What's new

Pakistan stops bid on Diamer-Bhasha Dam. Beijing placed strict conditions including ownership of the

ghazi52

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Joined
Mar 21, 2007
Messages
102,868
Reaction score
106
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Pakistan stops bid on Diamer-Bhasha Dam in CPEC. Beijing placed strict conditions including ownership of the project,

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan has withdrawn its request to include the $14-billion Diamer-Bhasha Dam in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) framework after Beijing placed strict conditions including ownership of the project, said Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) Chairman Muzammil Hussain on Tuesday.

“Chinese conditions for financing the Diamer-Bhasha Dam were not doable and against our interests,” said Hussain while briefing the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on the status of the mega water and power project.

He said the Chinese conditions were about taking ownership of the project, operation and maintenance cost and securitisation of the Diamer-Bhasha project by pledging another operational dam.

These conditions were unacceptable, therefore, Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi approved a summary to finance the dam from the country’s own resources, he said.

The issue of excluding the Diamer-Bhasha Dam from the CPEC framework also featured in the Cabinet Committee on CPEC which met last week.

The Wapda chairman and the water resources secretary informed the premier that the only way out was to fund the much-delayed project from domestic resources.

The sixth meeting of the Joint Cooperation Committee (JCC) – the highest decision-making body of CPEC – had agreed to establish a mechanism to develop hydroelectric power projects along the northern side of the Indus River including the Diamer-Bhasha project, according to minutes of the deliberations.

Pakistan decided to take the dam off the table just days before the seventh JCC meeting, which is scheduled for November 21 in Islamabad. The JCC will review progress on the implementation of already approved projects and decide the fate of new schemes.

Currently, about 15 prioritised energy projects valuing at $22.4 billion and having 11,110-megawatt generation capacity are part of the CPEC framework. Among these, only two are hydroelectric power projects with cumulative capacity of 1,590MW. Most of the CPEC energy projects are based on coal.

Pakistan has been struggling to raise money from international institutions amid Indian opposition to the project. There were hopes that Pakistan may finally complete the project after including it in the CPEC framework whose worth has already swelled to $60 billion.

Ground-breaking of the Diamer-Bhasha Dam has been performed five times in the past 15 years.

Neither the World Bank and Asian Development Bank (ADB) nor China would finance the dam, therefore, the government decided to construct the reservoir from its own resources, said Water Resources Secretary Shumail Khawaja.

The Wapda chairman blamed the ADB for the delay, saying the bank first destroyed the project and later declined to provide loan. The ADB was of the view that the project was located in a disputed territory, he said.

The project will have the capacity to generate 4,500MW of electricity in addition to the storage capacity for six million acre feet of water, which the country desperately needs due to shrinking storages.

The Wapda chairman said the project cost would hover around $14 billion and the prime minister had agreed to split the scheme into dam storage and power generation.

Federal govt will treat all parts of the country equally: PM

According to the new financing plan, he said, the federal government would provide Rs30 billion per annum over the next nine years from the Public Sector Development Programme, taking total federal contribution to Rs270 billion.

Hussain said Wapda would generate 20% of equity from its own resources whereas financing for constructing power plants would be arranged from commercial sources.

Construction work on the dam site would begin next year and the government would complete it in nine years, he said. Work on the power generation site will begin two and a half years after the start of work on the dam.

The Wapda chairman said 969MW Neelum-Jhelum and 1,410MW Tarbela extension projects would be commissioned in February next year

 
.
This is a most encouraging development. It means that Pakistani decision-makers have not been swept off their feet by Chinese broad-brush approaches, and that they still carefully apply their minds before coming to any decision. In this mesalliance, only such constant vigil will preserve the smaller partner.

Well done.
 
.
So, who is going to fund the project now? India or the US with similar or worse conditions?

No doubt, Pakistan will return to China for investment.
 
