Mohenjo Daro | Official Trailer

[coffee_cup]

The historic point I made is factually correct. Below is Proto Shiva Seal from Indus Valley. Shiva did not come to India in the vedic texts. This dude evolved from existing shiva representations that are traced to IVC.

And no...we're just humble people of the subcontinent. I'm dravidian anyway so no chance of belonging to Deutschland

Dude...question 1- are you suggesting India is a figment of people's imagination (I warn you affirming that statement will imply really bad consequences for you only)

Go ahead, tell us what is the country you call "India"?

Tell us where was it ,say, in year 350 or year 1450 AD?

 

[Guynextdoor2]

Go ahead, tell us what is the country you call "India"?

Tell us where was it ,say, in year 350 or year 1450 AD?

The implicaiton is that a figment of people's imagination cut you into two in 1971. Not a good vote of confidence for your state, not us.

 

[Indika]

What we say in Urdu "Baygani shadi main Abdullah dewana". Its like Israel making movie about Egyptian civilization because in ancient times, their lands were part of Egyptian empire. I am sure Indians got their own civilization called Ganges. What is this obsession with a foreign empire/civilization?

so says the taliban.

Modern day Pak is a modern day phenomenon. I do not understand this obsession with trying to define yourself as 'different' from rest of India. 7000 years ago the people who lived were in a different civilization. Hinduism derived from them and from Vedas. Somewhere along the line a new faith emerged that was accepted by a number of people who concentrated in an area. You broke your relationship with with past and the others continued. Why is this logic so difficult for you to digest I wonder? I mean Taxila university was hardly islamic.

They suffer from identity crisis. May be they should consult a mullah who give them some ....err gyan or some thing else. Harappan religion is supposed to be animistic which is totally opposite to the current ones.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Modern day Pak is a modern day phenomenon.

And so is India.. Modern day India was born on 15th August 1947 .. As one of the 2 successor states of British India..

British who colonised not less than 650 kingdoms or states to form the British colony.

I do not understand this obsession with trying to define yourself as 'different' from rest of India.

Your a South Indian/Dravidian .. I'm Baluch .. The other Pak member is probably Panjabi or Pashtun ... We don't share the same religion,language,clothings,food,habits,culture or even physique or appearance .. And you think we are same people?

7000 years ago the people who lived were in a different civilization. Hinduism derived from them and from Vedas.

So now your saying that somehow Hinduism evolved from a lost civilisation that emerged from
Modern day Pak? As opposed to your previous claim that the seal represented a Hindu god?

Any ways..

Somewhere along the line a new faith emerged that was accepted by a number of people who concentrated in an area. You broke your relationship with with past and the others continued. Why is this logic so difficult for you to digest I wonder? I mean Taxila university was hardly islamic.

Let's suppose that entire Pak.. Panjabis,Sindhis,Pashtuns,Baluch,Huzai,Shigris,Pamiris,Sheenas,Sheens,Wakhis,Seirkis,Qizilbashi,Hazaras,Kashmiris etc etc were all somehow Hindus ? (which they weren't)... And they accepted another religion (although Buddhism at one stage was the dominant religion in this part of the world -- with Buddhist civilisations like Gandhara etc emerging from the same land)...

How does that according to your really crappy logic makes you the inheritors or heirs of IVC than the people of the region whose ancestors created the civilisation?

Going by your logic .. Persians,Mongols,Egyptians,Greeks,Italians,Turks etc are not inheritors of their civilisations because they became Muslims,Buddhists or Christians?

so says the taliban.


They suffer from identity crisis. May be they should consult a mullah who give them some ....err gyan or some thing else. Harappan religion is supposed to be animistic which is totally opposite to the current ones.

Says the saffron chaddi revolutionary.. So now a Hindu is going to claim Harrappa (which again is our national heritage)?

Is Hindu a animalistic faith too?

 

[coffee_cup]

The implicaiton is that a figment of people's imagination cut you into two in 1971. Not a good vote of confidence for your state, not us.

And this is your argument to lay claim on our civilization? Oh boy, the brainwashing they are doing in Indian schools !

Modern day Pakistan, call it whatever you want to, and its people are true successors of this great old civilization of Mohenjo Darro, Harrpa , Taxilla etc.

Today's "India" has absolutely no business with our civilization. India can teach whatever fantasies she wants to her children and lay claim on everything starting from Egyptian civilization to Inca. But you can not change reality!

Says the saffron chaddi revolutionary.. So now a Hindu is going to claim Harrappa (which again is our national heritage)?

Is Hindu a animalistic faith too?

Look at his nick "EyesWideShut", tells you the real state of mind our Eastern neighbors live in,

You are wasting your time with these, bro!

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Hardly an inspiring trailer to begin with. And some are debating to whom the IVC belongs to.

The wise will accept that it is a shared civilisation. Well the stupid ones.... Never mind..

 

[Levina]

Modern day Pak is a modern day phenomenon. I do not understand this obsession with trying to define yourself as 'different' from rest of India. 7000 years ago the people who lived were in a different civilization. Hinduism derived from them and from Vedas. Somewhere along the line a new faith emerged that was accepted by a number of people who concentrated in an area. You broke your relationship with with past and the others continued. Why is this logic so difficult for you to digest I wonder? I mean Taxila university was hardly islamic.

Oh forget it!!!
It's as if IVC/SSC cities were limited to Pakistan.
These guys would refuse to believe that Varanasi is as old as IVC/SSC itself.
Varanasi is as old as Indus valley civilization, finds IIT-KGP study

But then we should not be surprised.Most of India has remained inhabited since a very long time.
Varanasi as far as i know is one of the oldest inhabited cities in the world.
If I had to quote a similar instance then it'll be Ashoka,the emperor. India had completely forgotten about him till a British officer found a pillar with our national emblem. Ashoka was just an 1800 years old story, so how do you expect traces of IVC/SSC to remain intact under perpetually inhabited city???

And...
@Guynextdoor2 you can not drill sense into someone who has vacuum between his ears, and whose only purpose on the forum is to prove himself superior to others.
Hail the galoot! lol

 

[Guynextdoor2]

And so is India.. Modern day India was born on 15th August 1947 .. As one of the 2 successor states of British India..

British who colonised not less than 650 kingdoms or states to form the British colony.


Your a South Indian/Dravidian .. I'm Baluch .. The other Pak member is probably Panjabi or Pashtun ... We don't share the same religion,language,clothings,food,habits,culture or even physique or appearance .. And you think we are same people?



So now your saying that somehow Hinduism evolved from a lost civilisation that emerged from
Modern day Pak? As opposed to your previous claim that the seal represented a Hindu god?

Any ways..


Let's suppose that entire Pak.. Panjabis,Sindhis,Pashtuns,Baluch,Huzai,Shigris,Pamiris,Sheenas,Sheens,Wakhis,Seirkis,Qizilbashi,Hazaras,Kashmiris etc etc were all somehow Hindus ? (which they weren't)... And they accepted another religion (although Buddhism at one stage was the dominant religion in this part of the world -- with Buddhist civilisations like Gandhara etc emerging from the same land)...

How does that according to your really crappy logic makes you the inheritors or heirs of IVC than the people of the region whose ancestors created the civilisation?

Going by your logic .. Persians,Mongols,Egyptians,Greeks,Italians,Turks etc are not inheritors of their civilisations because they became Muslims,Buddhists or Christians?



Says the saffron chaddi revolutionary.. So now a Hindu is going to claim Harrappa (which again is our national heritage)?

Is Hindu a animalistic faith too?

Your either hindus or buddhists by ancestry - since buddhism was almost completely booted out due to Brahminical backlash you're almost certainly Hindu in terms of ancestry. and yes, because Hinduism never started at one point (word of the Prophet for instance) it was a mixture of old and new continuing traditions. some were quashed and some continued.
Hindus were inheritors of IVC. Your ancestors made a clean break with both.

Oh forget it!!!
It's as if IVC/SSC cities were limited to Pakistan.
These guys would refuse to believe that Varanasi is as old as IVC/SSC itself.
Varanasi is as old as Indus valley civilization, finds IIT-KGP study

But then we should not be surprised.Most of India has remained inhabited since a very long time.
Varanasi as far as i know is one of the oldest inhabited cities in the world.
If I had to quote a similar instance then it'll be Ashoka,the emperor. India had completely forgotten about him till a British officer found a pillar with our national emblem. Ashoka was just an 1800 years old story, so how do you expect traces of IVC/SSC to remain intact under perpetually inhabited city???

And...
@Guynextdoor2 you can not drill sense into someone who has vaccuum between his ears, and whose only purpose on the forum is to prove himself superior to others.
Hail the galoot! lol

From what I gather the latest IVC location is in Tamil Nadu?

 

[Indika]

Says the saffron chaddi revolutionary.. So now a Hindu is going to claim Harrappa (which again is our national heritage)?

National heritage? be happy that those things were not bulldozed by the mullahs like in afghanistan.
By telling a lie thousand times it wont become the truth. ppl identify harappan civilization with India and never with pakistan. Your culture is antithesis to harppan which believed in nature.

 

[raj76]

what documentary? There was hardly any use of metal in the civilization. Here he is using metals swords and whatnot. Ashutosh gowariar's brain fart. Wonder why he didn't put birder milk's favorite bird 'ef sola' also in there to complete the joke. None of his historical movies have anything to do with reality.

Thats why i said its movie(Larger than life) and its no documentary where they are trying tell truth

 

[Levina]

From what I gather the latest IVC location is in Tamil Nadu?

Yes.
You got that right.
Finally they've started to take southern Indian seriously.
Towards the east of Tamil Nadu specially between SL and India there's a treasure to be unearthed but due to security reasons diving in deep waters is not allowed in the area.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

Oh forget it!!!
It's as if IVC/SSC cities were limited to Pakistan.
These guys would refuse to believe that Varanasi is as old as IVC/SSC itself.
Varanasi is as old as Indus valley civilization, finds IIT-KGP study

But then we should not be surprised.Most of India has remained inhabited since a very long time.
Varanasi as far as i know is one of the oldest inhabited cities in the world.
If I had to quote a similar instance then it'll be Ashoka,the emperor. India had completely forgotten about him till a British officer found a pillar with our national emblem. Ashoka was just an 1800 years old story, so how do you expect traces of IVC/SSC to remain intact under perpetually inhabited city???

And...
@Guynextdoor2 you can not drill sense into someone who has vacuum between his ears, and whose only purpose on the forum is to prove himself superior to others.
Hail the galoot! lol

I think this is tragic in some sense. They are hell bent on establishing two state theory by bending as much history as possible. Fact is state is just a political construct. You don't need any dvisions, if politically it is formed, it is formed. You don't need to cook up history to build a case.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Your either hindus or buddhists by ancestry - since buddhism was almost completely booted out due to Brahminical backlash you're almost certainly Hindu in terms of ancestry. and yes, because Hinduism never started at one point (word of the Prophet for instance) it was a mixture of old and new continuing traditions. some were quashed and some continued.
Hindus were inheritors of IVC. Your ancestors made a clean break with both.

Ah no .. Actually Baluch were historically most likely zoarastrians.. And so were the Pashtuns...

Northern Pakistan was Buddhist interlocking with the Tibetan branch of Buddhism..

Sindh and Panjab is where buddism flourished for centuries..

Religion has nothing to do with race .. If you become a Chritistans your race would not somehow change to European.

Religion doesn't change ancestory either lol.

Hinduism never flourished in this region and that itself is documented by the British..

From what I gather the latest IVC location is in Tamil Nadu?

Lol.

 

[Levina]

I think this is tragic in some sense. They are hell bent on establishing two state theory by bending as much history as possible. Fact is state is just a political construct. You don't need any dvisions, if politically it is formed, it is formed. You don't need to cook up history to build a case.

I dont blame them.
They're expected to do that. A lie told often becomes the truth.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

Ah no .. Actually Baluch were historically most likely zoarastrians.. And so were the Pashtuns...

Religion has nothing to do with race .. If you become a Chritistans your race would not somehow change to European.

Religion doesn't change ancestory either lol.

Hinduism never flourished in this region and that itself is documented by the British..


Lol.

this discussion is for people with brain