#SendAfghanRefugeesBack and #GoAfghaniGo have become a trending hashtag

[pakistani342]

It seems that the Pakistani social media scene has also got into the act.

#SendAfghanRefugeesBack and #GoAfghaniGo have been trending hashtags in the Pakistan related topics.

 

[Kabira]

I keep saying its next to impossible to deport Afghanis. Did Pakistan deport Bengalis who kept coming even after 71 as economic migrants? Nope, in fact BD goverment even refused few Bengalis who were deported....

Secure the border and remove corruption from Nadra. Make difficult for Afghanis to move back and return to Pakistan, plus make it impossible for them to get Pakistani passports.

 

[pakistani342]

I keep saying its next to impossible to deport Afghanis. Did Pakistan deport Bengalis who kept coming even after 71 as economic migrants? Nope, in fact BD goverment even refused few Bengalis who were deported....

Secure the border and remove corruption from Nadra. Make difficult for Afghanis to move back and return to Pakistan, plus make it impossible for them to get Pakistani passports.

mmmm other countries have no problem deporting people -- but perhaps you are right -- we are so incompetent at everything that we cannot even control our immigration policy.

But then again Bengalis were not hostile people -- Afghans on the other hand are unique in their hatred of Pakistanis -- plus there has never been a popular backlash against Benaglis, against Afghans' it seems the sentiment will only snowball.

One can wish.

 

[pakistani342]

Bonglas were one beghairat people who kept coming like rats even after 71....

If someone hate us he should stay where he is....

And there was backclash against Bengalis, if GoP didn't do something at that time then Karachi would have been majority bengali city by now.

Are there estimates on how many Bengalis there are in Pakistan ?

Pakistanis welcomed Afghans -- not realizing that they are inviting back-stabbers

 

[Echo_419]

It seems that the Pakistani social media scene has also got into the act.

#SendAfghanRefugeesBack and #GoAfghaniGo have been trending hashtags in the Pakistan related topics.

Afghanistan is your neighbour where will it go.What about values like Islamic brotherhood

 

[pakistani342]

Afghanistan is your neighbour where will it go.What about values like Islamic brotherhood

Whey don't they go to India -- Indians and Afghans love each other -- everybody is happy.
Afghans happy
Indians happy
Pakistanis happy

 

[Kabira]

mmm, but for such a large demographic -- it surely must be documented -- even estimates by journalists, reports, etc?

From wiki, main source website does not work anymore.

"By 1995 however, continuous migration led it to cross the 2,500,000 mark. During the administration of Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, some top advisers became concerned with the large Bangladeshi migrant population, afraid they could become second largest group in Karachi after Urdu-speaking Muhajir people and disturb sensitive demographics. Accordingly, Bhutto ordered a crackdown and deportation on Bangladeshi immigrants. Benazir Bhutto action strained and created tensions in Bangladesh–Pakistan relations, with Khaleda Zia, who was in power in Dhaka during the time, refusing to accept the deportees and reportedly sending two planeloads back towards Pakistan and Muslim political parties in Pakistan also criticized Bhutto and dubbing the crackdown as anti-Islamic. She was ultimately forced to abandon the order.[5]"

Bengalis in Pakistan - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

See this

Muslim political parties in Pakistan also criticized Bhutto and dubbing the crackdown as anti-Islamic. She was ultimately forced to abandon the order.[5]"

Same thing will happen when GoP force Afghanis, big hearted Pakistanis will cry once again.

 

[pakistani342]

mmm, but for such a large demographic -- it surely must be documented -- even estimates by journalists, reports, etc?



A quick look at wikipedia states 100,000 -- 500,000 people which would seem a more plausible figure.

Further, Pakistanis are not unwelcome in Bangladesh -- you know many Pakistani Industrialists have set up factories in Bangladesh due to better operation conditions.

There is (justified) hostility against Pakistanis by some quarters but nothing comparable to how Afghans hate us.

Plus it is not Bengali drugs that are poisoning Pakistani Children.

 

[Echo_419]

Whey don't they go to India -- Indians and Afghans love each other -- everybody is happy.
Afghans happy
Indians happy
Pakistanis happy

We already are clearing your mess in BD

 

[Kabira]

Further, Pakistanis are not unwelcome in Bangladesh -- you know many Pakistani Industrialists have set up factories in Bangladesh due to better operation conditions.

There is (justified) hostility against Pakistanis by some quarters but nothing comparable to how Afghans hate us.

Plus it is not Bengali drugs that are poisoning Pakistani Children.

I am just giving you example of how its impossible for Pakistan to deport Afghanis forcefully.

 

[pakistani342]

We already are clearing your mess in BD

Forgive me or wasn't it India that intervened in the internal matters of a sovereign nation?

I am just giving you example of how its impossible for Pakistan to deport Afghanis forcefully.

I don't think it is impossible -- what needs to be done is to make sure Afghans leave themselves for example:

1. Do not allow Afghans to rent property
2. Do not let them attend schools
3. Do not give them access to public services

It will address the problem in a large part -- similar to how some local counties and states are dealing with illegal aliens in the US.

Forgive me or wasn't it India that intervened in the internal matters of a sovereign nation?



I don't think it is impossible -- what needs to be done is to make sure Afghans leave themselves for example:

1. Do not allow Afghans to rent property
2. Do not let them attend schools
3. Do not give them access to public services

It will address the problem in a large part -- similar to how some local counties and states are dealing with illegal aliens in the US.

50,000 Afghans cross daily at the Torkham crossing
-- mostly without papers -- disallow that.

Forgive me or wasn't it India that intervened in the internal matters of a sovereign nation?



I don't think it is impossible -- what needs to be done is to make sure Afghans leave themselves for example:

1. Do not allow Afghans to rent property
2. Do not let them attend schools
3. Do not give them access to public services

It will address the problem in a large part -- similar to how some local counties and states are dealing with illegal aliens in the US.



50,000 Afghans cross daily at the Torkham crossing
-- mostly without papers -- disallow that.

Another anecdote, my mom lives in Gulberg Lahore -- the Afghans intimidate her neighborhood, can you believe it in Gulberg

 

[halupridol]

I keep saying its next to impossible to deport Afghanis. Did Pakistan deport Bengalis who kept coming even after 71 as economic migrants? Nope, in fact BD goverment even refused few Bengalis who were deported....

Secure the border and remove corruption from Nadra. Make difficult for Afghanis to move back and return to Pakistan, plus make it impossible for them to get Pakistani passports.

thats a nice tactic,,,isnt it
aur konse afghan refugees ke barey me baat kar rahe ho,,aur 5 saal ruko jao,,,phir woh tumhare apne pashto speakers ban jaenge

 

[Kabira]

thats a nice tactic,,,isnt it
aur konse afghan refugees ke barey me baat kar rahe ho,,aur 5 saal ruko jao,,,phir woh tumhare apne pashto speakers ban jaenge

How is Modi deporting Bengalis? I feel if hindutva leader can't deport muslim Bengalis from India then i don't see much hope left in GoP.

 

[EL LOBO]

GO KABLI GO----- GO NAMAK HARAM GO

 

[halupridol]

How is Modi deporting Bengalis? I feel if hindutva leader can't deport muslim Bengalis from India then i don't see much hope left in GoP.

politicians ki bato par bharosa kon karta hae,,,,,n not bengalis,,,,,illegal bangladeshis,,,,,,,
i forsee a similar situation in Pakistan with Afghan refugees,,,,,,pastho leaders will use them as vote banks in near future,,,,beware