What's new

India fears Chinese encirclement, citing 'overwhelming' Sino presence in South Asia

CAD

FULL MEMBER
Joined
May 9, 2017
Messages
608
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
India fears Chinese encirclement, citing 'overwhelming' Sino presence in South Asia :yahoo::china::pakistan::cheers::smitten::yay:
PM
By South Asia correspondent James Bennett
Posted about 2 hours ago



PHOTO: Indian officials are concerned about China's "overwhelming" maritime presence in the region. (ABC: Bill Birtles, file)


"It would become easier for China to start projecting power into the Indian Ocean region," he said.

"Already we are seeing that the Chinese submarine deployments in the region have grown substantially."



PHOTO: China's naval power continues to increase in an age of uncertainty over America's place in the region. (Reuters, file)
The concerns come amid continuing speculation over how globally engaged the United States will remain under President Donald Trump.

Dhruva Jaishankar, a foreign policy fellow at the Brookings think tank in New Delhi said Beijing was benefiting from that uncertainty.

"China's rise as an international power has accelerated under these circumstances," he said.

"Not because in material terms Chinese power has rapidly increased in the last few months but basically because of a withdrawal in some ways, or that uncertainty about US power projection in the region."

Last Friday at the Shangri-La defence dialogue in Singapore, US Defence Secretary Jim Mattis sought to allay fears that America was vacating its global leadership role.

"We cannot and will not accept unilateral changes to the status quo," Mr Mattis said.

"We will continue to fly, sail and operate wherever international law allows, and demonstrate resolve and operational presence in the South China Sea and beyond."

Mr Singh said while India planned on expanding its naval capacity, his country saw America's role as leading a regional balancing act.

"It is being seen by New Delhi as imperative that it expands its own operational presence in the region, and to do that it would need the assistance of its close partners and friends, the US, Japan and Australia," he said.

Worried about provoking Beijing, Australia left out of regional exercises



PHOTO: Malcolm Turnbull implored China to respect the sovereignty of its neighbours in a speech at the Shangri-La dialogue. (ABC News: Adam Harvey)
But India isn't moving too quickly, apparently fearful of a Beijing backlash.

Australia confirmed last week that India had rejected its request to observe naval exercises between America, India and Japan.

Mr Singh said New Delhi's reluctance to acquiesce to Australian involvement was pragmatic.

"Because the message might be seen as a bit too provocative by China," he said.

Brookings India's Dhruva Jaishankar said that was because — like Australia — India is increasingly economically dependent on its regional rival.

"There is a need at the same time not just to take an adversarial position, and strictly balance in the traditional sense, but also to develop, particularly economically, a much more cooperative relationship with China," he said.

Also in Singapore last Friday, Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull implored China to respect the sovereignty of its neighbours and 'rules-based order' which he said had underpinned Asia's growth.

Mr Turnbull said 21st century China would gain from respecting its neighbours' sovereignty.

What is clear is that Australia is certainly not alone in feeling torn between economic and security goals.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-05/india-fears-chinese-encirclement/8591160
 
.
Afro-Asian Ocean belongs to all and is not indian private lake.

China hasn't even started patrolling the Afro-Asian Ocean and our indian friends are full of concern.

South Asian region is of great economic and strategic importance to China.

Therefore, if indians think that the Chinese will be not coming in and make camp in SA just because indians are concerned...well...indians are free to concern themselves with any or everything.

Soon PLAN and PN will instituitionalise their annual exercises and start conducting joint patrols of Afro-Asian Ocean which is of strategic importance to both Friends and Iron Brothers.

It is difficult to understand what indians really feel...

At one hand their navy chief says that they are not worried and know every move of the PLAN subs or IAF chief says is not concerned about J20...which he thinks is not stealth.. or IA is ready for two front war with China and Pak...

With the indian brahmos..what is there to worry about...and then such articles..

What do our indians really feel?

Difficult.
 
. . . . . .

They make a myth to fool others, like the Modi or India superpower myth, and then they themselves get to believe in it as most outsiders are not to be easily fooled. In the long run, they shoot themselves in the foot.

As for Indian Ocean, unlike the South China Sea, which is an inner sea, Indian Ocean is an ocean, and belong to everybody. India's concerns are unwarranted. Do they really want to blockade the entire ocean?

Besides, like other posters said, India has manpower, and it will have more and more of it in the form of a demographic dividend. Great chance to create another great service industry, this time a frogman industry.
 
.
India can stop oil imports of China in a heart beat and yet it is India which is in "fear".
The dumbness of this article is astounding.
 
. .
India fears Chinese encirclement, citing 'overwhelming' Sino presence in South Asia :yahoo::china::pakistan::cheers::smitten::yay:
PM
By South Asia correspondent James Bennett
Posted about 2 hours ago



PHOTO: Indian officials are concerned about China's "overwhelming" maritime presence in the region. (ABC: Bill Birtles, file)


"It would become easier for China to start projecting power into the Indian Ocean region," he said.

"Already we are seeing that the Chinese submarine deployments in the region have grown substantially."



PHOTO: China's naval power continues to increase in an age of uncertainty over America's place in the region. (Reuters, file)
The concerns come amid continuing speculation over how globally engaged the United States will remain under President Donald Trump.

Dhruva Jaishankar, a foreign policy fellow at the Brookings think tank in New Delhi said Beijing was benefiting from that uncertainty.

"China's rise as an international power has accelerated under these circumstances," he said.

"Not because in material terms Chinese power has rapidly increased in the last few months but basically because of a withdrawal in some ways, or that uncertainty about US power projection in the region."

Last Friday at the Shangri-La defence dialogue in Singapore, US Defence Secretary Jim Mattis sought to allay fears that America was vacating its global leadership role.

"We cannot and will not accept unilateral changes to the status quo," Mr Mattis said.

"We will continue to fly, sail and operate wherever international law allows, and demonstrate resolve and operational presence in the South China Sea and beyond."

Mr Singh said while India planned on expanding its naval capacity, his country saw America's role as leading a regional balancing act.

"It is being seen by New Delhi as imperative that it expands its own operational presence in the region, and to do that it would need the assistance of its close partners and friends, the US, Japan and Australia," he said.

Worried about provoking Beijing, Australia left out of regional exercises



PHOTO: Malcolm Turnbull implored China to respect the sovereignty of its neighbours in a speech at the Shangri-La dialogue. (ABC News: Adam Harvey)
But India isn't moving too quickly, apparently fearful of a Beijing backlash.

Australia confirmed last week that India had rejected its request to observe naval exercises between America, India and Japan.

Mr Singh said New Delhi's reluctance to acquiesce to Australian involvement was pragmatic.

"Because the message might be seen as a bit too provocative by China," he said.

Brookings India's Dhruva Jaishankar said that was because — like Australia — India is increasingly economically dependent on its regional rival.

"There is a need at the same time not just to take an adversarial position, and strictly balance in the traditional sense, but also to develop, particularly economically, a much more cooperative relationship with China," he said.

Also in Singapore last Friday, Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull implored China to respect the sovereignty of its neighbours and 'rules-based order' which he said had underpinned Asia's growth.

Mr Turnbull said 21st century China would gain from respecting its neighbours' sovereignty.

What is clear is that Australia is certainly not alone in feeling torn between economic and security goals.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-05/india-fears-chinese-encirclement/8591160
Ofcourse India is afraid of China. China and Pakistan are allies
 
. .
Lolz :lol: go on try this .
.
Even Chinese dont feel threaten by india :) .

Soon there will be a naval base of China in Gawadar :) . maybe in next 5 to 10 years .

Even Chinese?!
Your statement makes it sound as if China is nothing. Please clarify.

My post was stating the facts that India has nothing to feel threatened about China since most of Chinese Oil gets to China using our waters. ;)
 
.
.My post was stating the facts that India has nothing to feel threatened about China since most of Chinese Oil gets to China using our waters. ;)
Did you put a blockade in 1962?
.
There are reasons why you whine about CPEC :) .
.
If China isnt a threat then why your generals keep discussing two front war ? Why they make fuss when Chinese submarine visit Karachi ?
.
indian ocean isnt the property of india & we will give a naval base to China :).
 
.
Did you put a blockade in 1962?
.
There are reasons why you whine about CPEC :) .
.
If China isnt a threat then why your generals keep discussing two front war ? Why they make fuss when Chinese submarine visit Karachi ?
.
indian ocean isnt the property of india & we will give a naval base to China :).

This aint 1962.
Ever wonder why India is building up such a huge Navy?

I am not saying China fears us. What I am trying to say is that China does not fear us with their Oil passing through our waters, hence, we have ZERO fear of any of Chinese activities.

You may then bring up objections by India to CPEC or OROB but then China also objects to a lot of things of India. this does not point to fear but geo-politics.

Hope the clarification is sufficient.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom