Mystic mythological battles Of India and Pakistan

[KS]

how is this pakistans history? You are all ofcourse, free to discuss this in members section. Mythology is not history and such agressive methodologies to somehow 'subdue' the posters from the other side is not fooling anyone.

As for ignoring the thread, i have absolutely no intention of doing the same. I agree to disagree.

This is neither India/Pakistan's specific history. India and Pak as entities came about in 1947.

We are talking about the mythological battles that took place in the sub-continent when Vedic religions were followed.

And who said Mythology cannot be history - Most of the tactics used in the mythological battles have found reference in the various books of war specifically Arthasastra.The vyuhas, the rules of combat etc. The lines separating them are too thin .

As for the precedents look here

http://www.defence.pk/forums/general-defence/88366-mythological-weapons.html

http://www.defence.pk/forums/military-history/88378-ancient-mythological-war-formations.html

See, with your belief I don't expect you to believe these, but there are people who believe these and more importantly interested in the various tactics, weapons, war rules used etc.

So dont act as a spoiler.If you are not comfortable still just report to the Mods and wait.

 

[Mech]

This is neither India/Pakistan's specific history. India and Pak as entities came about in 1947.

We are talking about the mythological battles that took place in the sub-continent when Vedic religions were followed.

And who said Mythology cannot be history - Most of the tactics used in the mythological battles have found reference in the various books of war specifically Arthasastra.The vyuhas, the rules of combat etc. The lines separating them are too thin .

As for the precedents look here

http://www.defence.pk/forums/general-defence/88366-mythological-weapons.html

http://www.defence.pk/forums/military-history/88378-ancient-mythological-war-formations.html

See, with your belief I don't expect you to believe these, but there are people who believe these and more importantly interested in the various tactics, weapons, war rules used etc.

So dont act as a spoiler.

As you can see, this thread is posted under the 'military history' of pakistan. Im sure a lot of people maybe interested but this is not the place for it. Personally, i think these type of threads are counter productive and highly improper.

This should have been posted under members section. I hope the mods take notice and nuke/move the thread.

And how do you consider it appropriate to make this piece of mythology inclusive of all indians?...or pakistanis for that matter?

These are mythologies related to a particular religion and is certainly not inclusive of all.

 

[KS]

As you can see, this thread is posted under the 'military history' of pakistan. Im sure a lot of people maybe interested but this is not the place for it. Personally, i think these type of threads are counter productive and highly improper.

I don't think so. So lets agree to disagree.

This sub-forum is not for the military history of Pakistan alone. See the description of the Military History properly before commenting.

And how do you consider it appropriate to make this piece of mythology inclusive of all indians?...or pakistanis for that matter?

These are mythologies related to a particular religion and is certainly not inclusive of all.

why the fcuk you people have to bring in religion into everything ?? See neither Joe Shearer nor Alternative are Hindus,I presume. But that did not stop them from having a fantastic discussion in the Mythological Weapons thread and I salute them for that.That is the sign of great men. No one is asking you to 'believe' these or forcing these down your throat. These petty things are the sign of an insecure/immature mind. Just leave who are interested in discussing that.

 

[Nair saab]

Mech brother let them post it...its there wish ...& after all this is not a flame thread until now...who have open mind let them come & share there knowledge...