Maoists Vs Taliban Who will win?

[Icarus]

Taliban are smart at least the higher ups are. I think it was @Icarus who said they play Quran verses to get people to surrender and than kill them.

Yep, the Taliban announce verses from the Quran that call for muslims to unite and not fall prey to division. They quote historical references of the humane treatment of POWs by muslims during the time of the Prophet (PBUH) and then assure the encircled that they are would be treated the same. It's all bullshit though, they'll just try and use you for a bargaining chip and later, they'll behead you. That's why I always say, when encircled by the Taliban and out of ammo, you're pretty much dead already, at least have the sense of honour to bayonet charge the enemy or run at them with your last grenade, that way, at least you die with your self-respect and dignity intact.

 

[Mani2020]

some videos of talibans beheading people are enough to wet the pents of maoists and you people here ....i bet you will not be able to sleep whole night .....Salute to the Pak army jawans for having the courage and dare to fight these people in taliban controlled areas

 

[Teeta]

last few hundred years rught from kicking butt og ottomans to eradicating mughal misrule, to planting their boots in muslim holy land of arabia to palestiine its christian all the way. muslims may have had a few initial success, but over the long term you have to see

Uhhh, "Last 300 years" ? Exactly. Out of 1400 years, Muslims are on the recieving end for 300 years...but what about 1100+ years?

From Spain to Northern Middle-East, From Asia Minor to Constantinople, From Jerusalem to Acre , From Egypt to Algeria, From Tunisia to Morocco etc..Islamic Armies didn't only defeat Christians, but for the most part, Islam just ideologically eradicated Christianity! Hundreds of millions of "Muslims" today are actually "ex-Christians" .... Can Christianity/Christendom even claim 1% of what Islam did to it?

On ideological level : Islam holds COMPLETE victory.
On Military and Political level : It is a mix for both Christendom and Islamic World...Sometimes, one had the upper hand, while the other times, other had the upper hand.

From last 300 years however, its secular West (Christian majority) having upper hand. The day Muslims left their science and technology and went to "Allah will do it for us" belief, their demise started.

BTW, even today, our biggest military challenge (or headache) comes from Global Islamic Jihad in Asymmetric Warfare Mode.

Leaving some fanatics, both Christians and Muslims have come out of this 'holy wars of religions' madness.

 

[Ayush]

if this happens,the biggest winners will be india and pakistan.

 

[cyphercide]

There is no other better, more brutal, more well equipped, more experienced, more dedicated, and more fanatical insurgent group than the Talibans!

Talibans will CRUSH groups like Maoists or say Sri Lankan Tamils , or Thai insurgent etc...

There is no match of Global Islamic Jihad-Assymetric Warfare Mode.

Where ever these guys are fighting (Russia, Philippines, Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Israel-Palestine Area, Yemen, Nigeria, etc), they are leaving their mark!

So no, Maoists are just tooooooooooooooooooooooooooo 'innocent and young' infront of a monster like Talibans and other fanatical Islamic Jihad Organizations.

And how did they get so brutal, well equipped, dedicated and experienced in the first place?

 

[Icarus]

Maoists Vs Taliban? Taliban would walk all over the Maoists. The Taliban have much greater operational capacity as compared to the Maoists. They are a lot more organized and are a potent threat, when was the last time that that the Maoists could detonate a Truck bomb in Delhi? Or maybe blow up a bus in Cochin? They pose a very limited threat and their ideology ensures that even if India does not keep them in check, they themselves will keep their expansion limited whereas the Taliban have an expansionist agenda and will die (quite literally) to serve that agenda.

 

[Cherokee]

It is not imagination - it may well come out true..

If Taliban attack India, we’ll fight them, say Maoists

If aliens attack earth , i will fight them too .

 

[Teeta]

And how did they get so brutal, well equipped, dedicated and experienced in the first place?

Brainwashing......

Islamic Ideology is probably THE strongest , MOST comprehensive and complete ideology human race has ever seen. If you use it to manipulate its followers, it can make them monsters! Specially under desperate situations as one see in Afghanistan or Somalia etc.

Regarding equipment : We and Pakistanis provided them with that.....

 

[cyphercide]

Maoists Vs Taliban? Taliban would walk all over the Maoists. The Taliban have much greater operational capacity as compared to the Maoists. They are a lot more organized and are a potent threat, when was the last time that that the Maoists could detonate a Truck bomb in Delhi? Or maybe blow up a bus in Cochin? They pose a very limited threat and their ideology ensures that even if India does not keep them in check, they themselves will keep their expansion limited whereas the Taliban have an expansionist agenda and will die (quite literally) to serve that agenda.

What makes you think that the Maoists would want to detonate a bomb laden truck in the capital? They are far more efficient in matters of propaganda than the Taliban.

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

some videos of talibans beheading people are enough to wet the pents of maoists and you people here ....i bet you will not be able to sleep whole night .....Salute to the Pak army jawans for having the courage and dare to fight these people in taliban controlled areas

Well i have seem some of these video in mobile of my cousin who was doing operation in waziristan..they are ruthless heartless people

 

[Icarus]

What makes you think that the Maoists would want to detonate a bomb laden truck in the capital? They are far more efficient in matters of propaganda than the Taliban.

Bomb the capital- Coverage, Attention, Strike Fear, Make yourself relevant.\

Propaganda-Taliban have their own online video channel, own written publications, over 5000 blogs and forums and over 30 radio channels (At their peak) in FATA. The Maoists don't come close in matters of propaganda.

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

last few hundred years rught from kicking butt og ottomans to eradicating mughal misrule, to planting their boots in muslim holy land of arabia to palestiine its christian all the way. muslims may have had a few initial success, but over the long term you have to see

Dont act stupid and read history before talking about it..you are mixing up jewd with christians and also i think for you Hulagu Khan was also christian lol

Islam is not ancient religion compare to hinduism, buddism , judiasm and christianity but look how its spread in four continent and still going on

 

[KRAIT]

Maoists Vs Taliban? Taliban would walk all over the Maoists. The Taliban have much greater operational capacity as compared to the Maoists. They are a lot more organized and are a potent threat, when was the last time that that the Maoists could detonate a Truck bomb in Delhi? Or maybe blow up a bus in Cochin? They pose a very limited threat and their ideology ensures that even if India does not keep them in check, they themselves will keep their expansion limited whereas the Taliban have an expansionist agenda and will die (quite literally) to serve that agenda.

I don't know about Taliban's influence in the educated society, Maoists have now reached the elite class of Engineers, Doctors, Lawyers, Writers etc. But these class have opted for non violent means.

Also, Maoists don't have that quality of weapons and their supply which Taliban has. Also, the field of operation of Maoists and Taliban are different. Terrain, geographical location, weather etc. all play an important role and hence distinguishes both the groups.

Secondly, Maoists have been effectively countered in many areas, not only through security but also through developmental and rehabilitation programs. Problem in Taliban case is that the Taliban soldiers don't have any other option and even if they leave they might become target of their own people just because they deserted them. And no guarantee of these people where even US soldiers are not safe.

So we are talking about different region, different social structure, different ideologies and different fire power. That's why this whole comparison is useless.

If one wants to study them comparatively, they should look at how these groups grew. The dynamics associated with one group may be analogous to other.

 

[Teeta]

Dont act stupid and read history before talking about it..you are mixing up jewd with christians and also i think for you Hulagu Khan was also christian lol

Islam is not ancient religion compare to hinduism, buddism , judiasm and christianity but look how its spread in four continent and still going on

lol, good point. Historically, christians weren't even any threat to Islamic Empires. Major blows to Islamic Power came from Mongols, or from "intra-Muslim" conflicts for power etc.

But, seems that Mr Funtoosh isn't much familiar with military history , or just history for that matter.

 

[cyphercide]

Brainwashing......

Islamic Ideology is probably THE strongest , MOST comprehensive and complete ideology human race has ever seen. If you use it to manipulate its followers, it can make them monsters! Specially under desperate situations as one see in Afghanistan or Somalia etc.

Regarding equipment : We and Pakistanis provided them with that.....

Hah. The United States systematically radicalized our environment for their own benefits. You don't get to hide behind the hapless state of Pakistan to cover up your sins.

I don't buy your theory on religion either because Islamic ideology was deliberately induced to perversion by foreign(read American) influences.