Jallikattu ban lifited

[Maravan]

I remember in 2011, when even after the SC banned it, Jallikattu events went on as usual as police were unable to do anything. I do feel as you. Its a game played by BJP. The Ordinance or the change in notification could be brought long back, so as to face the court even later.

MMK leader Sethuraman announced irrespective of the court order they will conduct jallikattu. Jaya is almost a goner this time, she must act to save her face.

 

[livingdead]

Like kumbamaela where a huge crowd gathers and pollutes river ganges? Of Course whipping horses to make them run fast is modernity for you people. Any way that doesn't matter, Between who the hell rest of india to decide what culture tamils should follow and what is modernity for them?

you are just clutching staws mate.. kumbh mela is like any other gathering and am sure elements of it can be modernized and nobody will say 'damn it we will do it the way our forefathers did'...

 

[sathya]

Even though I am tamilian, I was against jallikattu,

My main point of contension is not animal cruelty but human injuries

Quiet a lot of people mostly onlookers also get injuries,
Numbers will be around 100 s in a single jallikattu.

It becomes quiet a trouble at government hospitals,
With no special man power allotment, no bonuses for extra work like that,
It burdens the limited people, no added benefits, and at the end will have hear the all unsatisfactory patients grumbling ..

If all rules and regulations and necessitates are taken care off. It is of no problem.

I am not for letting down indigenous breeds , even with dogs.
I didn't even support beef ban..

 

[Maravan]

Even though I am tamilian, I was against jallikattu,

My main point of contension is not animal cruelty but human injuries

Quiet a lot of people mostly onlookers also get injuries,
Numbers will be around 100 s in a single jallikattu.

It becomes quiet a trouble at government hospitals,
With no special man power allotment, no bonuses for extra work like that,
It burdens the limited people, no added benefits, and at the end will have hear the all unsatisfactory patients grumbling ..

If all rules and regulations and necessitates are taken care off. It is of no problem.

I am not for letting down indigenous breeds , even with dogs.
I didn't even support beef ban..

No one complained about the injuries from the family of the ones participating in that.. Injuries happen even during riding bikes, shall we ban automobiles then? It's a game famous in the land of pandiyas, this game is only for the brave and to boost men's moral.. Result, pandiyas were the longest ruling indian dynasty in the history..

 

[Maravan]

you are just clutching staws mate.. kumbh mela is like any other gathering and am sure elements of it can be modernized and nobody will say 'damn it we will do it the way our forefathers did'...

Ban and modernise is entirely two different things. Kumbamaela can be modernised, but Jallikattu can't be? Jallikattu is already modernised, bulls will enter the field only after a group of doctors appointed by the govt, check the bull's condition. Don't comment on things which you aren't aware..

 

[Lonely Hermit]

Indian states don't have autonomy and it's not necessary for the centre to act. Now the DMK karunanidhi's DEMAND for state autonomy proved to be worthy..

You don't act that much butt hurt when Supreme court ask Karnataka to release water.
SC orders immediate release of Cauvery water to save Tamil Nadu’s standing crops

Or when it asked Kerala to raise dam height
Supreme Court okays raising height of Periyar Dam; Tamil Nadu happy, Kerala glum - The Economic Times

 

[Bombermanx1]

they did the right thing by banning it.. not sure why they are going backward..
if fighting a bull is your identity, then fcuk your identity...

Who are you to question a sport which is 3000 years old? Your PETA and animal activists fall silent during bakr-eid .
They will discuss Jallikattu and cruelty to animals over some beef burgers and Chicken nuggets.
What a bunch of Hypocrites.
This is deliberate targeting of Hindu customs and Supreme court can go to hell, if people revolt then no power in the world can stop them from conducting the festival.

 

[$@rJen]

they did the right thing by banning it.. not sure why they are going backward..
if fighting a bull is your identity, then fcuk your identity...

**** you.. your so called Animal Rights group or whatever mothefcrs they're.... India Ranks Nomber one in the world to export beef... where are these scums when they're cutting cows???? You should be ashamed of yourself

 

[sathya]

No one complained about the injuries from the family of the ones participating in that.. Injuries happen even during riding bikes, shall we ban automobiles then? It's a game famous in the land of pandiyas, this game is only for the brave and to boost men's moral.. Result, pandiyas were the longest ruling indian dynasty in the history..

Visit casualty of a medical college for day. Let alone during the Jallikattu.
You will understand what I am talking about.
On a single shift we admitted 124 patients. Some with their guts out.
I just asked enough arrangements to be made, to have a comfortable event for everyone.

There is a difference between emergency mass casualties from bus accidents and a elective bull sport.

Bike example is not apt here.

 

[Maravan]

Visit casualty of a medical college for day. Let alone during the Jallikattu.
You will understand what I am talking about.
On a single shift we admitted 124 patients. Some with their guts out.
I just asked enough arrangements to be made, to have a comfortable event for everyone.

There is a difference between emergency mass casualties from bus accidents and a elective bull sport.

Bike example is not apt here.

How many human casualties after the new guidelines? Almost zero.. Doctors team & ambulance will be in alert during the event. And it's not compulsory for anyone to participate, it's only for those who are willing.. After a serious injury, anyone's guts will be shattered, its not so special only with jallikattu..

 

[Maravan]

You don't act that much butt hurt when Supreme court ask Karnataka to release water.
SC orders immediate release of Cauvery water to save Tamil Nadu’s standing crops

Or when it asked Kerala to raise dam height
Supreme Court okays raising height of Periyar Dam; Tamil Nadu happy, Kerala glum - The Economic Times

Don't be so much stupid, what's the use of state autonomy for an interstate issue? It's foolish to compare modern day water crisis with a very old cultural tradition.

 

[Lonely Hermit]

Don't be so much stupid, what's the use of state autonomy for an interstate issue? It's foolish to compare modern day water crisis with a very old cultural tradition.

The question is about rule of law. The court judgement has to be followed whatever the supreme court says if supreme doesn't ban jallikattu Madras high court will. You need to follow due legal process in civilized society not rant and spread propaganda about perceived suppression of Tamil.

 

[itsanufy]

Who are you to question a sport which is 3000 years old? Your PETA and animal activists fall silent during bakr-eid .
They will discuss Jallikattu and cruelty to animals over some beef burgers and Chicken nuggets.
What a bunch of Hypocrites.
This is deliberate targeting of Hindu customs and Supreme court can go to hell, if people revolt then no power in the world can stop them from conducting the festival.

3000 year old Hindu Customs are targeted by court!. Please use people power to bring back sati...

 

[Maravan]

The question is about rule of law. The court judgement has to be followed whatever the supreme court says if supreme doesn't ban jallikattu Madras high court will. You need to follow due legal process in civilized society not rant and spread propaganda about perceived suppression of Tamil.

Do you know what's mean by state autonomy? It won't be a law if 100 fools outside this state who don't know anything about the culture passes a stupid theory in parliament won't become a law. If the people of the land passes a law then it's legal, not by some fools outside the state making it.. Then there is no much of a difference between British rule and indian rule.

If rest of india vote to revoke article 370 from kashmir, without Kashmiri's concern then it's oppression isn't? That's what happening with TN now.

 

[Lonely Hermit]

Do you know what's mean by state autonomy? It won't be a law if 100 fools outside this state who don't know anything about the culture passes a stupid theory in parliament won't become a law. If the people of the land passes a law then it's legal, not by some fools outside the state making it.. Then there is no much of a difference between British rule and indian rule.

If rest of india vote to revoke article 370 from kashmir, without Kashmiri's concern then it's oppression isn't? That's what happening with TN now.

In a federal system all state have certain level of autonomy but a central body will always have overreaching powers this is the case with all federal system like US, Mexico, Germany, Brazil. If we didn't have this kind of balance of power we could never have abolished practices like untouchability.