What's new

Qasba ali Garh killings 1986

W.11

BANNED
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
15,032
Reaction score
-32
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan

on the anniversary of qazba aligarh killings 14th december 1986

1) action was taken to curb drug dealers of sohrab goth

2) the retaliation of drug dealers came in the form of ethnic violence from sohrab goth when 50 people were mercilessly butchered and women violated on linguistic bases

3) police/rangers/army remained effortless to stop the killings and just kept spectating

4) no justice has been provided by supreme court till now, the drug dealers in sohrab goth and its status as no go area remains intact

BbKB8v5CQAA-JEg.jpg:large


 
Last edited:
Qasba Aligarh Massacre – a forgotten story

It has been more than a decade and a half but by actually going back to what really happened haunts me to the core. I didn’t know the extent of this massacre until only recently, yes, I am guilty as charged and it was only recently I met some of the survivors out of an accident to realize what really happened to the residents of a remote place named, Qasba Aligarh in Karachi. It really was a "genocide".


Qasba Aligarh is located with-in Karachi limits and consists of basically poor and lower middle class Mohajir families living side by side by Pashtoons. Qasba Aligarh was initially made as a colony for journalists where amenity plots were handed out to the residents but due to the distance from the city most journalists sold their plots or give out to their relatives mainly Muslim Migrants from India to Pakistan.


Background

It all started from an administrative decision from the than Governor Sindh, Gen.Retd. Jahandad Khan who took the decision on the orders from the federal government to start an operation at what we know as Al-Asif Square at Sorab Goth, Karachi (an illegally encroached properties by Afghan migrants during the late and early 1980s). During the Afghan War in the 1980’s against the Soviet Occupation and General Zia(s) manufactured Islam and Islamization of Society more then 4 million refugees from Afghanistan were welcomed in Pakistan as temporary refugees. Around 3/5th of these refugees moved to Karachi.
When the new migrants mostly Pashtuns from Afghanistan and K.P started to occupy areas allocated to the old migrants - tensions started to brew. One must also add that the conflict in Orangi town and Qasba area intensified after Biharis were repatriated from former East Pakistan where most of them were re-settled by Pakistani government in Orangi Town and adjoining area. Unfortunately, it was the time when ethnic violence intensified in Karachi. The Biharis which had most migrated from former East Pakistan used their Al-Badar and Al-Shams experience to safe-guard themselves while ditching Islamists Jamaat-e-Islami Islamists joining newly formed ethno-political entity, Mohajir Qaumi Movement (MQM) in a new Pakistan. The tensions were high and over priceless land: hence, both MQM and ANP representatives of Mohajirs and Pashtuns capitalized.

The Operation at Al-Asif Square
13th December 1986
Governor Sindh Gen (retd) Jahandad finally called for an operation against drug barons and illegal weapons at Al-Asif Square after US Consul General pointed towards piles of weapons and drugs being stocked in the area. Finally a committee to over-look operation at Al-Asif Square was formed consisting of Governor Sindh, Deputy Commissioner Karachi, IG Sindh, and CC-Karachi. The idea was to remove all encroached areas; clear the area and re-locate refugees to National Highway.

The Reaction
14th December 1986
The operation at Al-Asif Square was seen by ANP which represented Pashtuns as an operation against its constituency and ethnic riots broke out where Pashtuns after 1962 elections, attacked Mohajir localities and Mohajirs retaliated. These ethnic rioting were confined to slums however, affected all of Karachi: where resident's lived in fear of an attack. It is to be noted that Qasba was one of the most tense places in the city and there had been intelligence reports of rioting in the are and police and at-least two fully armed army units were deployed in the area to prevent rioting.

The Killing Spree
15th December 1986
Amid tensions and high-alert - when Karachi slept, the people of Qasba mourned; not from drone attacks or from a foreign force but from it's barbaric neighbors who were drowned in hate. While the numbers are sketchy but from 120-300 people where murdered in Qasba Aligarh and around 600 were injured.


“They came inside out houses and asked for men”, “they killed indiscriminately with knifes and guns chanting Allah’o’Akber as if we were infidels” said one of the survivors who lost her father and elder brother sobbing and she was correct. Astonishingly mosques were used to mobilize people to kill and there were speeches and sermons given against the people living in Qasba Aligarh by pseudo Mullah’s that day branding Mohajirs as “Infidels” and that “killing them would take one to heaven”. .

Mohammad Ibrahim another survivor who lost his elder brother told us that “they came in and started burning our houses, kicking the babies, raping our women and killing anyone in front of them …”.

The details are not sketchy at all. On asking the survivors and those who were in administrative structure in Sindh during the time revealed a shocking tale of how the Army Unit deployed at Qasba was mysteriously pulled out just before the massacre and how police never reacted while the police station was less than a kilometer away from Qasba? All these questions were raised by the people of the area ; facts which are undeniable.

The army division which deployed to the Qasba Coloney was mysteriously pulled back just two hours before the incident took place whom you do think is responsible? I asked to a top administrative official who refused to be named and his reply was “whom you do think has the power to call the army back?, ofcourse the than Core Commander Karachi.

Justice Sajjad Ali Shah the former Chief Justice of Supreme Court later wrote an inquiry report who criticized, “army, administrative and governor’s role in the event and clearly wrote in the report, “that it is the worst kind of massacre I had ever witnessed, where women, children and men from Mohajir community were slaughtered by people from illegal immigrants and Core Commander Karachi should have questioned as to why Army was asked to retreat approximately 2 hours before the incident took take. There clearly seems to be a foul-play”.
 
Governor Sindh Gen (retd) Jahandad finally called for an operation against drug barons and illegal weapons at Al-Asif Square after US Consul General pointed towards piles of weapons and drugs being stocked in the area.

Lets hear what has changed since then .

Astonishingly mosques were used to mobilize people to kill and there were speeches and sermons given against the people living in Qasba Aligarh by pseudo Mullah’s that day branding Mohajirs as “Infidels” and that “killing them would take one to heaven”

The history repeats itself , I have seen videos from Kati Pahari in which the same is being done before the killing ensued . Muslims , we say ? @FaujHistorian
 
Oi @Secur - Whats this incident about ? :what:

What happened in Qasba Ali Garh in '86 ? :undecided:

A blunder , just like many the country has done . FM Ayub and Gen. Zia together are responsible for many other things , than they are given credit of .

The story's true to the core , read it .
 
A blunder , just like many the country has done . FM Ayub and Gen. Zia together are responsible for many other things , than they are given credit of .

The story's true to the core , read it .

What happened ? :what:

How did this start ? :unsure:

Just because Pukhtoons & Muhajir were inhabiting adjacent neighborhood & Land Mafiyas popped up - Sh*t thats messed up !
 
What happened ? :what:

How did this start ? :unsure:

Just because Pukhtoons & Muhajir were inhabiting adjacent neighborhood & Land Mafiyas popped up - Sh*t thats messed up !

A Govt operation against rampant gun and drugs mafia in Al Asif ( which is present there even today ) turned into an ethnic strife and mass killing of Muhajirs - brewing for long but exploited by the opportunists on that day . The problem here is that the armed units deployed to protect the people living there were called two hours back by none other than the Core Commander of Karachi and the terrorists were allowed to kill the people of a single community - the whole night and even during the afternoon . Men , Women , Children , no discrimination at all . The religion's part important , always the mobilizing force ! The other problem is that they didn't have guns to defend themselves whilst the other side had its " jewelry " with it .
 
A Govt operation against rampant gun and drugs mafia in Al Asif ( which is present there even today ) turned into an ethnic strife and mass killing of Muhajirs - brewing for long but exploited by the opportunists on that day . The problem here is that the armed units deployed to protect the people living there were called two hours back by none other than the Core Commander of Karachi and the terrorists were allowed to kill the people of a single community - the whole night and even during the afternoon . Men , Women , Children , no discrimination at all . The religion's part important , always the mobilizing force ! The other problem is that they didn't have guns to defend themselves whilst the other side had its " jewelry " with it .

Why do all these foOked up things always happen in Karachi ?

What happens to Pakistanis living there that on something as trivial as 'real estate' they're willing to invoke everyone from religion to ethnicity & kill their fellow man ?

I mean Islamabad, Lahore, Rawalpindi are three of the largest or most important cities of Pakistan brimming with non-ethnic Punjabis & Punjabis - I can't recall any community-to-community turf war happening there !

Here in Lahore we've got Pukhtoons popping up left, right & center - Woh bhiii insaaan keii bacheiii bun kar rehteiii hain aur hum bhiii !

What in god's name happens to us Pakistanis in Karachi of all places whose diversity should've ensured that these parochial notions of 'ethnicity or linguistic' grouping would've been made redundant due to exposure of different ethnic & linguistic groups !
 
What in god's name happens to us Pakistanis in Karachi of all places whose diversity should've ensured that these parochial notions of 'ethnicity or linguistic' grouping would've been made redundant due to exposure of different ethnic & linguistic groups !

I will say no more , but please next time , ask the top brass to not try to change the demographics intentionally and on a mega scale , be it the FM Ayub who had to resort to violence to control the supporters of the sister of Quaid-e-Azam and encourage mass migrations for no reason or the Commander of the Faithful Gen. Zia-ul-Haq who had to ensure that Afghans are settled in Karachi and do all sorts of criminal activities .

I will tell you why . Diversity is a delicate thing , this is why Karachi's volatile , mate . You will not persecute/oppress a group of people and then expect them to live harmonically with you , despite the fact that they are patriots whilst the refugees from the other side of the Khyber Pass aren't . Now this is a sensitive thing , mate . A lot changed after Pakistan was formed , the initial spirit died down with time , Armstrong . The " migrants " were suddenly considered some aliens or foreigners and tried to be put down . The " historical residents of Sindh " thing was on the rise . You couldn't get the stranded Pakistanis back , right ? Why do you think it was ? . The quota system , the killings , the migrations , the operations , where do you think they are getting at ? . I will tell you a nice little fact , the Rangers today finds it easy to enter Azizabad , Mukka Chowk etc to conduct operations but cant enter the same Sohrab Goth Al Asif , Banaras , Kati Pahari , there's no resistance to be faced in the former case but the latter will go ugly the moment they see the " arrowed number plates " and will take their jewelry out :D

I am not interested in any racial or linguistic politics but that is the way things are here . At least try to be balanced , equal and neutral .
 
Why do all these foOked up things always happen in Karachi ?

What happens to Pakistanis living there that on something as trivial as 'real estate' they're willing to invoke everyone from religion to ethnicity & kill their fellow man ?

I mean Islamabad, Lahore, Rawalpindi are three of the largest or most important cities of Pakistan brimming with non-ethnic Punjabis & Punjabis - I can't recall any community-to-community turf war happening there !

Here in Lahore we've got Pukhtoons popping up left, right & center - Woh bhiii insaaan keii bacheiii bun kar rehteiii hain aur hum bhiii !

What in god's name happens to us Pakistanis in Karachi of all places whose diversity should've ensured that these parochial notions of 'ethnicity or linguistic' grouping would've been made redundant due to exposure of different ethnic & linguistic groups !

karachi is the single biggest centre of drug business

 
@Armstrong

The night's young , mate ? Lets hear another one . The infamous " Kati Pahari " has an extremely famous place where " Cannabis " is sold up on the mountain and near the graveyard , everybody knows it in the area and outside it , there's a long line of customers waiting to buy some of the revered resin , but the literally adjacent police station well doesn't . :D This is why the city's bathed in blood every other day because you do not consider people equal , you have your biases while dealing with criminals/terrorists . How do you then expect the operation to be successful and the law and order be restored ?
 
At least try to be balanced , equal and neutral .

I thought I was accusing all of you equally & with complete impartiality ! :cray:

No but I often find this curious - It is often quoted that 5 million immigrants came into Pakistan (West Pakistan) of them 1.5 million of them went to Karachi, Hyderabad & the adjoining areas whilst the rest settled primarily in Punjab - thats 3.5 million here who would've grown in size tremendously over the past 65 years because we do breed like rabbits after all !

Not all of them were Punjabis from East-Punjab - Quite a few Kashmiris from Up North & Biharis & other North Indian Ethnicities from North & North-Eastern Parts of India came & settled here - I know many of them !

We weren't spared the machinations of opportunistic foOks who ruled over us either in the political stream or the bureaucratic ones, either !

How is it then that these things happen in Karachi & nowhere else with this much intensity ?

Don't get me wrong - I condemn it & I don't for a second think that I'm not deeply..deeply disturbed by it or I'm looking to score brownie points here in a Lahore vs Karachi thing but I can't for the life of me grasp what is it about Karachi that would drive people to such madness not once, not twice but countless times !

What was it about Immigrants in Punjab that they assimilated to their New Home with such ease despite maintaining their linguistic & cultural uniqueness & what is it about the Locals that they never initiated an 'Us & Them' shameless display of parochialism !

What happens to these same ethnicities in Karachi of all places that not only has a history of being a metropolitan city but also resides in a province which is often dubbed the Land of the Sufis - What more does one need as ingredients of Inclusivity ?

Where did everything go so terribly wrong ?

P.S I haven't the faintest idea of the names of the places you took - Sohrab Goyath or something - What are they ?

@Armstrong

The night's young , mate ? Lets hear another one . The infamous " Kati Pahari " has an extremely famous place where " Cannabis " is sold up on the mountain and near the graveyard , everybody knows it in the area and outside it , there's a long line of customers waiting to buy some of the revered resin , but the literally adjacent police station well doesn't . :D This is why the city's bathed in blood every other day because you do not consider people equal , you have your biases while dealing with criminals/terrorists . How do you then expect the operation to be successful and the law and order be restored ?

Yaraaa I'm curious why there was a need for an Operation to begin with ?

No amount of drugs can be sold in Karachi that aren't present in the rest of Pakistan as well & the break down of Governance is the same all over !
 
I thought I was accusing all of you equally & with complete impartiality ! :cray:

No but I often find this curious - It is often quoted that 5 million immigrants came into Pakistan (West Pakistan) of them 1.5 million of them went to Karachi, Hyderabad & the adjoining areas whilst the rest settled primarily in Punjab - thats 3.5 million here who would've grown in size tremendously over the past 65 years because we do breed like rabbits after all !

Not all of them were Punjabis from East-Punjab - Quite a few Kashmiris from Up North & Biharis & other North Indian Ethnicities from North & North-Eastern Parts of India came & settled here - I know many of them !

We weren't spared the machinations of opportunistic foOks who ruled over us either in the political stream or the bureaucratic ones, either !

How is it then that these things happen in Karachi & nowhere else with this much intensity ?

Don't get me wrong - I condemn it & I don't for a second think that I'm not deeply..deeply disturbed by it or I'm looking to score brownie points here in a Lahore vs Karachi thing but I can't for the life of me grasp what is it about Karachi that would drive people to such madness not once, not twice but countless times !

What was it about Immigrants in Punjab that they assimilated to their New Home with such ease despite maintaining their linguistic & cultural uniqueness & what is it about the Locals that they never initiated an 'Us & Them' shameless display of parochialism !

What happens to these same ethnicities in Karachi of all places that not only has a history of being a metropolitan city but also resides in a province which is often dubbed the Land of the Sufis - What more does one need as ingredients of Inclusivity ?

Where did everything go so terribly wrong ?

P.S I haven't the faintest idea of the names of the places you took - Sohrab Goyath or something - What are they ?

Well , I wasn't talking about you when I said to be " neutral , equal and balanced " , bon ami . It was a reference to the top brass/army/politicians . Where did you get the idea from ? I know my own country's history - the undiluted one . I can also understand the case of Kashmiris and people from other ethnicity that settled in Punjab and well history tells us , never faced any discrimination . The same wasn't true for people of Karachi who were subjected to a lot of things - the reaction of course was there . Understand the importance of the financial hub of our country , every single goddamn leader wants to have the pound of flesh . The population is huge and the demographics are rife for the drug business to thrive . The rivalries are there to make sure , the weapon dealers get their money . The politicians and the mafias made sure that the ethnic violence was always there to exploit and it was always easy to create an insecurity here because of the extreme diversity . Didn't you once say that you are sure that Bengalis just didn't go mad one day ? Apply the same logic here .

I know , you condemn it . Unfortunately , there are thousand others , who would have it here as another incident in the massive history of Pakistan . The people just do not want to learn , mate . They want to overlook , there's apathy , there's indifference . If a Punjabi is killed in Baluchistan , none other than the Punjabi himself would give a darn , that is the problem . Though , every killing that takes places in the country because of the opiate of the masses ( religion ) or the childish blood significance and domination angers me to the core . It all started with Ayub Khan as the history tell us , the Muhajirs at that time were firm supporters of Fatima Jinnah , of course the later Field Marshal didn't like it and used force , did no good . Others factor then piled up on that and the insecurity ( although largely untrue ) grew a plenty . The result is right in front of you . I hate MQM for its policies , but it doesn't take me long to understand why people vote for them . You have instilled fear of being " not of the land " in them , research , Armstrong .

P.S The areas I just named - the second list are the ones in which you cant enter wearing your standard Jeans-T Shirts and hope to leave with your personal belongings or on a wrong time , even life :D Come online , lets talk .

Yaraaa I'm curious why there was a need for an Operation to begin with ?

No amount of drugs can be sold in Karachi that aren't present in the rest of Pakistan as well & the break down of Governance is the same all over !

Cmon , why shouldn't they have operated against it ? The question you should be asking is " Why did the armed deployed units leave under the order of Core Commander of Karachi just two hours before killings began " even though the area was recognized as a major risk and the administration anticipated violence ?
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom