NEW DELHI Many of India's protected tribal groups live in "beastly" conditions and the government should review long-standing laws that keep them in isolation, the country's tribal affairs minister told AFP.
His comments were prompted by a scandal involving a video of naked Jarawa tribal women on the tropical Andaman Islands being told to dance for tourists, who had allegedly bribed a policeman to gain access to their reserve.
Contact with several tribes on the islands, set deep in the Indian Ocean, is illegal in a bid to protect their indigenous way of life and shield them from diseases against which they have no protection.
The policy means that while economic development is surging ahead in India's main cities, there remain pockets of the country where conditions have hardly evolved in centuries and modernity is deliberately kept out.
"As far as my personal view is concerned it will be unfair to leave them like that in a beastly condition forever," Tribal Affairs Minister Kishore Chandra Deo told AFP in an interview.
"At the same time I would add that I am certainly not one who would like to expose them to shopping mall and junk culture."
Not all of India's vast number of indigenous groups are protected or live in reserves, but they consistently rank bottom in terms of human development alongside "untouchables" at the bottom of India's caste system.
Deo, who has vowed to visit the Andaman Islands on a special trip within weeks, said that the issue of how to deal with protected tribal groups was highly divisive and that the government needed to listen to tribal people.
"We have to start a dialogue," he said. "A lot of the (Jarawa tribe) youngsters have learnt to speak Hindi, so one has to explain things to them and come to some conclusion.
"They have traditions, lots of indigenous knowledge, and they also have to enjoy the benefits of development that have taken place but it has to be a gradual process. There has to be a consensus."
Other groups and campaigners, such as Survival International, say tribes such as the 402-strong Jarawa should be left alone.
The London-based campaigner for tribal rights worldwide says the tribe is threatened by a road that brings traffic, tourists and trade into the heart of their land.
The London-based Observer newspaper, which first published the video that triggered the controversy, said its journalist saw tourists toss bananas and biscuits to tribespeople on the roadside.
It also said local traders had openly advised how much to bribe the police to spend a day out with the Jarawa.
Other tribes on the Andamans, such as the Sentinelese, shun all contact with the outside world and are known to be hostile to any encroachers.
Their last remaining territory, North Sentinel island, is out of bounds even to the Indian navy in a bid to protect its reclusive inhabitants who number only about 150.
Some government officials in the capital of the Andaman Islands, Port Blair, say it is difficult to determine whether the tribes want to be left alone or not.
"I communicate with the Jarawas and I see their willingness to contact us is increasing by the day," head of the Andamans' Tribal Welfare Department, Som Naidu, told AFP.
"At the same time they love their habitats and traditions so one must not rush to conclusions. They see us and love to wear the clothes we wear but washing the clothes is alien to them."
Naidu said that the government in New Delhi had recently formed an expert panel to investigate the "hands-off" isolation policy, which was first enacted in the 1950s and further strengthened in 2004.
Suresh Babu, of Delhi's Ambedkar University, said studies he had carried out in the Andamans suggested that observers should not idealise the tribes' lifestyle.
"Tourists have a fanciful image of the great life of the hunter-gatherers of these beautiful islands," the researcher wrote in The Indian Express.
"They fall ill from malaria and other common ailments, although they are not exposed to the deadly germs we carry, and survive employing whatever traditional medicines they can conjure up."
His conclusions are disputed by Samir Acharya, a founder of the Society for Andaman and Nicobar Ecology environmental group, who opposes any weakening of the non-contact law.
"Their quality of life is quite good," Acharya told AFP from Port Blair, adding that efforts to bring tribal people on the island into the mainstream had been bad for them.
He cited the example of Andaman's largest tribal population, the Nicobarese, who have been given government jobs and modern homes and facilities.
"Their traditional food was coconuts and now they have been taught to eat rice although they do not grow any, and as a result they now need cash to buy food.
"The Nicobarese are unused to labour, but they now toil to find ways to fulfil their modern aspirations like whisky," he said. "Is that a good life?"
