What's new

Returning to N. Korea: Defectors double back

Reashot Xigwin

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 20, 2012
Messages
5,747
Reaction score
0
Shin Hyon-hee, The Korea Herald | World | Thu, November 15 2012, 8:01 PM


North Korean defectors Kim Kwang-hyok and Ko Jong-nam dreamed of a life free from repression and hunger.

Nearly four years later they found themselves at the bottom of the social ladder, suffering from financial difficulties, prejudice and social isolation.

That was the “miserable life” in the South the couple described at a news conference in Pyongyang on November 8 after they returned to the North with their 2-year-old son Se-han.

According to the North’s official Korean Central News Agency, Kim, 27, and wife Ko, 30, said they “were taken away to South Korea by dint of gimmicks, appeasement and manipulation of brokers and agents” of its intelligence agency and aware that their stay “would only bring death to them”.

Kim’s family is the latest in a recent string of North Korean defectors returning to their impoverished home, stoking concerns over their resettlement and adaptability in the better-off, democratic South.

In June, the KCNA reported a similar case of another defector who went back on foot. It claimed that Park Jong-suk was “disillusioned” with South Korean society and dragged into the “wrong ideological state” by operatives here.

In May, Chon Yong-chol triggered a furore after claiming that he was directed by a group of defectors, Seoul’s spy agency and the US to blow up a statue in a border city of its national founder Kim Il-sung.

“I regret that already three similar redefection incidents have occurred this year. We will make greater efforts and pay closer attention to help defectors better adjust to our society,” said Unification Ministry spokesperson Kim Hyung-suk.

Kim said his agency is investigating the reason for their return, dismissing the news reports as “groundless and absurd”. The regime habitually mobilises its propaganda machine, glorifying its leaders’ achievements and casting South Koreans as victims of capitalism.

Analysts say the rare conferences are more likely designed to reinforce security control and send a warning to other defectors here, who would generally be incarcerated, tortured or slain in prison camps if caught or forcibly repatriated.

As the new leadership tightens its grip, the number of new defectors here dropped sharply to 1,202 in the first 10 months of the year, compared with last year’s total 2,706.

“The state media appears to propagate the North’s system by emphasising that the South is not a livable place given that most North Koreans know there are people defecting,” said Koh Yu-hwan, a North Korean studies professor at Dongguk University in Seoul.

“With the Kim Jong-un regime taking off, it’s also probably aimed at boosting hopes and expectations for a new era.”

Some observers speculate that the couple may have been captured as it has happened before while helping other defectors in border towns in China. Then they could have also agreed to hold a press call in return for lighter penalties, they say.

Some members of a Daegu-based civic group reportedly said that Kim and Ko were striving hard for a better living such as by taking a six-month computer training course though the husband had been on and off the payroll due to health issues.

Kim’s mother and younger brother still live in Daegu.

“While watching the reports, I felt that they may have been sent here by the regime as more people escape and yearn for life in the South. Or they had a hard time adapting here and went back thinking of playing double or nothing and then realised that they had to pump out lies to survive there,” said Kang Chul-ho, a Christian minister who fled the North in 1992.

Nonetheless, the young couple’s story may provide a lesson.

Defectors here have reported a wide range of social and financial problems. Cultural and educational gaps could take years to overcome. Prejudice among South Koreans is another factor as politics and ideology frame them despite their common ethnicity.

A 2011 survey on 8,299 defectors by the North Korean Refugees Foundation showed that more than 30 per cent earn less than 1 million won ($919) a month. The jobless rate averaged at 12.1 per cent - 3.3 times the general population’s 3.7 per cent.

In some cases, they opt to leave for a third country such as the US, Britain or Australia, seeking to access a better social safety net and to break free from social exclusion and cutthroat competition with more affluent, better educated South Koreans in an already saturated job market.

Critics have called on the government to set up a system to help defectors land a more secure job and plan for their later years.

While acknowledging the importance of state support, Kang stressed that defectors themselves should make greater efforts to build a better future.

“Everyone goes through this period to adjust to cultural differences, social prejudice and so on. But why bother? You’d better strive to learn and get used to the society you are in. How can the government take care of so many defectors forever?” he told The Korea Herald.

Koh of Dongguk said: “It’s not a matter of support because most problems originate from differences in systems between the two countries. Even if you literally take the re-defectors’ words as reported, they could have difficulties shifting to an active life from passive.”

More than 24,300 North Koreans have arrived in the South since the 1950-53 Korean War, ministry numbers show, largely via China, Thailand and other Southeast Asian countries.

Since a 1997 North Korean refugee law, the central and local governments have rolled out a series of programmes to fund everything from housing to education to job training.

The ministry’s defector-related budget neared 124 billion won this year, making up about 58 per cent of the total.
Real proof that the Grass isn't always greener on the other side:what:
 
North Koreans are slightly better than the S ones.
 
They are not a puppet of uncle sam like the south one.

I rather be a well fed puppet than a free starving men

Look in the eyes of the homeless man Tell me what you see? In the eyes of a jobless man Tell me what you see?
What about the eyes of a prisoner What do you see? Now you've seen it all It is time to make up your mind
Don't try to hide it 'cause I can see it all In your face, yeah It the same questions that I ask myself every time To be or not to be
Do you wanna be a well fed slave or a hungry free man? Do you wanna be a well fed slave or a hungry free man? Do you wanna be a well fed slave or a hungry free man?
What is the point in being free When you can't get no job What is the point in being free When you can't get food
What is the point in going out to work When others can get for free What is the point in being free When you don't have no home
Now you've heard it all It is time to make up your own mind To be or not to be Oh ho ho ho
Do you wanna be a well fed slave or a hungry free man? Do you wanna be a well fed slave or a hungry free man? Do you wanna be a well fed slave or a hungry free man?

LUCKY DUBE - WELL FED SLAVE / HUNGRY FREE MAN LYRICS
 
How many calories does being a "non-puppet" supply at dinner?

What are you talking about?They are poor because they have bad leaders,not because they are not a puppet of US.
 
Commies couldnt cope with the concept that you are expected to work and pay for your needs!
 
Why would we need to compete with everything, the north is better than south, the America is better than commie. We don't need to do that.

WHy could poeple not see it as it is, He just can't adjust to his new life, there are people from China who migrated to America and only come back to China because they are sick of flipping burger for 14.50 an hour. People don't like what they see and is totally different from what they think, then they will go, does that mean American Life is far better than Chinese life? NO, There are people live like a King in America so does there are poeple who live like a king in China, just those people who don't and move to America or Whereever, when they found out this is still the way they ,live and they got fed up and returned. This happened to a lot of Chinese having American Dream. Why can't we just see this case like that?
 
Why would we need to compete with everything, the north is better than south, the America is better than commie. We don't need to do that.

WHy could poeple not see it as it is, He just can't adjust to his new life, there are people from China who migrated to America and only come back to China because they are sick of flipping burger for 14.50 an hour. People don't like what they see and is totally different from what they think, then they will go, does that mean American Life is far better than Chinese life? NO, There are people live like a King in America so does there are poeple who live like a king in China, just those people who don't and move to America or Whereever, when they found out this is still the way they ,live and they got fed up and returned. This happened to a lot of Chinese having American Dream. Why can't we just see this case like that?

That's why I said that the Grass isn't always greener on the other side
 
Real proof that the Grass isn't always greener on the other side:what:
Sure...

BBC News - Are North Koreans really three inches shorter than South Koreans?
"If you look at older Koreans," says Schwekendiek, "we now see a situation where the average South Korean woman is approaching the height of the average North Korean man.

"This is to my knowledge a unique situation, where women become taller than men."

The Dangers of the Coming North Korean Famine - World Report (usnews.com)
One study shows that the average North Korean solider is 10 inches shorter than those in the South Korean military—a sign of chronic acute malnutrition affecting an entire generation of young North Koreans.

Many male defectors returned to North Korea because they would not be able to find wives in the South.
 
Many male defectors returned to North Korea because they would not be able to find wives in the South.

:rofl: That's rich man. There are many factors why people migrate & finding Hot ;) S.Korean wife does not count for a fraction why some Defectors return back to their oppressive regimes
 
Back
Top Bottom