What's new

Pakistan discloses borrowing from China

Reddington

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Feb 22, 2019
Messages
1,053
Reaction score
20
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistan discloses borrowing from China

By Shahbaz Rana
Published: May 23, 2019

1978533-chinaspresidentxijinpingrshakeshandswithpakistansprimeministerimrankhanlaheadoftheirmeetingatthegreathallofthepeopleinbeijingonnovemberafpxx-1558581154-768-640x480.jpg

Prime Minister Imran Khan to attend Belt and Road Forum in Beijing PHOTO: FILE

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan, for the first time, fully disclosed the debt taken from China which stood at $6.5 billion for the current fiscal year alone, equal to three-fourths of the $8.6 billion worth of total loans that Islamabad received in the past 10 months, show official documents.

Under pressure from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the government of Prime Minister Imran Khan has disclosed every type of loan that Islamabad has received from its strategic ally, China.

Foreign loan disbursements in Jul-Apr of the current financial year showed loans for the Karachi Nuclear Power Plants, known as K2 and K3, and China SAFE deposits as part of federal debt obligations.

Earlier, the $2 billion worth of China SAFE deposits, which Islamabad had received in July 2018, were shown on the books of the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP). SAFE is an acronym for the State Administration of Foreign Exchange managed by the Chinese central bank.


Pakistan also received $3 billion from Saudi Arabia and $2 billion from the United Arab Emirates but these loans were not disclosed along with Chinese SAFE deposits.

Pakistan has long been using Chinese money to shore up its official foreign currency reserves but it is for the first time that these Chinese deposits with the central bank have been made part of the Ministry of Finance’s debt statistics.

Finance ministry spokesman Dr Khaqan Najeeb did not comment on the development. But a senior official of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs told The Express Tribune that the decision to disclose Chinese SAFE deposits was taken at the level of Adviser to Prime Minister on Finance Dr Abdul Hafeez Shaikh.

The full disclosure of Chinese loans was one of the sticking points between the government and the IMF during staff-level negotiations for a $6-billion bailout package. It now seems Prime Minister Imran Khan has accepted the IMF’s terms on Chinese loans.

The United States wants to ring-fence IMF money in order to stop Pakistan from using such funds for repaying Chinese loans.

Owing to the fresh disclosure, the Chinese foreign loans from July through April FY19 surged to $6.56 billion, according to the finance ministry’s documents. These were equal to 75% of the total foreign loans of $8.6 billion that Pakistan received during the period.

There was over $2-billion jump in foreign loan disbursements within a month due to the disclosure of Chinese loans.


Out of the $6.5 billion, China gave $2 billion in SAFE deposits and $2.53 billion in foreign commercial loans, also for cushioning the declining foreign exchange reserves.

In March, the Chinese government provided the loans through two commercial banks. China Development Bank gave $2.24 billion in a short-term loan while Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) disbursed $300 million.

China gave $628.4 million for the construction of two ongoing nuclear power plants in the past 10 months, according to the finance ministry statistics.

China also gave $1.4 billion in project financing in the past 10 months, largely for China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) projects. Project loans have largely been disbursed for the Sukkur-Multan motorway, Havelian-Thakot project of CPEC and Lahore Orange Line project.

Every successive government has been heavily relying on foreign loans to stay afloat. The reliance on China increased in recent years after the traditional multilateral lenders stopped budgetary support due to deterioration in macroeconomic conditions.

Pakistan hopes that the blocked budgetary support will soon be restored after approval of the $6-billion bailout package by the IMF Executive Board. It also expects to return to the international capital market from the next fiscal year to raise funds for building official foreign currency reserves.

On the back of Chinese loans, the commercial financing surged to $3.2 billion as of the end of April, which was equal to 37.2% of the total foreign loans. Ajman Bank PJSC disbursed another tranche of $76 million in April, taking its total loans to $150 million.

A consortium of Credit Suisse AG, UBL and ABL has already given $295 million and $184 million was released by Dubai Bank in previous months. The lending by multilateral agencies amounted to $1.3 billion or 14% of the total disbursements. The country received $380 million from the Asian Development Bank (ADB) by April, far lower than estimates. The World Bank disbursed only $250 million.

The Islamic Development Bank (IDB) disbursed an additional $35 million last month, which took its total loans for Pakistan to $578 million in 10 months. The IDB gave these commercial loans for oil purchase from Saudi Arabia. The disbursements by other lenders remained low.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1978533/2-pakistan-discloses-borrowing-china/
 
. .
You do realise most of this "borrowing" is actually the investment being made in CPEC?

In which parallel world is a LOAN considered as an Investment, LOL ???? Again what Pakistan do with it is your own business, GOP can invest it in CPEC or anything else, but the fact still remain is that the amount mentioned in the article is a loan and not some FDI from China. :-)
 
.
In a world where they've worded the facts incorrectly.

I bet only your nation is smart. The guy's sitting on top of IMF are all fools who can't understand the difference between an Investment and a Loan. Sorry my bad. :(
 
.
You do realise most of this "borrowing" is actually the investment being made in CPEC?

It is not investment, China doesn't want to expose itself to the financial risk, it is lending pakistan the money in the form of loans which are then paid to the chinese companies and workforce working on CPEC projects, 90% of this money goes back to china but in the mean time a project is constructed and pakistan gets indebted. So this is NOT at all chinese investment, it is loan and only loan.

In case of investment the liability will be on china, but in case of loan the liability is on pakistan. That is the difference between investment and loan. For example if the project fails then pakistan still has to pay the money because it was financed through a loan but if it was financed through an investment then pakistan would not have to pay anything and china would bear all financial losses itself. Now you see how smart chinese are.
 
Last edited:
.
It is not investment, China doesn't want to expose itself to the financial risk, it is lending pakistan the money in the form of loans which are then paid to the chinese companies and workforce working on CPEC projects, 90% of this money goes back to china but in the mean time pakistan is indebted. So this is NOT at all chinese investment, it is loan and only loan.

In case of investment the liability will be on china, but in case of loan the liability is on pakistan. That is the difference between investment and loan.

Just realised what @Tom M meant. Apologies for the tone of my response.

I guess what I wanted to clear up was that the loans being taken also include loans we're taking for development work, not just loans we're taking to keep the lights on.
 
.
So what is the CPEC loan? $8.2 billion just that? Thank you China for investing rest of $51.8 billion of $60 billion CPEC fund in Pakistan without making it a loan.

China is a true friend with markup of 1 to 2 % on this loan.
 
.
So what is the CPEC loan? $8.2 billion just that? Thank you China for investing rest of $51.8 billion of $60 billion CPEC fund in Pakistan without making it a loan.

China is a true friend with markup of 1 to 2 % on this loan.

LOL, is that what you understood after reading the very first line of the above article ??? :lol::lol::lol:

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan, for the first time, fully disclosed the debt taken from China which stood at $6.5 billion for the current fiscal year alone, equal to three-fourths of the $8.6 billion worth of total loans that Islamabad received in the past 10 months.

 
.
LOL, is that what you understood after reading the very first line of the above article ??? :lol::lol::lol:

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan, for the first time, fully disclosed the debt taken from China which stood at $6.5 billion for the current fiscal year alone, equal to three-fourths of the $8.6 billion worth of total loans that Islamabad received in the past 10 months.
So if Pakistan has disclosed the loan to China what is the total loan?

I understood it is total $8.2 billion because it has also orange line mentioned in it which is a 6 year old project.
 
.

  • Thursday, 23 May 2019
THE EXPRESS TRIBUNE > BUSINESS
China leads with 75% share in total foreign loans

Every tom dick and Harry kept repeating the same Mantra, Chinese loans have nothing to do with the precarious debt trap that forces Pakistan into the tender embrace of the IMF.
Chinese loans are tiny , a very small fraction of the debts Pakistan has rung up.
Lies lies and more lies as the IMF tries to ensure the Awam of Pakistan is made aware of where these debts emanate from.
Remember how IK was going to disclose all the details and then finds out he cannot disclose these details as the Chinese will not let him.
The interest being charged is a figure that the Govt still continues to fudge. One day its 2% another day 2.5% another day much more and another day it becomes a state secret that China says must never be disclosed
 
.
It is not investment, China doesn't want to expose itself to the financial risk, it is lending pakistan the money in the form of loans which are then paid to the chinese companies and workforce working on CPEC projects, 90% of this money goes back to china but in the mean time pakistan is indebted. So this is NOT at all chinese investment, it is loan and only loan.

In case of investment the liability will be on china, but in case of loan the liability is on pakistan. That is the difference between investment and loan.

that was clear. i just hope pakistani leaders are as clear headed as you
 
.
Foreign loan disbursements in Jul-Apr of the current financial year showed loans for the Karachi Nuclear Power Plants, known as K2 and K3

China is building these nuclear plants for us yes from their money which we eventually have to pay them back so what ? This is how expensive projects like water dams and others are always built in Pakistan whether taking loans for World Bank ,ADB or China.
 
.
So what?

Not a matter of life and death if we lease Gawadar to China as worst case scenario.

It's nowhere as bad as IMF and Western bankers ready to take our airports etc.
 
. . .

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom