What's new

Through a ‘widely-circulated’ letter: PTI seeks to upset govt-IMF apple cart?

muhammadhafeezmalik

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
5,417
Reaction score
-17
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan

PTI seeks to upset govt-IMF apple cart?


  • Through a ‘widely-circulated’ letter, the KP govt expresses its inability to create budget surplus
  • Miftah takes umbrage at the letter

Federal Finance Minister Miftah Ismail has expressed his disappointment over a letter that he received from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Finance Minister through which the latter has expressed his province’s inability to create budget surplus due to the devastation wrought by floods in the province.


Addressing a press conference last midnight, finance minister said he had spoken to the KP Finance Minister Taimur Saleem Khan Jhagra who assured him (Miftah) that this letter was not sent to the IMF (International Monetary Fund). He said he invited Jhagra for a discussion on Monday and would give the province required funds for the FATA merger, etc. Miftah said he was disappointed by Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) leader Fawad Chaudhary’s statement in this regard. He said the KP Finance Minister has written to him for resolution of long-standing issues of the province.


Miftah said the IMF might have taken note of this letter, “which is everywhere in media.” He added: “This is very surprising. When entire Pakistan is flooded, the provincial government is writing this letter which could have been written ten days later. What is the point of writing this letter? Does he [Jhagra] want to put Pakistan and Pakistan’s economy at stake? You [the KP government] are doing such politics when there are unprecedented floods and your’re doing it when the IMF board is going to take up Pakistan’s case.”


He accused former Finance Minister Shaukat Tarin of nudging the provincial governments of Punjab and KP to write such a letter.


Earlier, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Finance Minister Taimur Saleem Khan Jhagra conveyed to Finance Minister Miftah Ismail of the province’s inability to generate budget surplus for the ongoing fiscal year due to the destruction caused by the floods and previously unresolved financial issues by the Center.


In a letter dated 26 August 2022 addressed to Finance Minister Ismail, Jhagra stated that this letter is a follow-up to his letter of July 6 this year to him (Miftah) on the same topic.


“When we last met, the federal government committed to resolve the province’s financial issues.” He added that in return, as committed, he obtained the authorization of the Chief Minister, for the province of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa to sign on to the MOU and did so within 24 hours. “We did this in the greater national interest. However, in contrast to this, in the intervening period of almost two months, we have been unable to get time to meet either the minister or the secretary, even once. Let me remind you of the criticality of the issues.”


The provincial finance minister added that “perhaps most importantly, to resolve the budget allocations for ex-FATA, which, in the absence of an updated NFC award, are decided at the discretion of the federal government; (a) to resolve the issue of current budget allocations for ex-Fata, which are insufficient to cover even the monthly salary costs of existing employees; (b) to finance the transfer of the Sehat Card Programme for the residents of ex-Fata, in which the federal government has chosen to unilaterally deprive the six million residents of ex-Fata of health insurance; (c) to ensure adequate budgeting to cater to the needs of TDPs (Temporarily Displaced Persons) moved into out of districts camp because of operations against militancy followed by; (2) to commit to monthly NHP transfers based on the MoU signed between the federal government and the Government of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa in 2016. Incidentally, this MOU was signed during the previous PML-N and; (3) for the federal government to immediately revive the National Finance Commission (NFC), so that these issues can be resolved more permanently: (4) for the federal government to also commit to immediately engage and resolve other financial issues with the Government of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa.


“These include but are not limited to; clearing outstanding liabilities to the Pakhtunkhwa Energy Development Organization (PEDO); resolving the issues of energy wheeling; resolving the issue of WACOG, and the availability of natural gas to the province in line with Article 158; the financing of PESCO to develop transmission and distribution infrastructure in the province; and the commitment of the federal government to not delay execution of provincially funded PESCO and TESCO projects; and not substituting the federal excise duty with the petroleum levy without provincial consent, as this amounts to unilaterally reducing the size of provincial transfers from the total quantum of federal collections.”


He further stated that as per estimate that the overall impact of not resolving these issues is actually to create a Rs100 billion unfunded liability in the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa budget.


Jhagra said that now the monsoon flooding that the province is currently facing has wreaked destruction in Swat, DI Khan, and Tank making the situation even more challenging, “but that may over the course of the next few hours and days, make the damage from this year’s flooding greater than the super-floods of 2010. The cost in terms of rescue, relief, rehabilitation, and building back is likely to run into the tens of billions.”


He concluded that “in these conditions and without the resolution of the issues highlighted previously, for the province of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa to actually leave a surplus will be next to impossible.”


 
Booooooo! PTI bAd.

Ummm. I just have one question that I for the life of me can't figure out. If IK was laying landmines for you. You knew he'd play dirty. Then kon sa keera sat maar rha tha ke jis liye billions lga ke MNA, MPA khareeday aur aaj zaleel ho rhe ho?

I think in logon pe ye meme fit ata he. Excuse the french.

https://d33wubrfki0l68.cloudfront.net/256250a11a6320558a86dd9724c775cceacf5441/6e479/img/templates/paragliding-video-madarchod.jpg

https://d33wubrfki0l68.cloudfront.net/b8bdd31de99258c302f5278f8848a30ec3c79362/861d1/img/templates/paragliding-video-500.jpg

https://d33wubrfki0l68.cloudfront.net/fe4cbb0a43fc68b33035a2c3a3e2c633ab2ef604/97729/img/templates/paragliding-video-pair.jpg


Also, any guesses who the guy at the back, guiding the whole thing is? That guy must also be regretting for having agreed to glide with this chay.

@lastofthepatriots , sir, would you like to add something? :)
 
Last edited:
Damn, propganda wing of PDM/army in full swing. These lot are going ape on Pakistanis with 5th gen warfare.
 
Funny how the same pdm is now crying about Pakistani economy which they themselves destroyed. As for the letter its just politics.
 
Someone said "KP has an honest government under PTI and has shown economic surplus while other provinces under the imported Hamza and Sindh under PPP have been looted "
 
Congratulations, Pakistan Zindabad, three cheers, a clink of the wine glasses...thori si sharam hi kar lo besharmo.

Sahi hai the deal is done, good for the country, and I hope our financial situation does get better now, but is it really something to celebrate and congratulate on?
Is saving the country from a prospective economic default not something to be celebrated? Why should this be a shame for the fixer?!

All PTI supporters have been trolling about IMF deal not coming through for past few weeks. I would expect them to be satiated with this development. Granted that this is a bandaid solution and real stability will take a few years to achieve. :coffee:
 
Is saving the country from a prospective economic default not something to be celebrated? Why should this be a shame for the fixer?!

Begging to 8 people for giving you money, in return for a whole host of concessions, only to be stuck in the same cycle again...if that's something for you to celebrate then carry on wearing the party hat!


All PTI supporters have been trolling about IMF deal not coming through for past few weeks. I would expect them to be satiated with this development.

Who all PTI supporters? Please show. No one in their right mind would say that going to the IMF is not good for us right now.

Granted that this is a bandaid solution and real stability will take a few years to achieve. :coffee:

Ah yes, the story after every IMF program.

As for the default thing, the same is said by every government when they come into power. A fair few people think we were in MUCH poorer shape in 2018 than we are now. Zubair (forget his full name), Dr Ashfaq I think of NUST, and a few others are on record saying the same, so don't take my word for it. Guess who left us in the situation in 2018!

Or was PTI so clever, that in merely 3 months it put us on the path to default? Because I am sure they planned to stay in power until 2023 and not bow out prematurely.
 
Begging to 8 people for giving you money, in return for a whole host of concessions, only to be stuck in the same cycle again...if that's something for you to celebrate then carry on wearing the party hat!




Who all PTI supporters? Please show. No one in their right mind would say that going to the IMF is not good for us right now.



Ah yes, the story after every IMF program.

As for the default thing, the same is said by every government when they come into power. A fair few people think we were in MUCH poorer shape in 2018 than we are now. Zubair (forget his full name), Dr Ashfaq I think of NUST, and a few others are on record saying the same, so don't take my word for it. Guess who left us in the situation in 2018!

Or was PTI so clever, that in merely 3 months it put us on the path to default? Because I am sure they planned to stay in power until 2023 and not bow out prematurely.
1) IMF deal required bridging finance. What was the other option to seek help from friendly countries?
2) PTI supporters were trolling PDM for delay in closing negotiations with IMF. There are threads in the 'similar threads' section below to see this.
3) PTI was also on track for utilizing the IMF EFF. But when they realized the opposition was going for the jugular, Imran announced the subsidy to threaten PDM with MAD. The subsidy was in violation of IMF terms and that took only 3 months. Rest is history and Pakistan was pushed to near default because without IMF deal the other creditors would not roll over debt obligations.

I don't know if PDM will do better than PTI. Only time can tell that. But I have the feeling that Pakistan will naturally reach economic stability in a few years when Reko diq and thar coal is utilized properly. :cheers:
 
1) IMF deal required bridging finance. What was the other option to seek help from friendly countries?
2) PTI supporters were trolling PDM for delay in closing negotiations with IMF. There are threads in the 'similar threads' section below to see this.
3) PTI was also on track for utilizing the IMF EFF. But when they realized the opposition was going for the jugular, Imran announced the subsidy to threaten PDM with MAD. The subsidy was in violation of IMF terms and that took only 3 months. Rest is history and Pakistan was pushed to near default because without IMF deal the other creditors would not roll over debt obligations.

I don't know if PDM will do better than PTI. Only time can tell that. But I have the feeling that Pakistan will naturally reach economic stability in a few years when Reko diq and thar coal is utilized properly. :cheers:
1. Solution was below market commodity contracts. The friendly countries are not giving aid but entering into sale contracts where they are buying national assets at steeply discounted values. Congratulations, you have gone from potentially buying stuff at a discount to selling stuff at a discount.
3. Subsidy was not given to lower oil prices but to try and maintain them and stave off inflation and keep growth intact. The idea was that this ought to be possible with the Russian contracts, at least to an extent. The subsidy btw was rupee denominated and wouldn't impact CAD, unless you are saying that it kept oil consumption artificially high when we needed to increase prices to reduce oil imports thereby reducing demand, reducing growth, increasing inflation. If it was so hemorrhaging and wrong, why didn't PDM reverse it on day 1? Why wait for reserves to deplete first?
 
Back
Top Bottom