What's new

one of the most sensitive issue debated between China,Koreo and Japan

Aeneas

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Dec 30, 2008
Messages
185
Reaction score
0
TOKYO, June 4 Kyodo

Yasukuni Shrine will not remove ''traces'' of Class-A war criminals from its premises as it claims the results of the Tokyo war crimes tribunal that convicted them remain controversial, according to a written statement from the Shinto shrine.

''This is a matter of Japanese religious faith...Their separate enshrinement will never happen,'' the shrine said in the statement in response to questions from Kyodo News.

Yasukuni Shrine's flat rejection of a proposal to separately enshrine 14 Class-A war criminals -- including wartime Prime Minister Gen. Hideki Tojo -- from Japan's 2.5 million war dead came as Japan's ties with China and South Korea are tense due to Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's repeated visits to the Tokyo shrine.

Other Asian countries see Yasukuni as symbolic of unrepentant Japanese nationalism and regard visits to it by Japanese government leaders as insensitive and insulting to them.

The statement attributed the shrine's rejection to ''lingering objections'' voiced by some international legal scholars to the validity of the results of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East after World War II.

It said the Diet unanimously adopted a resolution in 1953 denying the existence of ''war criminals'' in Japan in connection with World War II.

It said that as a result of revisions from 1953 to 1955 to the laws concerning the government's relief for families of the war dead, the government began treating war criminals and ordinary war dead alike.

Noting Nobusuke Kishi, once on the dock as a Class-A war criminal, became prime minister later, the statement said, ''There was no recognition of war criminals among the Japanese at all.''

In view of Japan's tense relationship with China and South Korea, some legislators of Koizumi's governing Liberal Democratic Party proposed removing ''traces'' of the Class-A war criminals from Yasukuni.

Among others, Hidenao Nakagawa, chairman of the LDP's Diet Affairs Committee, said last Sunday it is desirable that the Class-A war criminals be enshrined separately from the rest of the war dead through discussions between the shrine and families of the war dead.

Shingo Oyama, chief of Yasukuni Shrine's public relations office, said that although there were inquiries from the government and the LDP, the shrine has received no requests for the separate enshrinement of the Class-A war criminals.

Koizumi has visited the shrine once every year since taking office in April 2001. He last visited it on Jan. 1, 2004.

He has repeatedly said his visits are aimed at paying tribute to Japan's war dead, not to the Class-A war criminals, and has pledged that Japan will not wage war again.

China says words are insufficient to show Japan's atonement for various atrocities it committed during the war, and has urged Koizumi to show atonement through action.



Background and Context of Debate:
Yasukuni is a shrine in Tokyo that honors Japan's war dead. Among the over 2 million names indexed at the shrine are over a dozen Class A war criminals from World War II. Visits by prominent politicians to the shrine remain a major sticking point in relations between Japan and its neighbors, particularly South Korea and China. Yushukan, a military history museum on the shrine grounds also causes controversy for its allegedly revisionist views of World War II events and its lack of attention paid to comfort women, the occupation of Nanjing or the crimes of Manchukuo.
 
The Tokyo-based Yasukuni Shrine on Saturday refused to separate memorial tablets of Class-A war criminals from Japan's ordinary war dead despite of proposal of domestic statesmen and strong protests from many Asian countries, Kyodo News reported Saturday.

"This is a matter of Japanese religious faith...Their separate enshrinement will never happen," the shrine said in a written statement in response to questions from Kyodo.

Yasukuni Shrine's statement on a proposal to separately enshrine 14 Class-A war criminals -- including wartime Prime Minister Gen. Hideki Tojo -- from Japan's 2.5 million war dead came as Japan's ties with China and South Korea encounter difficulties due to Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's repeated visits to the Tokyo shrine.

In view of the cooling relationship of Japan with China and South Korea, some legislators of Koizumi's governing Liberal Democratic Party proposed removing the tablets of the Class-A war criminals from Yasukuni.

Among others, Hidenao Nakagawa, chairman of the LDP's Parliament Affairs Committee, said last Sunday it is desirable that the Class-A war criminals be enshrined separately from the rest of the war dead through discussions between the shrine and families of the war dead.

Five Japanese former prime ministers and House of Representatives Speaker Yohei Kono on Wednesday also reached an agreement urging Koizumi to halt his visits to the notorious shrine in order to avoid further worsening relations with China.

Yasuhiro Nakasone, who was unable to attend the former prime ministers' meeting, also expressed similar opinions to Kono.

Moreover, the former prime minister on Friday reiterated that Koizumi should stop visiting the shrine.

Kiichi Miyazawa, Toshiki Kaifu, Tomiichi Murayama, Ryutaro Hashimoto, Yoshiro Mori all agreed on the issue in a gathering on concerns of current difficulties in Japan-China relations.

According to Asahi Shimbun's report on Saturday, Nakasone also made a suggestion to separately enshrine the Class-A war criminals and the Japanese war dead. "If the separation needs time, it is wise for Koizumi to make decision of stopping the visits during the time," Nakasone was quoted by the daily.

Nakasone, once visited shrine as prime minister, stopped the shrine visit due to protests from China, South Korea and some other Asian countries in order to no longer damage ties with the countries and hurt their people's heart.

In spite of strong protests from China and other Asian countries, Koizumi has paid four visits to the shrine since he took office in April 2001, with the latest one on New Year's Day in 2004.

He has repeatedly made chicaneries saying his visits are aimed at paying tribute to Japan's war dead, not to the Class-A war criminals, and has pledged that Japan will not wage war again.

As a widely known fact, the 14 Class-A war criminals honored at the shrine are responsible for the most atrocious crimes in Japan's war of aggression against its Asian neighbors.

Source: Xinhua
 
Has Chinese-Japanese relations improved since then?

Pakistan will always take side with China over any country.
These days Pakistan is friendly towards Japan because Pakistan is going through its worst economic crisis and Japan is showing some interst in improving Pakistan's economy.

Pakistan should side with China.
China helped Pakistan more than any country in the world.
Long Live Pakistan China friendship :china::pakistan:
 
there is a strange relationship between China and Japan called "cold political
,hot economy".

reasonable Chinese people like me ask no more than sincere apology symbolized by remove ''traces'' of Class-A war criminals from Yasukuni Shrine.but Japanese refuse to do that again and again.I just couldn't understand them.as the result,reasonable people like me has no willing to advise or comfort jacobinical people who hate Japanese.

all these Class-A war criminals were sentenced by World Court,they were devils as well as Goering,Goebbels,Ribbentrop,and etc.how could Chinese tolerate they stay in Yasukuni Shrine?we may forgive hundreds of thousands of Japanese soldiers,NCO,generals who had invaded China,but we couldn't bear the thought of forgive Class-A war criminals.

in my opinion,I'm ready to take effort to improve political relationship of China and Japan in case they show sincerity by remove ''traces'' of Class-A war criminals from Yasukuni Shrine.It would be better if Japanese remove ''traces'' of Class-B,C war criminals from Yasukuni Shrine.

thank you for pak bro supporting China firmly,it's OK for Pak cooperate with Japan,we never envy about it.we have great friendship which Japan can never imagine.Japanese are competent indeed,they will help you a lot as well as they did for Chinese economy.:pakistan::china:
 
Last edited:
Has Chinese-Japanese relations improved since then?


Pakistan should side with China.
China helped Pakistan more than any country in the world.
Long Live Pakistan China friendship :china::pakistan:

Not true, Japan has done a great deal to help Pakistan. Japan as Top Donor
 
a friend in need is the friend indeed.even you Americans would find out who is the real friend in the future.Hillary Clinton just came to Beijing and negotiated with our prime minister Mr.Wen.

I think we can not help US economy much,but we will not let it become worse.
 
Back
Top Bottom