India says Burma has NO nukes

[Ingis]

The question still is why an Indian MP raised question about Burma's nukes and why Indian FM has to say in clear words "Burma has NO nukes"


I mean what relevance India has with regards to Burmese nuclear program?


Can you explain a bit so that i can understand in which context the Indian Members Parliament are raising the question officially

To put it straight, India prefers that no other country in its neighborhood (be Iran or Myanmar) acquires nuclear weapons.

Secondly, this comment has come in the wake of a Norwegian media report alleging that Myanmar is trying to develop nuclear weapons with the help of North Korea. India and Myanmar share deep military ties and obviously Indian parliamentarians would want to know whether Myanmar has a nuclear program or not. It is a matter of commonsense that India would not do military business with any country which has an active illegal nuclear weapons program (unlike some other countries).

 

[Leviza]

none of the stated accidents r of the magnitude off Chernobyl or 3 mile island,but us u had started the debate it seems the world is more concerned about security and accidents of nuclear facilities inside Pakistan

BBC NEWS | South Asia | Two die at Pakistan nuclear plant

U.S. Policy and Pakistan's Nuclear Weapons: Containing Threats and Encouraging Regional Security | The Heritage Foundation

Thinking about Pakistan's Nuclear Security in Peacetime, Crisis and War | Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses

Assessing Pakistan's Nuclear Plant Accident - Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

Pakistan’s 125 nuclear weapons at risk from terrorists and U.S. drones nuclear-news

http://belfercenter.ksg.harvard.edu/files/Pakistan%20Nuclear%20Hassan%20Abbas.pdf

Western Concern Over Security Of Pakistan’s Nuclear Arsenal | Islam Dating - Islam Chat - Muslima, Vrouw, Moslim dating Site

so when u urself r in deep water dont try to comment about Indian safety and implications for world,and by the way every source is neutral so when u plan to strike back bring similar kind of sources rather than ur controversy fed media claims

This is quite off topic but just to give you answer all these links you posted were never a concern of world. its just what media says ....
on ground there was never a threat on Pakistani nukes...

i have given you links from indian sources about accidents in indian nuclear plants,,,,, giv me one link about accidents in Pakistani Nuclear plants?????? if you know jew control all media of the world and they spread these sort of stories about Pakistani nukes where as hindu terroriest are more into indian army and they are the biggest issue these days....go and learn about nuclear history......

 

[Spring Onion]

on the contrary when U.S speaks Burma have nukes or are developing nukes,does it give an impression U.S is speaking as the official representative of Burma

There is big difference between accusation and clarification. what US is saying thats accusation for which the clarification should be coming from Burma NOT from India

 

[kashith]

yes we do have concerns about nuclear accidents in india coz we live nearby

But the main question is why india is concerned about burma nukes and how its indian security issue?
indians got nukes and its burma security concern too... i hope you got my point if you try to think with open mind which is highly unlikely thing...

you live in US/UK ?How come you live near to India,Please display your correct flags.

 

[Leviza]

To put it straight, India prefers that no other country in its neighborhood (be Iran or Myanmar) acquires nuclear weapons.

Secondly, this comment has come in the wake of a Norwegian media report alleging that Myanmar is trying to develop nuclear weapons with the help of North Korea. India and Myanmar share deep military ties and obviously Indian parliamentarians would want to know whether Myanmar has a nuclear program or not. It is a matter of commonsense that India would not do military business with any country which is has an active illegal nuclear weapons program.

so you are admitting that india have illegal nuclear program.....

My question is if india is concerned about Myanmar nukes then Myanmar have right to have concern about indian nukes coz indian nuclear plants have history of accidents....

 

[Leviza]

you live in US/UK ?How come you live near to India,Please display your correct flags.

go and read all post first and then post.... i have given my answer about this ..... my flags are correct its your flag which is in question

 

[prototype]

This is quite off topic but just to give you answer all these links you posted were never a concern of world. its just what media says ....
on ground there was never a threat on Pakistani nukes...

i have given you links from indian sources about accidents in indian nuclear plants,,,,, giv me one link about accidents in Pakistani Nuclear plants?????? if you know jew control all media of the world and they spread these sort of stories about Pakistani nukes where as hindu terroriest are more into indian army and they are the biggest issue these days....go and learn about nuclear history......

hahaha do u even read the sorces i provided,all so called media r quating different representatives from the so called govt.....the last time i think u were talking about concerns, is not it,and i dont care what u consider it as Zionist spread or hindu spread as u people can only only eat drink $hit fart and sleep onlt controversy news

 

[prototype]

There is big difference between accusation and clarification. what US is saying thats accusation for which the clarification should be coming from Burma NOT from India

ur actually now shooting on ur feet,did India clarified this in United nation,or any other international organization,this was actually a discussion which happened inside Indian parliament to which even Burma have no stakes

 

[xyz]

yes we do have concerns about nuclear accidents in india coz we live nearby

But the main question is why india is concerned about burma nukes and how its indian security issue?
indians got nukes and its burma security concern too... i hope you got my point if you try to think with open mind which is highly unlikely thing...

we do not have such radicals and fundamentalists like taliban, al qaida, LeT, JeM, JuD which will steal a nuclear bomb and bomb Pakistan or other Nations. And what ever you call Radicals like VHP, Bajrang Dal, RSS and all, they are well educated people and itellectuals, they are a part of government and government will not allow such things to happen. We work in a system which is mature.

 

[xyz]

so you are admitting that india have illegal nuclear program.....

My question is if india is concerned about Myanmar nukes then Myanmar have right to have concern about indian nukes coz indian nuclear plants have history of accidents....

That's why there is a term known as Nuclear Liability, which all responsible Nuclear Power generating states have.

 

[pmukherjee]

I am Born British and now American nation from last 11 years.... and i do love Pakistan as its my Parents country whats your problem with thisssS????

dont prevoke me to remove indians masks who will be ashamed to be called humans......



Nuclear Incident is an incident small or large, which can create hell of a mess

indian nukes record
See your face in mirror

Leaks- another mirror

-1992: Four tons of heavy water spilt at Rajasthan nuclear power plant (India)

8-1972: Radioactive water has to be pumped out of the Indian Point nuclear power plant (USA)

13-1992: Tube leak causes a radioactive release of 12 Curies of radioactivity from Tarapur nuclear power station (India)

need more details?????

Need more details??? exactly what details have you given?

I agree that even these minor leaks and malfunctions are not desirable and need to be guarded against but they are hardly episodes over which anyone has lost sleep. Most of the sources you have quoted are domestic Indian watchdog bodies who rightly insist on higher safety standards. This is constructive self criticism which is an important function of any democracy with a free media and you are using these media reports for India bashing, a favourite past time on this forum.

By grace of God, India has been spared any major nuclear accident till date. While we have to be even more cautious now that we plan to acquire / build 40 new reactors and go for nuclear power generation in a really big way, there is no justification whatsoever of your initial statement that India's neighbours are concerned over nuclear accidents in India. You should be more concerned with the Punjabi Taliban blowing up your own countrymen in large numbers.

Like I said earlier, your intentions have more to do with spiteful defamation based on improper research than on meaningful debate.

 

[Devianz]

so you are admitting that india have illegal nuclear program.....

My question is if india is concerned about Myanmar nukes then Myanmar have right to have concern about indian nukes coz indian nuclear plants have history of accidents....

You are confused between nukes (nuclear weapons) and civil nuclear program.

 

[xyz]

Need more details??? exactly what details have you given?

I agree that even these minor leaks and malfunctions are not desirable and need to be guarded against but they are hardly episodes over which anyone has lost sleep. Most of the sources you have quoted are domestic Indian watchdog bodies who rightly insist on higher safety standards. This is constructive self criticism which is an important function of any democracy with a free media and you are using these media reports for India bashing, a favourite past time on this forum.

By grace of God, India has been spared any major nuclear accident till date. While we have to be even more cautious now that we plan to acquire / build 40 new reactors and go for nuclear power generation in a really big way, there is no justification whatsoever of your initial statement that India's neighbours are concerned over nuclear accidents in India. You should be more concerned with the Punjabi Taliban blowing up your own countrymen in large numbers.

Like I said earlier, your intentions have more to do with spiteful defamation based on improper research than on meaningful debate.

plus we have upcoming N-Liability Bill, which will answer these faggots

 

[Gene]

so you are admitting that india have illegal nuclear program.....

My question is if india is concerned about Myanmar nukes then Myanmar have right to have concern about indian nukes coz indian nuclear plants have history of accidents....

the world knows whose nuclear program is illegal & whose stolen nuclear program concerns most.no need to shout here,,

incident occurs in every plant/factory through out the world & nuclear plant is not that exception.you no need to concern about that.
better question about your own country's nuclear facility which are on stolen technologies.

 

[gregarious]

so you are admitting that india have illegal nuclear program.....

My question is if india is concerned about Myanmar nukes then Myanmar have right to have concern about indian nukes coz indian nuclear plants have history of accidents....

Very valid question..let their concern come officially from them, you don't need to bother. b/w Myanmar must be happy that its neighbor just had few incidents in the past and does not have the risk of losing its nukes to some freaking militants