AFP: Indian minister queries tribal 'isolation' policy
His comments were prompted by a scandal involving a video of naked Jarawa tribal women on the tropical Andaman Islands being told to dance for tourists, who had allegedly bribed a policeman to gain access to their reserve.
Contact with several tribes on the islands, set deep in the Indian Ocean, is illegal in a bid to protect their indigenous way of life and shield them from diseases against which they have no protection.
The policy means that while economic development is surging ahead in India's main cities, there remain pockets of the country where conditions have hardly evolved in centuries and modernity is deliberately kept out.
"As far as my personal view is concerned it will be unfair to leave them like that in a beastly condition forever," Tribal Affairs Minister Kishore Chandra Deo told AFP in an interview.
"At the same time I would add that I am certainly not one who would like to expose them to shopping mall and junk culture."
Not all of India's vast number of indigenous groups are protected or live in reserves, but they consistently rank bottom in terms of human development alongside "untouchables" at the bottom of India's caste system.
Deo, who has vowed to visit the Andaman Islands on a special trip within weeks, said that the issue of how to deal with protected tribal groups was highly divisive and that the government needed to listen to tribal people.
"We have to start a dialogue," he said. "A lot of the (Jarawa tribe) youngsters have learnt to speak Hindi, so one has to explain things to them and come to some conclusion.
"They have traditions, lots of indigenous knowledge, and they also have to enjoy the benefits of development that have taken place but it has to be a gradual process. There has to be a consensus."
Other groups and campaigners, such as Survival International, say tribes such as the 402-strong Jarawa should be left alone.
The London-based campaigner for tribal rights worldwide says the tribe is threatened by a road that brings traffic, tourists and trade into the heart of their land.
The London-based Observer newspaper, which first published the video that triggered the controversy, said its journalist saw tourists toss bananas and biscuits to tribespeople on the roadside.
It also said local traders had openly advised how much to bribe the police to spend a day out with the Jarawa.
Other tribes on the Andamans, such as the Sentinelese, shun all contact with the outside world and are known to be hostile to any encroachers.
Their last remaining territory, North Sentinel island, is out of bounds even to the Indian navy in a bid to protect its reclusive inhabitants who number only about 150.
Some government officials in the capital of the Andaman Islands, Port Blair, say it is difficult to determine whether the tribes want to be left alone or not.
"I communicate with the Jarawas and I see their willingness to contact us is increasing by the day," head of the Andamans' Tribal Welfare Department, Som Naidu, told AFP.
"At the same time they love their habitats and traditions so one must not rush to conclusions. They see us and love to wear the clothes we wear but washing the clothes is alien to them."
Naidu said that the government in New Delhi had recently formed an expert panel to investigate the "hands-off" isolation policy, which was first enacted in the 1950s and further strengthened in 2004.
Suresh Babu, of Delhi's Ambedkar University, said studies he had carried out in the Andamans suggested that observers should not idealise the tribes' lifestyle.
"Tourists have a fanciful image of the great life of the hunter-gatherers of these beautiful islands," the researcher wrote in The Indian Express.
"They fall ill from malaria and other common ailments, although they are not exposed to the deadly germs we carry, and survive employing whatever traditional medicines they can conjure up."
His conclusions are disputed by Samir Acharya, a founder of the Society for Andaman and Nicobar Ecology environmental group, who opposes any weakening of the non-contact law.
"Their quality of life is quite good," Acharya told AFP from Port Blair, adding that efforts to bring tribal people on the island into the mainstream had been bad for them.
He cited the example of Andaman's largest tribal population, the Nicobarese, who have been given government jobs and modern homes and facilities.
"Their traditional food was coconuts and now they have been taught to eat rice although they do not grow any, and as a result they now need cash to buy food.
"The Nicobarese are unused to labour, but they now toil to find ways to fulfil their modern aspirations like whisky," he said. "Is that a good life?"
AFP: Indian minister queries tribal 'isolation' policy
