copying articles to share with others is a breach of FT.com T&Cs and Copyright Policy. Email licensing@ft.com to buy additional rights. Subscribers may share up to 10 or 20 articles per month using the gift article service. More information can be found here.
https://www.ft.com/content/2db0434d-2851-4485-850d-06cfca32ff22
1637361481240.png

Turkey defies warnings and cuts interest rates Lira tumbles as economists fret that loose monetary policy will spur inflation The lira has dropped 30% against the dollar in 2021 © Reuters Share on twitter (opens new window) Share on facebook (opens new window) Share on linkedin (opens new window) Save Adam Samson in London and Laura Pitel in Ankara NOVEMBER 18 2021 294 Print this page Sign up for our Europe Express newsletter Don’t miss your essential guide to what matters in Europe today. Delivered every weekday morning. Turkey slashed interest rates on Thursday, sending the lira tumbling as much as 6 per cent to a new record low, heightening concerns President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s fixation on low borrowing costs will worsen already acute inflation. The central bank cut its one-week repo rate 1 percentage point to 15 per cent, marking the third straight reduction in interest rates under governor Sahap Kavcioglu from 19 per cent at the start of September. The bank said many factors behind surging consumer prices were “beyond monetary policy’s control” and that it would “consider” ending its cycle of rate cuts this December. The lira’s decline had eased to 3 per cent by the end of the London trading day. However, the currency has fallen more than 30 per cent this year — on a par with Turkey’s currency crisis in 2018 — as economists fret that low interest rates will worsen an inflation spiral, with consumer price growth having reached an annual pace of almost 20 per cent in October. “It’s mystifying why they would do this,” said Paul McNamara, an emerging market investor at GAM in London. He said some aspects of Turkey’s economy looked encouraging as the country recovered from the pandemic. “The only driver for a weak lira is the policy outlook,” he said. Turkey’s central bank has been under intense pressure from Erdogan to loosen monetary policy despite blistering inflation. Lower rates — and a weaker currency — tend to worsen inflation because it increases the price of imported goods, creating a vicious cycle. Erdogan, who holds the unorthodox view that high interest rates cause, rather than tame, inflation, on Wednesday renewed his pledge to free Turkey from the “scourge” of high interest rates. “I’m sorry to our friends [from the ruling party] who defend [high] interest but I cannot and will not walk the same path as them,” he said. The central bank on Thursday laid blame for the elevated inflation on “transitory effects of supply-side factors” including high global food and energy prices, which it expected to last into the first half of next year. It said many advanced economies were continuing to pursue monetary policy stimulus, partially on expectations that the surge in global inflation would prove to be fleeting in the medium to long term. But Turkey’s loosening of monetary policy leaves the country as an outlier at a time when many other emerging markets are raising rates. Both South Africa and Hungary announced rate rises on Thursday. The US Federal Reserve, the world’s most influential central bank, is also reducing its stimulus measures, something that has placed emerging markets under more pressure to increase interest rates to attract investment. Analysts at Barclays said Turkey had entered “uncharted waters”, calling the recent rate reductions “counter-productive”. Erdogan has faced mounting calls from the opposition and the Turkish business community to set aside his obsession with rate cuts in order to tame inflation and stabilise the currency, whose slide has been eroding standards of living. “Now STOP, Erdogan!” Kemal Kilicdaroglu, the leader of the country’s largest opposition party, said in a tweet in response to Thursday’s decision and repeated his demand for Turkey to go to elections. The rightwing IYI party, which has been enjoying growing support in the polls, accused Erdogan of “bankrupting” the country. Recommended FT News Briefing podcast10 min listen Euro drama in currency markets “The reasons that are causing a currency crisis right now are not macroeconomic per se. It’s the decision-making system that gives Erdogan endless authority,” said Umit Ozlale, one of the party’s vice-presidents. “Whatever he wants is done. That’s why we’re in this crisis. This is a decision-making crisis.” Jittery markets had been further unnerved by an item published overnight in the country’s official gazette relating to foreign currency transactions at Turkish bureaux de change. Turkish officials dismissed frenzied speculation on social media that the move was a sign of impending capital controls. They said the directive was a small technical change to a previous requirement for citizens to show identification at foreign exchange offices, arguing that it was actually a liberalising measure that lifted the minimum transaction amount for such a requirement to $100.
 
Economic situation definitely appear grave, but since Turkey is an export oriented state, this inflation may very well help them raise exports.
As well may help win investments in industrial and manufacturing sector.
May very well discourage, economic immigrants from Pakistan and Afghanistan, which is good for developed Turkish society in general.
 
Economic situation definitely appear grave, but since Turkey is an export oriented state, this inflation may very well help them raise exports.
As well may help win investments in industrial and manufacturing sector.
May very well discourage, economic immigrants from Pakistan and Afghanistan, which is good for developed Turkish society in general.
yea turkey need to decrease intrase rate to normal level like 5 %
 
yea turkey need to decrease intrase rate to normal level like 5 %
5% sounds huge.. but can't comment what exactly is triggering fall in Lira value, my personal guess..... it's because of massive currency exchange drive, Just days ago, i was wandering at Taksim and surrounding areas, saw locals carrying USD in their wallets instead of Lira. I was looking for change.
 
Economic situation definitely appear grave, but since Turkey is an export oriented state, this inflation may very well help them raise exports.
As well may help win investments in industrial and manufacturing sector.
May very well discourage, economic immigrants from Pakistan and Afghanistan, which is good for developed Turkish society in general.

Actually, Turkey has deficit in its foreign trade.

And its exports have to source lots of intermediaries in USD. This reflects on declining profit margins in exported goods.

Because, Turkey exports are not competitive because of high-tech involved. They are competitive in pricing. There are lots of countries competing in low-labor cost, low-tech categories, such as textile or foods.
 
Actually, Turkey has deficit in its foreign trade.

And its exports have to source lots of intermediaries in USD. This reflects on declining profit margins in exported goods.

Because, Turkey exports are not competitive because of high-tech involved. They are competitive in pricing. There are lots of countries competing in low-labor cost, low-tech categories, such as textile or foods.
but they have other source of dollar getting like turrists and investments
 
There are alot of uneducated fools online who somehow pick up on something others are saying while thinking there is something to it... Example the inflation in Turkey which is ''Myth'' that it will do damage.. 1 USD against 10 Lira that is not bad at all I tell you what.. They are not even near threatening zone could be 50 years away from that if it even ever becomes threatening even at that point they will just print which means they will never hit a level of concern without a war in regards to their currency.

Example if you want inflation take a look at Russia 1 USD for 73 Russian currency because Russia's entire economy is one big inflation or Iran that has the worlds largest inflation with a whopping 42250 Iranian rial against 1 USD.. Inflation doesn't collapse ecnomies but what it does is that it just moves the gaol post until it reaches a critical point but Turkey is not there and far from it in fact North Korea itself that is struggling with savage inflation is not nearly there..

People should stop parroting fallacies this reminds me about the fools who has been saying since the 90s the GULF will go broke? We are 30+ years later and they have just become more wealtier.. fantasizing about something will not make it a reality... Example just weeks ago there were articles allover the Internet declaring China has collapsed economically due to Evergrande? Internet is full of weird groupies nowadays who are writting shitty articles and things they don't understand anything about
 
Last edited:
There are alot of uneducated fools online who somehow pick up on something others are saying while thinking there is something to it... Example the inflation in Turkey which is ''Myth'' that it will do damage.. 1 USD against 10 Lira that is not bad at all I tell you what.. They are not even near threatening zone could be 50 years away from that if it even ever becomes threatening even at that point they will just print which means they will never hit a level of concern without a war in regards to their currency.

Example if you want inflation take a look at Russia 1 USD for 73 Russian currency because Russia's entire economy is one big inflation or Iran that has the worlds largest inflation with a whopping 42250 Iranian rial against 1 USD.. Inflation doesn't collapse ecnomies but what it does is that it just moves the gaol post until it reaches a critical point but Turkey is not there and far it in fact North Korea itself that is struggling with savage inflation is not nearly there..

People should stop parroting fallacies this reminds me about the fools who has been saying since the 90s the GULF will go broke? We are 30+ years later and they have just become more wealtier.. fantasizing about something will not make it a reality... Example just weeks ago there were articles allover the Internet declaring China has collapsed economically due to Evergrande? Internet is full of weird groupies nowadays who are writting shitty articles and things they don't understand anything about
ok so need to cut intrest rate to 5%
 
The Turkish govt wants the currency to continue to depreciate? But the 15% interest rate is really too much.
 
Actually, Turkey has deficit in its foreign trade.

And its exports have to source lots of intermediaries in USD. This reflects on declining profit margins in exported goods.

Because, Turkey exports are not competitive because of high-tech involved. They are competitive in pricing. There are lots of countries competing in low-labor cost, low-tech categories, such as textile or foods.

If Turkish companies are supplying to US than they must be invoicing in USD. I don't see any loss, as such. I only see potential of increase in profit margins and exports.

Turkish exports may not be competitive vs. China's state sponsored business model but they manage to be relevant in markets vs China.
There exports are technical or not, is a subjective matter, depend what's technical for you... would you consider building ships technical?
 
Last edited:
If Turkish companies are supplying to US than they must be invoicing in USD. I don't see any loss, as such. I only see potential of increase in profit margins and exports.

Turkish exports may not be competitive vs. China's state sponsored business model but they manage to be relevant in markets vs China as incl.
There exports are technical or not, is a subjective matter, depend what's technical for you... would you consider build ships technical?
more epxort and less import maybe they will solve trade deficit
 
more epxort and less import maybe they will solve trade deficit
It's clear, if their import bill is higher than it's a problem, but you seem to be solid on interest rate cuts.... do you have shares in Turkish stock exchange ;)
 
It's clear, if their import bill is higher than it's a problem, but you seem to be solid on interest rate cuts.... do you have shares in Turkish stock exchange ;)
lol i want turkish economy will demage cause its enemy of israel cut intraste rate will get the lira to 20-30 to dollar
let them cut intrest rate to 2-3 % and will see what heppend
 
lol i want turkish economy will demage cause its enemy of israel cut intraste rate will get the lira to 20-30 to dollar
let them cut intrest rate to 2-3 % and will see what heppend

Turkey is ally of Israel, but what's the basis of your analysis?
If Lira comes to 20 /$ it will be a big havoc in Turkey.
 

Back
Top Bottom