What's new

Pakistan loses 50pc market share in Kabul

foxbat

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
4,093
Reaction score
-7
Country
India
Location
India
https://www.dawn.com/news/1393106/pakistan-loses-50pc-market-share-in-kabul

KARACHI: India has succeeded to penetrate in Kabul slashing the market share of Pakistan by more than 50 per cent in the last two years, Chairman Pakistan-Afghanistan Joint Chamber of Commerce and Industry Zubair Motiwala told Dawn on Friday.

Motiwala who recently visited Kabul said the penetration of India and China has limited Pakistan’s option to retain its market share while India subsidises heavily on its exports. He said Pakistan’s trade with Afghanistan fell to $1.2 billion from $2.7bn within in the last two years and the country has been losing even the traditional markets of flour, men and women’s clothes and red meat.

India has been providing goods at subsidised rates to capture the market and are providing air tickets with a 75pc rebate, said Motiwala, adding that Afghans find it easy to travel to India with cheap tickets and free multiple visas without police checks.

Kabul has been the natural market for Pakistani exports but that is changing as cheaper products from China and India flood the country. According to Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, exports to Afghanistan dropped to $1.271bn in FY17 from $1.437bn in FY16. Exports in the first quarter of 2017-18 stood at $319 million.

Each year thousands of Afghans used to visit Peshawar for medical treatment but now they prefer India due to cheaper treatments and other attractions like concessional treatments. “Medical tourism of Peshawar, which was mainly due to Afghans, is now at zero level; hospitals in Hayatabad are empty,” he continued.

He said Peshawar is the main victim of the declining trade with Afghanistan where people have lost their businesses on a large scale. Out of 200 flour mills, about 100 have been closed down due to a drastic fall in the export of flour to Afghanistan, he added.

He also referred to the decreasing containers’ traffic from Pakistan to Afghanistan. He said 70,000 goods containers were used to pass through between the two countries which has now dropped to just 7,000, reflecting the change of routes for imported goods to Afghans.

Pakistan was the biggest supplier of shalwar qameez suits to Kabul but that too has changed since both India and China are now supplying the readymade suits which are traditionally Pakistani products.
 
Less trade with Afghanistan is good news for Pakistan. We get shortages because Afghanistan prefers growing poppy instead of food.
And its good for Afghan people that they are getting cheaper commodities as subsidy from India.
 
Less trade with Afghanistan is good news for Pakistan. We get shortages because Afghanistan prefers growing poppy instead of food.
And its good for Afghan people that they are getting cheaper commodities as subsidy from India.

In other news this is good for bitcoin
 
Less trade with Afghanistan is good news for Pakistan. We get shortages because Afghanistan prefers growing poppy instead of food.
And its good for Afghan people that they are getting cheaper commodities as subsidy from India.
this is stupid logic has cause poverty in pakistan
stuck with stupid logic..world will change and we will remain poor..
china remained stuck in this logic till 1980s, they were poorer than we were in 1980s

even an idiot with no knowledge should know that econmy is all about production, the more you produce the more it becoems cheaper...open trade with afghanistan will not only allevate poverty in pakistan but all shortages as welll
 
this is stupid logic has cause poverty in pakistan
stuck with stupid logic..world will change and we will remain poor..
china remained stuck in this logic till 1980s, they were poorer than we were in 1980s

even an idiot with no knowledge should know that econmy is all about production, the more you produce the more it becoems cheaper...open trade with afghanistan will not only allevate poverty in pakistan but all shortages as welll

Pakistanis do not seem to realise that Afghanistan is one of the few trading partner with which it has substantial trading surplus
 
Less trade with Afghanistan is good news for Pakistan.
Pakistan has strategic geographical advantage.

Less trade means loss for Pakistani economy.

Learn from Chinese and STOP mixing enmity with business.
 
this is stupid logic has cause poverty in pakistan
stuck with stupid logic..world will change and we will remain poor..
china remained stuck in this logic till 1980s, they were poorer than we were in 1980s

even an idiot with no knowledge should know that econmy is all about production, the more you produce the more it becoems cheaper...open trade with afghanistan will not only allevate poverty in pakistan but all shortages as welll
poverty is better than getting killed from terrorism. What we got in return in doing trade with afghan? Poverty eliminated ? No we just got suicide bombers.
 
Glad India is subsidizing Afghanistan. I guess AFG can use all the handouts they can get. No problem, Pakistan can sell elsewhere, India can't subsidize the whole world even if it wanted to.
 
this is stupid logic has cause poverty in pakistan
stuck with stupid logic..world will change and we will remain poor..
china remained stuck in this logic till 1980s, they were poorer than we were in 1980s

even an idiot with no knowledge should know that econmy is all about production, the more you produce the more it becoems cheaper...open trade with afghanistan will not only allevate poverty in pakistan but all shortages as welll

I would chose poverty over getting killed at the hands of suicide bombers.

The bharatis who are lecturing about this "economic loss" are the same who start whining about Pakistani singers and actors working in India when 5-6 of their "jawans" die in IOK.

We have lost our kids to these Afghans, their president openly interferes in Pakistan's internal affairs and tries to divide Pakistanis on ethnic lines and that is enough reason to limit our relations with this country as much as possible.
 
which Afghanistan, the one with northern alliance, the one with Taliban or the one living in Pakistan?
 
He also referred to the decreasing containers’ traffic from Pakistan to Afghanistan. He said 70,000 goods containers were used to pass through between the two countries which has now dropped to just 7,000, reflecting the change of routes for imported goods to Afghans.

The most significant numbers. Container traffic reduced to 1/10th of what it was as Afghanistan moves traffic through Chahbahar.

India has been providing goods at subsidised rates to capture the market and are providing air tickets with a 75pc rebate, said Motiwala, adding that Afghans find it easy to travel to India with cheap tickets and free multiple visas without police checks.

Tickets are not "subsidised". Look at India's internal air traffic ticket prices, they are cheaper than a meal in Manchester's curry mile. These are competetive commercial airlines. They don't "subsidise". Export subsidies for goods are no more than what Pakistan offers its exporters. India and China are bound to replace 90% of Afghan trade as they are competitive.
NO hospital in India, which are all commercial concerns offer Afghans "special rates". They pay the same as do all medical tourists to India.
Pakistan can offer the same visa access as does India and China. No one is stopping them.
 
this is stupid logic has cause poverty in pakistan
stuck with stupid logic..world will change and we will remain poor..
china remained stuck in this logic till 1980s, they were poorer than we were in 1980s

even an idiot with no knowledge should know that econmy is all about production, the more you produce the more it becoems cheaper...open trade with afghanistan will not only allevate poverty in pakistan but all shortages as welll

What does this trade costs us???

Afghanistan is a security nightmare costing us many billions in headaches from refugees to terrorism

Limiting trade for increased security s not a bad option

Whats the value of trade when we also get chaos



We should facilitate chinese goods and business though whilst targeting indian interests
At the moment india has to subsidise goods, give free wheat etc in the hope of Market share in the future we can harm this plan whilst helping China
 
Pakistan has strategic geographical advantage.

Less trade means loss for Pakistani economy.

Learn from Chinese and STOP mixing enmity with business.

With regards to Afghanistan its a a exception, export of cement, construction material and food items creates a shortage driving prices up for Pakistani market. Some commodities which are subsidized by the government are also smuggled compounding the issue.

Wheat prices have been stable since India started sending subsidized wheat to Afghanistan. This used to be a big problem for us as despite being a wheat producer Pakistan had to at times import and previous attempts to prevent exports had resulted in massive smuggling. Smugglers found it lucrative as it was its more expensive in Afghanistan.

Another issue why we arnt happy with the Afghan transit trade agreement is Afghanistan imports duty free from Pakistani ports but once those shipments enter Afghanistan, a vast amount of those duty free goods make it back into Pakistan.

Same happened some years back when Afghanistan was allowed to import via road from India. The Pakistani markets were flooded with Indian medicines, commodities and tires back from Afghanistan. Was a big problem for Unilever, Philip Moriss and P&G as their brands which were manufactured in Pakistan were receiving competition from stocks manufactured in India which were cheaper since they werent subject to sales tax.
 
Last edited:
With regards to Afghanistan its a a exception, export of cement, construction material and food items creates a shortage driving prices up for Pakistani market. Some commodities which are subsidized by the government are also smuggled compounding the issue.

Add to this the criminality of the Afghans, the use of services, costs to house and look after all the namak haram trash, the use of trading routes as criminal/terrorist highways
Its an endless list of kak we have to deal with

Our dealing with Afghanistan should be strictly through view to protecting our own security and harming our enemies in Afghanistan including india
 

Back
Top Bottom