What's new

Modi effect: 'My father hates Muslims'. India's new law divides families

Lothal,Kalibangan,Dholavira,Rakhigarhi were made by Ancient Indians

I can accept that Mohenjodaro and Harappa were made by Ancient Pakistanis in Ancient Pakistan, but not in Ancient India

But Mohenjodaro and Harappa were also over come by our people who traveled from Eastern Europe and Central Asia. Same people were responsible for downfall of most native Indian civilizations and creating their own. Wasn't it them who spread out in India and were responsible for civilizing most of the masses and ruling over them? Same people who came to be known as the Kshatriya for their invasive and ruling prowess. Or I'm missing something?
 
.
But Mohenjodaro and Harappa were also over come by our people who traveled from Eastern Europe and Central Asia. Same people were responsible for downfall of most native Indian civilizations and creating their own. Wasn't it them who spread out in India and were responsible for civilizing most of the masses and ruling over them? Same people who came to be known as the Kshatriya for their invasive and ruling prowess. Or I'm missing something?


I think the big mistake is to think that people came directly from Ukrainian Pontic steppes to North-Western part of into gangetic plain in the span of a few years...When actually they stopped, settled down, mixed and again moved on over a period of 1,000 years...If we think of India-european intrusion into Indian subcontinent in 1500 BCE, that is around 800-1,000 years forward in time from the Yamnaya dispersal (the original chariot riding into European culture)


if you know which ones are Indo-european languages then this is a much better video




All in all I am of the opinion that the info-Europeans who came into India would have characteristics that are somewhere between modern Pashtuns and Tajikis at one end of the spectrum and modern Pamiris at another end

given that they had already substantially mixed heavily with a lot of cultures along the way especially BMAC

There was high culture already in modern day Pakistan as well as modern day India well before Indo Europeans arrived...but that high culture had already declined a few hundred years before IE people arrived..So IE people were not exactly on a civilising mission in India

Actually civilisation disappears and then civilisation reappears "in-situ" in Gandhara-Kamboja stretch as well as "Panchala-Magadha" stretch.....It would not be until 600 BCE that the high culture lost in 1900 BCE would be recreated

and by that time, a operate outsider identity had long disappeared
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom