Karnataka hijab row.. Asaduddin Owaisi rants against Pakistan

[Pak_Sher]

Trying to survive as a minority in India. Abhee or jutay parain ga Hindutva say. Just wait. Tumaray ghar ka mamlah hai, jutay bhee tum khayoo. Saray k saray

 

[SaadH]

Why you guys share everything about him? who is he? His statement has no value neither in Indian politics nor in pakistani politics.

Because he is emblematic of the core issue plaguing Indian Muslims...

They continue to bash Pakistan in the misconceived hope that it will endear them to their hindu compatriots...instead of standing up for their rights on their own merits and strength.

BTW, where are Indian Muslim men, why are they so conspicuously missing from the protest and resistance, as someone mentioned above this is biggest example of a whole population been collectively emasculated without any resistance, perhaps the worst case in history.

I always compare the Indian Muslims' plight and their resistance or lack thereof to that African Americans, who constitute a similar proportion to the overall population and have arguably been subjected a more brutal and systematic subjugation and yet they resisted without fear of death. Even to this day, Black people standup to authority in the US when they are wronged even knowing that just meekly surrendering will most likely result in their being unharmed, yet at a tremendous risk to their lives and in many cases they fight back against abuse by Police.

I just wish Indian Muslims can replicate even a fraction of courage of African Americans.

 

[SD 10]

Pakistan kidr se a gya ab idr...... mtlb kuch bhi

 

[alphapak]

Why has he dragged Pakistan into this hijab iissue? or am I missing something?

 

[GumNaam]

is this chootad trying to prove his loyalty to his hindutva overloads again?

 

[kingQamaR]

He’s an Indian what good do you want him to say about us

Some of you have already forgotten our history and are still piping on about religion unity

Bangladeshis taught you this in 1971 religion has no importance to these groups on the other side of indus borders they are poisonous snakes

 

[GumNaam]

He’s an Indian what good do you want him to say about us

Some of you have already forgotten our history and are still piping on about religion unity

Bangladeshis taught you this in 1971 religion has no importance to these groups on the other side of indus borders they are poisonous snakes

that's a pretty one sided view of Bangladesh...completely devoid of the fact that minority but controlling western ruling elite had neglected the eastern population to the extent that when a bengali won the elections fair and square, treacherous traitors like bhutto and yahya refused to even call in the parliament session, what the hell did you expect the bengali Pakistanis to think except that the west really hates us and we have no choice to get independence...I mean, DUH! Had power been peacefully transferred, west and east Pakistan would still be together today, mujib would've never simply settled for Bangladesh if he was going to be the ruler over both east and west. would you settle for a suzuki mehran when you had the chance of owning a chevy impala? answer is obvious...face it, the western ruling minority elite gave the entire fiasco an ethnic trust
twist.

@Bilal9 your thoughts good sir?

 

[xeuss]

Because he is emblematic of the core issue plaguing Indian Muslims...

They continue to bash Pakistan in the misconceived hope that it will endear them to their hindu compatriots...instead of standing up for their rights on their own merits and strength.

BTW, where are Indian Muslim men, why are they so conspicuously missing from the protest and resistance, as someone mentioned above this is biggest example of a whole population been collectively emasculated without any resistance, perhaps the worst case in history.

I always compare the Indian Muslims' plight and their resistance or lack thereof to that African Americans, who constitute a similar proportion to the overall population and have arguably been subjected a more brutal and systematic subjugation and yet they resisted without fear of death. Even to this day, Black people standup to authority in the US when they are wronged even knowing that just meekly surrendering will most likely result in their being unharmed, yet at a tremendous risk to their lives and in many cases they fight back against abuse by Police.

I just wish Indian Muslims can replicate even a fraction of courage of African Americans.

I reluctantly agree with what you have said, but there is important point that you should take note of and factor in your thoughts

The Indian Muslims have been subjected to numerous state sponsored pogroms that have absolutely brutalized the community.

 

[Wood]

Because he is emblematic of the core issue plaguing Indian Muslims...

They continue to bash Pakistan in the misconceived hope that it will endear them to their hindu compatriots...instead of standing up for their rights on their own merits and strength.

BTW, where are Indian Muslim men, why are they so conspicuously missing from the protest and resistance, as someone mentioned above this is biggest example of a whole population been collectively emasculated without any resistance, perhaps the worst case in history.

I always compare the Indian Muslims' plight and their resistance or lack thereof to that African Americans, who constitute a similar proportion to the overall population and have arguably been subjected a more brutal and systematic subjugation and yet they resisted without fear of death. Even to this day, Black people standup to authority in the US when they are wronged even knowing that just meekly surrendering will most likely result in their being unharmed, yet at a tremendous risk to their lives and in many cases they fight back against abuse by Police.

I just wish Indian Muslims can replicate even a fraction of courage of African Americans.

The African American population in US were subject to incomparable treatment before the civil rights movement in the US. They were not allowed to sit in the same school or use the same rest room as the white man. Such treatment was the norm and not the exception. Despite my criticism of the right wing movement in India today, I don't agree that the Indian Muslim population have that level of a problem. Even if you find some comparable incidents in India, it will only be an exception.

However, I do agree that there are strong parallels between the alt right movement in the US and the conservative momentum in India today. Here the African community in the US have several advantage that minority communities in India do not have.

a) Trump (and the Republican party) did not win the popular vote. Modi consistently trumps everyone else in India when it comes to popularity.
b) Mainstream US media was always against Trump. In India, this is the opposite. Mainstream media is completely under BJP's spell.
c) Trump popularity continued to plummet throughout his Presidency in US. Meanwhile, Modi's popularity has continued to dominate throughout his tenure despite self inflicted pain like demonetization.

Under the above conditions, I don't see many options for Indian Muslims to protest against the government.

 

[Adonis]

He's a bloody fool.
Someone needs to tell him that all minorities in Pakistan have two votes in all elections, reserved seats proportional to their percentage of population, plus equal rights in open elections.

What does that mean?.....What is the representation of minorities in Pakistan on higher seats??

 

[Sayfullah]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1485011978410205192

No surprises from someone who wouldn’t dare say Allah Hu Akbar on live TV

 

[Maula Jatt]

that's a pretty one sided view of Bangladesh...completely devoid of the fact that minority but controlling western ruling elite had neglected the eastern population to the extent that when a bengali won the elections fair and square, treacherous traitors like bhutto and yahya refused to even call in the parliament session, what the hell did you expect the bengali Pakistanis to think except that the west really hates us and we have no choice to get independence...I mean, DUH! Had power been peacefully transferred, west and east Pakistan would still be together today, mujib would've never simply settled for Bangladesh if he was going to be the ruler over both east and west. would you settle for a suzuki mehran when you had the chance of owning a chevy impala? answer is obvious...face it, the western ruling minority elite gave the entire fiasco an ethnic trust
twist.

@Bilal9 your thoughts good sir?

pure BS, Bengalis are ethno-nationalist to the core, always were, always will be
look at history they have always rebelled against Delhi sultanate, they always want to do their own thing and are also very proud of it - which is their right and I am not going to say its inherently bad
its us the Indus Muslims who have stayed together ONE way or another for 800-1000 years already, we should put some respect on our historical linkages BY NOT TURNING THIS whole Pakistan thing into one big pan Muslim BS mess which never existed nor will it ever exist

He’s an Indian what good do you want him to say about us

Some of you have already forgotten our history and are still piping on about religion unity

Bangladeshis taught you this in 1971 religion has no importance to these groups on the other side of indus borders they are poisonous snakes

My brother I deeply respect you for always saying it how it really is! and not getting into Islamist pan cluster BS

 

[GumNaam]

pure BS, Bengalis are ethno-nationalist to the core, always were, always will be
look at history they have always rebelled against Delhi sultanate, they always want to do their own thing and are also very proud of it - which is their right and I am not going to say its inherently bad
its us the Indus Muslims who have stayed together ONE way or another for 800-1000 years already, we should put some respect on our historical linkages BY NOT TURNING THIS whole Pakistan thing into one big pan Muslim BS mess which never existed nor will it ever exist

your entire argument falls apart on the simple historical fact that the bengali Muslims were the first ones to support Muhammed Ali Jinnah, a nonbengali, on his demand for Pakistan. Pakistan is not a sultanate, the bengali identity could have very easily co-existed with other identities under the greater umbrella of Pakistan just as many identities happily exist today under the greater umbrella of Pakistan and its ideology. east Pakistanis weren't asking for much. Just the preservation of their language and equal representation. In the 24 years of Pakistan's existance up until 1971, nearly 60% of Pakistan's population was bengali and yet, not a single army chief, air force chief or naval chief was ever a bengali. this is just one of the many many glaring mistakes the ruling western minority elite had made. Would've cost us nothing to embrace the east Pakistanis along with their cultural identity as our brothers. But calling them people of "adhaa imaan" (yahya) and "kuttay kay bachay" (bhutto) cost us half the country.

 

[PakSarZameen47]

your entire argument falls apart on the simple historical fact that the bengali Muslims were the first ones to support Muhammed Ali Jinnah, a nonbengali, on his demand for Pakistan. Pakistan is not a sultanate, the bengali identity could have very easily co-existed with other identities under the greater umbrella of Pakistan just as many identities happily exist today under the greater umbrella of Pakistan and its ideology. east Pakistanis weren't asking for much. Just the preservation of their language and equal representation. In the 24 years of Pakistan's existance up until 1971, nearly 60% of Pakistan's population was bengali and yet, not a single army chief, air force chief or naval chief was ever a bengali. this is just one of the many many glaring mistakes the ruling western minority elite had made. Would've cost us nothing to embrace the east Pakistanis along with their cultural identity as our brothers. But calling them people of "adhaa imaan" (yahya) and "kuttay kay bachay" (bhutto) cost us half the country.

 

[SaadH]

I reluctantly agree with what you have said, but there is important point that you should take note of and factor in your thoughts

The Indian Muslims have been subjected to numerous state sponsored pogroms that have absolutely brutalized the community.

True but nothing can be analogous to slavery, though Indian Muslims are currently in the same predicament as Jim Crow South and therein is the lesson for them on how African Americans resisted against that and somewhat overcame it.