.
Pakistan stops bid on Diamer-Bhasha Dam in CPEC. Beijing placed strict conditions including ownership of the project,

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan has withdrawn its request to include the $14-billion Diamer-Bhasha Dam in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) framework after Beijing placed strict conditions including ownership of the project, said Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) Chairman Muzammil Hussain on Tuesday.

“Chinese conditions for financing the Diamer-Bhasha Dam were not doable and against our interests,” said Hussain while briefing the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on the status of the mega water and power project.

He said the Chinese conditions were about taking ownership of the project, operation and maintenance cost and securitisation of the Diamer-Bhasha project by pledging another operational dam.

These conditions were unacceptable, therefore, Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi approved a summary to finance the dam from the country’s own resources, he said.

The issue of excluding the Diamer-Bhasha Dam from the CPEC framework also featured in the Cabinet Committee on CPEC which met last week.

The Wapda chairman and the water resources secretary informed the premier that the only way out was to fund the much-delayed project from domestic resources.

The sixth meeting of the Joint Cooperation Committee (JCC) – the highest decision-making body of CPEC – had agreed to establish a mechanism to develop hydroelectric power projects along the northern side of the Indus River including the Diamer-Bhasha project, according to minutes of the deliberations.

Pakistan decided to take the dam off the table just days before the seventh JCC meeting, which is scheduled for November 21 in Islamabad. The JCC will review progress on the implementation of already approved projects and decide the fate of new schemes.

Currently, about 15 prioritised energy projects valuing at $22.4 billion and having 11,110-megawatt generation capacity are part of the CPEC framework. Among these, only two are hydroelectric power projects with cumulative capacity of 1,590MW. Most of the CPEC energy projects are based on coal.

Pakistan has been struggling to raise money from international institutions amid Indian opposition to the project. There were hopes that Pakistan may finally complete the project after including it in the CPEC framework whose worth has already swelled to $60 billion.

Ground-breaking of the Diamer-Bhasha Dam has been performed five times in the past 15 years.

Neither the World Bank and Asian Development Bank (ADB) nor China would finance the dam, therefore, the government decided to construct the reservoir from its own resources, said Water Resources Secretary Shumail Khawaja.

The Wapda chairman blamed the ADB for the delay, saying the bank first destroyed the project and later declined to provide loan. The ADB was of the view that the project was located in a disputed territory, he said.

The project will have the capacity to generate 4,500MW of electricity in addition to the storage capacity for six million acre feet of water, which the country desperately needs due to shrinking storages.

The Wapda chairman said the project cost would hover around $14 billion and the prime minister had agreed to split the scheme into dam storage and power generation.

Federal govt will treat all parts of the country equally: PM

According to the new financing plan, he said, the federal government would provide Rs30 billion per annum over the next nine years from the Public Sector Development Programme, taking total federal contribution to Rs270 billion.

Hussain said Wapda would generate 20% of equity from its own resources whereas financing for constructing power plants would be arranged from commercial sources.

Construction work on the dam site would begin next year and the government would complete it in nine years, he said. Work on the power generation site will begin two and a half years after the start of work on the dam.

The Wapda chairman said 969MW Neelum-Jhelum and 1,410MW Tarbela extension projects would be commissioned in February next year




Source??????
 
.
So, who is going to fund the project now? India or the US with similar or worse conditions?

No doubt, Pakistan will return to China for investment.

Actually it is a very good decision IF it is made in the favor of Pakistani interests.

The good thing about China is that they make decisions putting their self interests first BUT they don't force Pakistan and let Pakistani administration take decision if it suits Pakistani interests, unfortunately this is not the case with US, World Bank, EU, IMF, fundings. All their fundings come with restrictions and conditions.
 
.
This is a most encouraging development. It means that Pakistani decision-makers have not been swept off their feet by Chinese broad-brush approaches, and that they still carefully apply their minds before coming to any decision. In this mesalliance, only such constant vigil will preserve the smaller partner.

Well done.

Quite frankly I would want us to fund this dam personally. Right now we ate throwing everything behind China and China is of course going to ask for some consideration in return of such investments.

I personally understand the point of view of pakistan and the economic concessions we did due the economic state of pakistan in 2013 due to the governance and security issues of 2008-2013.

Yes it is indeed a good step.

The thing is in the end pakistan will have to learn how to generate its own resources rather than seek extreme aid from foreign backers and this is a great opportunity to do just that. A huge project is being worked on, we got funds coming, energy problem is being resolved, transit routes are being built and this is a golden opportunity to take control of economic reigns and showcase capability to create resources by itself even if that requires for pakistan to surrender ego and move towards more self sufficiency.

However I believe the govt is oblivious to this and there is little to no effort. I believe we are again entering the " Allah rakhay " ( God preserve) stage rather than the " he helps only those who help themselves.
 
.
This is a most encouraging development. It means that Pakistani decision-makers have not been swept off their feet by Chinese broad-brush approaches, and that they still carefully apply their minds before coming to any decision. In this mesalliance, only such constant vigil will preserve the smaller partner.

Well done.

Actually It Is Only Indian Perception That Pakistan Is Giving Everything Away To China.When It Came To Protecting It's Interests Pakistan Placed Anti Dumping Duties on Chinese Steel and Tiles.
 
.
Shows Pakistan not willing to completely sell out. This might set a precedent for future large projects to be funded in house if foreign option has too many strings/sovereignty issues.
 
. .
Actually it is a very good decision IF it is made in the favor of Pakistani interests.

The good thing about China is that they make decisions putting their self interests first BUT they don't force Pakistan and let Pakistani administration take decision if it suits Pakistani interests, unfortunately this is not the case with US, World Bank, EU, IMF, fundings. All their fundings come with restrictions and conditions.

China placed conditions on this project. It says so in the first paragraph of article:

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan has withdrawn its request to include the $14-billion Diamer-Bhasha Dam in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) framework after Beijing placed strict conditions including ownership of the project, said Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) Chairman Muzammil Hussain on Tuesday.

How is this different than what US, World Bank, IMF, or anyone do when they are financing a project? They impose conditions. After all, they are taking the financial risk and want to be assured they will get their money back. China is no different. And nobody is forcing Pakistan to do anything here, it chose this path.
 
.
If the news about conditions are true then good ............. Try to build it with our own money...... And Start KalaBagh Dam too.
 
.
China placed conditions on this project. It says so in the first paragraph of article:



How is this different than what US, World Bank, IMF, or anyone do when they are financing a project? They impose conditions. After all, they are taking the financial risk and want to be assured they will get their money back. China is no different. And nobody is forcing Pakistan to do anything here, it chose this path.

Sorry if my post was not so clear. What I meant was that those funding restict Pakistan's options and comes with conditions. For instance Pakistan was trying to go for Iranian gas and energy with Iran funding the project at a better rate and not any major conditions. US was pushing for funding some project via CAR's and Afghanistan with of course conditions, we Pakistan showed interest in Iranian project, US strongly started opposing nd even threaten sanctions. Similarly with IMF or WB funding they first of all have some western strings attached as most of the money comes from west and then they constantly push Pakistan to increase tax rates or sort of things that shows that they are meddling into Pakistan's internal affairs. Similarly EU funding comes,with them meddling in Pakistan's internal affairs. Again, this is what I observed and is my opinion based on those observation. I haven' seen Chinese doing these sort of things.
 
.
No one is a permanent friend in the global arena, so much for the deeper than ocean friendship between China and Pakistan.
It’s a good sign that atleast now Pakistan is able to take decisions that will truely benefit their own people rather than pleasing others.
 
.
14 Billion is bit to high Dam construction has always been valued at 3-5 Billion range unless they are building it with Gold plating
 
.
Good, start work with local funding.

We can have many more projects under CPEC on which both Pakistan and China agree. No worries.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom