What's new

Indian Navy discharges sailor who underwent sex change to become woman

Orca

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Nov 30, 2016
Messages
661
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Indian Navy discharges sailor who underwent sex change to become woman
The Navy has discharged the services a sailor who underwent gender reassignment surgery to become a woman.

Last Updated: Oct 10, 2017, 12:17 PM IST

630931-woman.jpg

Representative Image
NEW DELHI: The Navy has discharged the services of a sailor who underwent gender reassignment surgery to become a woman.

Manish Giri, the sailor, underwent surgery in Mumbai last year after he felt like "a woman trapped in a man's body". He now goes by the name "Sabi" and started dressing up like a woman.

Post surgery, the sailor returned to the INS Eksila base in Visakhapatnam, when the issues cropped up.





The sailor was allegedly kept in a psychiatric ward for six months by the maritime force.

This is the first ever case of gender transformation in the Indian Navy, which claimed that it recruited Giri under the “Indian male citizen" clause seven years ago.

The Navy does induct women officers but recruits only men as sailors, soldiers, and airmen in entry-level or lower ranks. Currently, transgenders or transsexual people are not allowed to join the armed forces.

The maritime force served the discharge letter on Friday, dismissing Giri by invoking the clause of 'Service No Longer Required' under the Navy Regulations", post-approval from the defense ministry.

The sailor is also not eligible for any pension because of mandatory service clause of 15 years in the armed forces.

In its official statement, the Indian maritime force said, "The serving sailor, who underwent sex reassignment surgery at a private facility whilst on leave, was administratively discharged from the service," the statement said.

"The individual chose to undergo irreversible gender re-assignment on his own accord whilst on leave, wilfully altering his gender status from the one he was recruited for at the time of his induction," it said.

"He has, therefore, breached the Recruitment Regulations and eligibility criteria for his employment as a sailor in the Indian Navy. The existing service rules and regulations do not permit the sailor's continued employment owing to his altered gender status, medical condition and resultant employability restrictions," it added.


Giri has vowed to fight for justice.
dlteov1uqaefut0_100917094755.jpg
 
Sailor of Indian Navy undergone sex change- See images before and after
Know more : | | | | |
mainimg1507609968.jpg

Delhi 10 Oct Total News
Indian Navy discharged sailor Mahesh Giri from his services after he has changed his sex into female. Issuing a press release on behalf of Navy, Manish's sex change has been told against the service rule. After changing sex, Manish Giri has changed his name and now it is Sibee Giri. Only men's appointment has been made in the Navy's post of sailor. For the first time, the Navy has faced such a case.

Navy has argued for his removal from the job that Manish Giri had undergone surgery for a sex change during a holiday. He did this task with his own will, which can not be changed later. By changing his Gender status during joining the Navy, he broke rules of recruitment and the qualifications of his appointment. According to the existing rules, the sailor can not be allowed to remain in service due to restrictions regarding sex status, medical condition and recruitment. They have been removed from the service of administrative service. Navy further said that this step has been taken under the rules of Navy, according to the provision, it is said that there is no need for service.

Manish, a Mumbai man, had joined the Navy as a sailor 7 years ago in the Marine Engineering Department of Eastern Naval Command. After a few years of service, he felt that there was a woman inside him. After this, in 2016, he talked to a doctor in Vishakhapatnam and got his treatment. The doctor gave them the idea of ??sex change and after that he took leave of twenty-two days and had sex re-assignment surgery in Delhi. After the surgery, Manish returned to the Naval Base of Vishakhapatnam and came back. After this he raised his hair and started wearing sarees.

Share News


Total News To Stay Updated With News Like Our Facebook Page
 
Navy sacks sailor for undergoing sex change surgery
The Navy said the sailor who underwent "sex reassignment surgery" while on leave was administratively discharged from the service.
  • By: PTI | New Delhi | Published:October 10, 2017 12:44 pm
navy-759.jpg
Giri had been posted at a naval facility in Visakhapatnam. (Express File)
The Indian Navy has sacked a sailor for undergoing a sex change surgery last year, holding him guilty of breaching service rules. Manish Giri, a naval sailor, had undergone the sex change surgery in August at a hospital in Mumbai when he was on leave.

“The Indian Navy has discharged Manish Giri, a naval sailor, evoking the clause of ‘Service No Longer Required’ under the Navy regulations,” the Navy said in a statement.

It said the sailor who underwent “sex reassignment surgery” while on leave was administratively discharged from the service.

“The individual chose to undergo irreversible gender re-assignment on his own accord, whilst on leave wilfully altering his gender status from the one he was recruited for at the time of his induction,” it said.

Giri was posted at a naval facility in Visakhapatnam.

“He has breached the Recruitment Regulations and eligibility criteria for his employment as a sailor in the Indian Navy,” the Navy said.

It said that the existing service rules and regulations do not permit the sailor’s continued employment owing to his altered gender status, medical condition and “resultant employability restrictions”.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App
 
India navy discharges officer after sex change
  • 10 October 2017
  • From the sectionIndia
_98247277_sexchange.jpg
Image copyrightHINDUSTAN TIMES
Image captionSabi has said that she will appeal to military court against her sacking
An Indian naval officer who underwent sex change surgery has been discharged from service.

A navy statement said its "rules and regulations do not permit the sailor's continued employment" because of "irreversible gender reassignment".

Sabi, formerly Manish Giri, has said that she will appeal to the military court against her sacking.

It has sparked a debate on transgender rights in India, where it is legally recognised as a third gender.

Sabi joined the Indian navy in 2010. She underwent gender reassignment surgery in late 2016 while on leave.

When she returned to work, she alleged that she was confined to a psychiatric ward for nearly five months.

"It was like being in jail," she told BBC Hindi's Sushila Singh.

The Indian navy has not yet responded to the allegations, and has declined to comment when contacted by the BBC.

Sabi said she rejoined the navy in April, and she received a letter discharging her from service on 6 October.

"The individual chose to undergo irreversible gender reassignment on his own accord, whilst on leave wilfully altering his gender status from the one he was recruited for at the time of his induction," a navy statement on her sacking said.

An Indian Court ruled in 2012 that there was no legal bar to an adult man having a sex change surgery. And in a landmark ruling in 2014, India's Supreme Court also recognised transgender people as a third gender.

"I am not a criminal, I have done nothing wrong, I have only revealed my true identity," Sabi said, adding that she would fight for "justice".

But legal experts say that transgender people in India are in a strange situation: on the one hand, they are legally recognised and protected under the Constitution, but on the other hand they may have been judged to be breaking the law if they have consensual gay sex.
 
An Indian naval officer who underwent sex change surgery has been discharged from service.

A navy statement said its "rules and regulations do not permit the sailor's continued employment" because of "irreversible gender reassignment".

Sabi, formerly Manish Giri, has said that she will appeal to the military court against her sacking.

It has sparked a debate on transgender rights in India, where it is legally recognised as a third gender.

Sabi joined the Indian navy in 2010. She underwent gender reassignment surgery in late 2016 while on leave.

When she returned to work, she alleged that she was confined to a psychiatric ward for nearly five months.

"It was like being in jail," she told BBC Hindi's Sushila Singh.

The Indian navy has not yet responded to the allegations, and has declined to comment when contacted by the BBC.

Sabi said she rejoined the navy in April, and she received a letter discharging her from service on 6 October.

"The individual chose to undergo irreversible gender reassignment on his own accord, whilst on leave wilfully altering his gender status from the one he was recruited for at the time of his induction," a navy statement on her sacking said.

An Indian Court ruled in 2012 that there was no legal bar to an adult man having a sex change surgery. And in a landmark ruling in 2014, India's Supreme Court also recognised transgender people as a third gender.

"I am not a criminal, I have done nothing wrong, I have only revealed my true identity," Sabi said, adding that she would fight for "justice".

But legal experts say that transgender people in India are in a strange situation: on the one hand, they are legally recognised and protected under the Constitution, but on the other hand they may have been judged to be breaking the law if they have consensual gay sex.

According to a 153-year-old colonial-era law, a same-sex relationship is an "unnatural offence" and punishable by a 10-year jail term.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-41566641
 
Back
Top Bottom