Redrawn map for Muslim world

[Sid]

That is what I call, 'in Mr Ralph Peter's face!' Perhaps, he should get back to some medication instead of this re-drawing of boundaries B.S.

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

One should not take things to heart.

These are what is called "Mind Games".

The only aspect that is worrisome is that it was published in a US Army Magazine!

Therefore, instead of taking it to heart or getting wild, one should think what's up and watch the world events more intently and hopefully those who chart the desitiny of nations apply the antidote.

 

[Sid]

Who's taking it to heart? Who's going 'wild'? Are you?

 

[araz]

They planned, and Allah planned. And Indeed Allah is the gbetter planner.(AlQuran).
As to the muslim world of today, the way we are , we deserve to be beaten even more. when people lose their way and their aims they deserve to be punished the way we are being.
Araz

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

That is too harsh a sentiment, if I may say so.

 

[KashifAsrar]

One should not take things to heart.

These are what is called "Mind Games".

The only aspect that is worrisome is that it was published in a US Army Magazine!

Therefore, instead of taking it to heart or getting wild, one should think what's up and watch the world events more intently and hopefully those who chart the desitiny of nations apply the antidote.

I agree !! It is published in a US Army magazine !! It is no fantasy or co-incedence or political fiction !!! It is a reality !!

They planned, and Allah planned. And Indeed Allah is the gbetter planner.(AlQuran).
As to the muslim world of today, the way we are , we deserve to be beaten even more. when people lose their way and their aims they deserve to be punished the way we are being.
Araz

Yes you are also right arz ..... Unfortunately !!!
Kashif

 

[araz]

firstly sorry for the delayed response.As somebody said "Hamaisha Der Kardeta hun mein"
Brother, realities are harsh. You are very welcome to criticize me but loook at the realities. We have forgotten all that was good in Islam. Humility, piety, fear of Allah, pain for the suffering of the ummah, no superiority of Ajami over Arabi, except in Taqwa, Jehad bil Nafs, lust for knowledge , critical self analysis. I could go on and on. From one great Ummah, we have been degraded into smaller units with larger than life egos.Please look around you. Sindhi, punjabi, Baluch, Afghan, Mohajir,Irani,the list goes on, nobody turns around and says "hey wait, we are muslims first. We are gathered on the basis of the kalima La Ilaha Illallah---.nothing more nothing less.Till that day we will continue to suffer.No education, plenty of money but no planning of what to do with it. No research worth mentioning and most importantly no critical analysis of self and life around oneself. The reaction that we see around us is nationalistic interpretation of Islam, not Islam. This is why I lament and cry at the fate of the Ummah. This is why I feel that every tom dick and harry will succeed against us. We have forgotten our roots and therefore we suffer.
WaSalam
Araz

 

[lulldapull]

I wouldn't mind this map at all. If these ethnicities are unhappy with one another, then so be it. Let everyone be free in his own God-damn country. The mechanations for the first installment of this redrawing is already happening. Iraq, Afghanistan, Iran, Saudi haramia, Turkey and all these countries will be redrawn, and for the better as minorities are being oppressed. The Baloch have decided to cooperate with the World Federalists to make this happen at least for ourselves. Kurdistan would be another fact of life, and half of it is already autonomous, and will declare independance in due time, followed by Darfur and all these independance movements.

 

[Srirangan]

I don't think ethnicities could be a valid basis for countries in the modern era. Look at India, China, United States .. hell Europe is merging - diversity is an asset - order out of chaos - the Romans said it first.

But then that doesn't mean religion can be a valid basis for a nation either. :-S

 

[lulldapull]

I don't think ethnicities could be a valid basis for countries in the modern era. Look at India, China, United States .. hell Europe is merging - diversity is an asset - order out of chaos - the Romans said it first.

But then that doesn't mean religion can be a valid basis for a nation either. :-S

Yeah but we need to look at this situation from a different lens Srirangan! If human rights are being violated and entire nations being forced to go along a failed idea and concept then it makes no sense.

Carve these hollow nations out so there can be peace! The EU is as divided as ever on everything and anything......and wont last.

 

[Srirangan]

Yeah but we need to look at this situation from a different lens Srirangan! If human rights are being violated and entire nations being forced to go along a failed idea and concept then it makes no sense.

Carve these hollow nations out so there can be peace! The EU is as divided as ever on everything and anything......and wont last.

Sure. An independent Baluchistan would be better than the current Quagmire in which the military dictator has to repeat every 2 weeks that the "writ" of the "government" will be "enforced". That's enough testament to the current mess.

But, in a long term perspective, will an independent Baluchistan be sustainable. Perhaps it can. It's got access to warm waters, has mineral resources and can import what it lacks.

Will that mean ethnicity based countries are a good idea? I doubt it. If you are a small country with a not-so-large population, sooner than later you'll find the Arab's or Persians or the Gora's and/or their proxies interfering.

 

[lulldapull]

Sure. An independent Baluchistan would be better than the current Quagmire in which the military dictator has to repeat every 2 weeks that the "writ" of the "government" will be "enforced". That's enough testament to the current mess.

But, in a long term perspective, will an independent Baluchistan be sustainable. Perhaps it can. It's got access to warm waters, has mineral resources and can import what it lacks.

Will that mean ethnicity based countries are a good idea? I doubt it. If you are a small country with a not-so-large population, sooner than later you'll find the Arab's or Persians or the Gora's and/or their proxies interfering.

Yaar we have a hell of a better chance at it than the land-locked Kurds do. We have excellent relations with our neighbours up north including Russia and Afghanistan and Iran is neutral in this conflict (So far).....and we enjoy strong Indian support. Balochistan is rich in NG, coal and minerals. Already the population absolutely hates Punjabi/ Mohajir nexus and this Punjabi military. These guys can't leave their contonments and go out unescorted, or we kill these bastards. Same in Waziristan and the entire western NWFP. Whatever it will be yaar whether with these American terrorists or with Russia's help, we will get our independance one day. Punjabastan is dead for us!

 

[sparten]

Punjabastan is dead for us
I really don't think anyone in Pakistan cares a hoot what an Iranian thinks.

 

[EagleEyes]

Baluchistan will gain its independence how? With the few guns, and the few terrorists who dont even have a proper dress code?

 

[Srirangan]

Baluchistan will gain its independence how? With the few guns, and the few terrorists who dont even have a proper dress code?

Even if it does, is it sustainable? Does it have institutions which the country can rely on?