What's new

Indian beef ban will cost jobs and harm economy, warn critics

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
Nitin Tarode wants to sell his old bull to help pay for his sister’s wedding, after his income was hit by patchy rainfall. But he has struggled to find a buyer who will pay a decent price because of a ban on slaughtering cows, bulls and bullocks in Maharashtra, the western state run by Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist party.

“Now I will have to take a loan for my sister’s wedding,” says Tarode, the oldest of five siblings and the only earning member of his family in Akola, nearly 370 miles from Mumbai.

A renewed thrust by Modi’s Bharatiya Janata party to protect cows, worshipped by Hindus, has closed abbatoirs in Maharashtra, making it hard for farmers to sell their animals, and restrictions are spreading to other states.

Even lions, tigers and leopards in Mumbai’s national park are being fed chicken and mutton rather than their usual beef because the city’s main abattoir has been shut for the past two weeks.

Maharashtra, India’s second most populous state, extended a ban on the slaughter of cattle this month and other BJP-led states such as Jharkhand and Haryana have also tightened restrictions on trading beef.

Critics say tougher anti-beef laws discriminate against Muslims, Christians and lower-caste Hindus, who rely on the cheap meat for protein, and fear they could pave the way to a nationwide ban that would threaten thousands of jobs.

Several thousand, mainly from the Muslim community, will be rendered jobless in the beef trade and related industries like leather goods, leaders of the business community say.

“My business is ruined. Farmers are offering cattle at much lower prices but I can’t buy because slaughtering is illegal now,” said Asif Qureshi, a cattle supplier based in Baramati, Maharashtra.

Slaughterhouses in Maharashtra are now refusing to slaughter buffalo in protest against the ban, cutting off all beef supplies in a bid to put pressure on the government. Hindus do not consider buffalo to be sacred.

Not all BJP-led states are pushing for tighter restrictions on beef. The chief minister of Goa has refused to back the ban, saying that around 40% of people there eat beef and he respected the rights of minorities.

Meanwhile, Hindu nationalist groups affiliated to the BJP want to set up more cattle camps and cow shelters to house animals no longer wanted by farmers.

India has some 300m cattle, and cows foraging for food are a familiar sight on the rubbish-strewn streets of towns and villages. Their numbers could swell by 200,000 in Maharashtra alone as farmers abandon animals they cannot sell, according to the beef trade.

Indian beef ban will cost jobs and harm economy, warn critics | World news | The Guardian
 
. .
As I said a secular state has no place dictating what a person should eat and not eat. The particular victim of this will be us muslims.

In every country with a large number of minorities there is some space, some leeway given for minorities. India does not even care for the fact that Muslims and Christians do eat beef. Even Kenya has a law directing all food to be halal. India has no such law and pizza outlets and Mcdonalds are off limits to muslims because of no halal meat.

This law is as dumb as the blasphemy law on Pakistan. I mean what is the problem if someone else eats beef. Its like me saying to a non muslim don't eat pork. It puts a curb on freedom of right and is against the secular fabric of the state. Also it is harmful to pastoral farmers and will directly hurt them, most of whom are muslims.
 
.
As I said a secular state has no place dictating what a person should eat and not eat. The particular victim of this will be us muslims.

In every country with a large number of minorities there is some space, some leeway given for minorities. India does not even care for the fact that Muslims and Christians do eat beef. Even Kenya has a law directing all food to be halal. India has no such law and pizza outlets and Mcdonalds are off limits to muslims because of no halal meat.

This law is as dumb as the blasphemy law on Pakistan. I mean what is the problem if someone else eats beef. Its like me saying to a non muslim don't eat pork. It puts a curb on freedom of right and is against the secular fabric of the state. Also it is harmful to pastoral farmers and will directly hurt them, most of whom are muslims.

I am in india now and almost all restaurant in Bangalore are Halal. Even McDonalds, Pizza hut, KFC are halal meat.
 
.
I am in india now and almost all restaurant in Bangalore are Halal. Even McDonalds, Pizza hut, KFC are halal meat.

Things could have changed since my last visit. But the Mc donalds in Delhi from where we took train to Lucknow was not halal. Neither were Pizza hut and Mc Donalds in Lucknow.
 
