Should the U.S introduce Pakistan style Ahmadi law for U.S muslims?

[yolo2016]

With all this talk about Trump's plan, and after I have seen many Pakistani americans openly calling us Americans terrorists on PDF and elsewhere- while they chose to continue to live among us - thus posing a terrorist risk.

I wanted to ask- why would America be wrong to introduce a constitutional law exactly like Pakistan has done i.e. where we ban muslims from certain countries as not being the "kind" of muslims we want. Pakistan says ahmadis are not the " kind of or are muslims as Pakistan defines them"... why can't we?

We want to protect ourselves and our families too. We don't want us to become what Britain has become.

Uncle Sam is the patron in chief of the terrorists.

And US is creator of terrorists.

US is mastermind of every terrorist activity in the planet. US itself is drive by few Zionist.

 

[untitled]

Will the US first introduce a Pakistan style blasphemy law first? What will it charge Muslims for blaspheming against?

 

[yolo2016]

Will the US first introduce a Pakistan style blasphemy law first? What will it charge Muslims for blaspheming against?

we will first start by denying muslims from certain countries that are hotbed of terror activities- persona non grata status- no entry to the U.S aka banned! . Then we will put any muslim americans who make claims like the one's in my OP on a watch list, revoke citizenship and proceed deportations. You would do the same if I came and lived in the belly of your country and made excusers for TTP; would you not?

 

[thesameguy]

That's a good idea. The law will identify Muslims as legally recognized minority groups with set quotas in education and jobs. same as Ahmedis get in Pakistan as legally recognized minority.

 

[untitled]

we will first start by allowing muslims from certain countries that are hotbed of terror activities- persona non grata- no entry to the U.S aka banned! . Then we will put any muslim americans who make claims like the one's in my OP on a watch list, revoke citizenship and proceed deportations. You would do the same if I came and lived in the belly of your country and made excusers for TTP; would you not?

so questioning American foreign policy is blasphemy?

 

[yolo2016]

That's a good idea. The law will identify Muslims as legally recognized minority groups with set quotas in education and jobs. same as Ahmedis get in Pakistan as legally recognized minority.

The law will recognize muslims from "certain" countries as not being allowed in the U.S as they pose a terror threat. It will allow us to revoke their status in country, plus send back muslim americans like the pakistani americans in my OP.

This is not about a sect. We could care less what sect of Islam you belong to. All we care about is our safety from terrorist sympathizers, and people like that man and woman who killed our citizens.

so questioning Americans foreign policy is blasphemy?

Terror sympathizers are not asking questions. Those are emphatic claims made.

 

[ArsalanKhan21]

These Qadianis have gone beserk !!

 

[CHD]

With all this talk about Trump's plan, and after I have seen many Pakistani americans openly calling us Americans terrorists on PDF and elsewhere- while they chose to continue to live among us - thus posing a terrorist risk.

I wanted to ask- why would America be wrong to introduce a constitutional law exactly like Pakistan has done i.e. where we ban muslims from certain countries as not being the "kind" of muslims we want. Pakistan says ahmadis are not the " kind of or are muslims as Pakistan defines them"... why can't we?

We want to protect ourselves and our families too. We don't want us to become what Britain has become.

It was the USA which started the muslim holy war aka Jihad against the soviets so ye USA is the Godfather of modern day terrorism

 

[thesameguy]

The law will recognize muslims from countries as not being allowed in the U.S as they pose a terror threat. It will allow us to revoke their status in country, plus send back muslim americans like the pakistani americans in my OP,

This is not about a sect. We could care less what sect of Islam you belong to. All we care about is our safety from terrorist sympathizers, and people like that man and woman who killed our citizens.

No you are noe changing your statement. You said "Ahmedi style law of Pakistan " ?
Pakistan does not cancel Ahmedi nationality. So your analogy is wrong. Should have thought this through before starting the thread

 

[yolo2016]

These Qadianis have gone beserk !!

Are you calling me a muslim ? lol, trust me I'm far far from being one

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Well to counter your statement, many "white" folks , with American citizenship are calling the Government behavior questionable


There are plenty of None-Muslim , fellas and gals , saying that , will you ban Christians or Educated intellects, its just open debate people question the motives of wars with no sense


Look it is a fact , historic fact , Iraq - Syria - Libya were 100% safe countries that a man could go apply for job and work there make 3,000 USD /Month salary and get free eductaion , free medical care and free housing even.



Is Average American war seeker , no
Is Average American obsessed with oil , no
Is Average American obsessed with religion , no


However, one has to be accountable to policies , being approved by Government

• Yes congressed approved missions to destroy Iraq , to search for WMD , later apologized
• Generals retired and came on record and said hey look we had not clue what we were doing there
  
• Most of ISIS weapons is made in USA

So why don't you impeech the folks responsible for taking USA into 13 Trillion dollar Dept trap ?

So should all folks from Texas should be banned as well because they came forth and admitted hey look I don't know why I was sent to Iraq

So , while most Muslims love America and American people , however they don't understand why Muslim cities are only bombed , and later after 2-10 years delay a apology is issued on some talk show - Hey we are sorry darn it they had no WMD



Baning Muslims will not do much , as they don't sit in Congress and pass resolutions to take USA to wars or take them out on missions to destroy or topple governments


When someone laughs at his mistake its weired because his decision killed crippled many and created mess in region

Really ... he said he was 100% sure

What difference any banning will do ? When Folks like Bush are walking free collecting big fat pay cheque for their mistakes

Should USA ban Connecticut , residents due to Bush ? That would be dumb as American freedom movement itself I think was born in Connecticut

For every idiot like Trump/Bush or others there are credible people like Mr Wesley clark (Retired General that is speaking to his people to tell them hey ... we had no clue what we were doing)

 

[CHD]

let me tell you something American shit, USA is the biggest terrorist the world have ever seen, these are the pictures of countries before USA

 

[yolo2016]

No you are noe changing your statement. You said "Ahmedi style law of Pakistan " ?
Pakistan does not cancel Ahmedi nationality. So your analogy is wrong. Should have thought this through before starting the thread

I have not changed it. It's you who could not comprehend my original post, my friend.

If you have the power to make constitution law to declare the status and validity of people's religious status. Thereby a dramatic change in their rights. Why can't we Americans do what Trump says? i.e. make muslims from certain countries not welcome, and deport those who are terror sympathizers from among us. We promise to not attack , behead and kill them . We will be civilized in kicking them out, or denying them entry to our country

 

[CHD]

I have not changed it. It's you who could not comprehend my original post, my friend.

If you have the power to make constitution law to declare the status and validity pf people's religious status. Thereby a dramatic change in their rights. Why can't we Americans do what Trump says? i.e. make muslims from certain countries not welcome, and deport those who are terror sympathizers from among us. We promise to not attack , behead and kill them . We will be civilized in kicking them out, or denying them entry to our country

America muslims are as much american as you, maybe you should go back to your home in Europe the land of white and english speaking people if you are not feeling safe in USA

 

[yolo2016]

let me tell you something American shit, USA is the biggest terrorist the world have ever seen, these are the pictures of countries before USA

First- those pictures are result of fellow muslim terrorists blowing up the city, not americans. Secondly, if you think it was us, then all the more you would be okay if we banned the likes of you from ever being allowed in our country. Win - Win for both , would you not agree?

America muslims are as much american as you, maybe you should go back to your home in Europe the land of white and english speaking people if you are not feeling safe in USA

How come that rule does not apply for your ahmadis, why do they have a constitutional law denying them? How come you can allow/ deny status in your country, yet we cannot in ours?