. . .
The Guardian as usual Spouting Anti-India news.
Economy and jobs will be harmed, by quoting anecdotal evidences?
 
.
Nitin Tarode wants to sell his old bull to help pay for his sister’s wedding, after his income was hit by patchy rainfall. But he has struggled to find a buyer who will pay a decent price because of a ban on slaughtering cows, bulls and bullocks in Maharashtra, the western state run by Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist party.

“Now I will have to take a loan for my sister’s wedding,” says Tarode, the oldest of five siblings and the only earning member of his family in Akola, nearly 370 miles from Mumbai.

A renewed thrust by Modi’s Bharatiya Janata party to protect cows, worshipped by Hindus, has closed abbatoirs in Maharashtra, making it hard for farmers to sell their animals, and restrictions are spreading to other states.

Even lions, tigers and leopards in Mumbai’s national park are being fed chicken and mutton rather than their usual beef because the city’s main abattoir has been shut for the past two weeks.

Maharashtra, India’s second most populous state, extended a ban on the slaughter of cattle this month and other BJP-led states such as Jharkhand and Haryana have also tightened restrictions on trading beef.

Critics say tougher anti-beef laws discriminate against Muslims, Christians and lower-caste Hindus, who rely on the cheap meat for protein, and fear they could pave the way to a nationwide ban that would threaten thousands of jobs.

Several thousand, mainly from the Muslim community, will be rendered jobless in the beef trade and related industries like leather goods, leaders of the business community say.

“My business is ruined. Farmers are offering cattle at much lower prices but I can’t buy because slaughtering is illegal now,” said Asif Qureshi, a cattle supplier based in Baramati, Maharashtra.

Slaughterhouses in Maharashtra are now refusing to slaughter buffalo in protest against the ban, cutting off all beef supplies in a bid to put pressure on the government. Hindus do not consider buffalo to be sacred.

Not all BJP-led states are pushing for tighter restrictions on beef. The chief minister of Goa has refused to back the ban, saying that around 40% of people there eat beef and he respected the rights of minorities.

Meanwhile, Hindu nationalist groups affiliated to the BJP want to set up more cattle camps and cow shelters to house animals no longer wanted by farmers.

India has some 300m cattle, and cows foraging for food are a familiar sight on the rubbish-strewn streets of towns and villages. Their numbers could swell by 200,000 in Maharashtra alone as farmers abandon animals they cannot sell, according to the beef trade.

Indian beef ban will cost jobs and harm economy, warn critics | World news | The Guardian

Don't be fool!!!!

Export all of these Cows and other meat animals to Pakistan. India can make $$$ Billions $$$ in this business with Pakistan.
 
.
Things could have changed since my last visit. But the Mc donalds in Delhi from where we took train to Lucknow was not halal. Neither were Pizza hut and Mc Donalds in Lucknow.

MacDonalds near the train station in Delhi is now halal. Can't speak about Lucknow tho

This beef ban law is stupid if not outrageous. There is no evidence that beef is being marketed as sheep for example to give any credibility to this law. The rights of Hindus are respected by the remaining consumers of beef who slaughter sensitively and away from Hindu residences and temples. Why are we forcing our belief unto the minorities?
 
. .
Banning food, what a nation!
The logical conclusion of this is banning pork and drinking too... if hindus are being provided extra say in the nation then its muslims turn too... this is very very silly. Even in Pakistan ZAB drew flak for banning drinking even for minorities. Now drinking is allowed for minorities provided they have a permit. But I can draw a comparison here with what Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto did.
 
.
Things could have changed since my last visit. But the Mc donalds in Delhi from where we took train to Lucknow was not halal. Neither were Pizza hut and Mc Donalds in Lucknow.
You should not lie like that. Since inception all this outlet provide Halal meat except Beef neither they loose sizable muslim consumers.
These day they write on their front gate that 'Only Halal', which they no do before.
 
.
You should not lie like that. Since inception all this outlet provide Halal meat except Beef neither they loose sizable muslim consumers.
These day they write on their front gate that 'Only Halal', which they no do before.
I am glad that things are changing. My last visit was at least 6 years ago. My parents lived a lot there though.
 
.
I am glad that things are changing. My last visit was at least 6 years ago. My parents lived a lot there though.
You should ask them, previous they didn't write on front gate in bold letters.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom