India Crackdown Forces Rohingya Refugees to Go fUnderground, Flee to Bangladesh

[_Nabil_]

Well Hindus have no where else to go. And Gandhi had already made a promise for this.

If not us then no where to go for them.

Rohingyas have options. Not our responsibility.


I am all for giving shooting orders at Bangladesh India borders at illegal crossing. Just like LoC , not a single illegal should be allowed if the crossing is not recognised by both governments.

In fact, the Rohingyas are escaping from your Shīthole country.

You can shīt peacefully in the streets now

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

I am all for giving shooting orders at Bangladesh India borders at illegal crossing. Just like LoC , not a single illegal should be allowed if the crossing is not recognised by both governments.

Waste of ammunition but necessary

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

When I look at those cute innocent Rohingya children I feel like crying to see what they have to pass through in the age where they should be treated like a pampered prince and princess.....

It's time for both Big economies like India and Bangladesh to grant them a secure region with strictly one child policy in future....

Both India and Bangladesh can create a region among their borders which will be jointly administered by both countries and all costs should be shared by both.....

Myanmar is not going to listen and there is little we both can do anything about it..... So why not work out such solution so these kids can have a peaceful and happy life....

Problem is not that simple

Refugee influx is serious problem and often can destabilize a nation.

When a refugee crosses into your nation's border you have no idea if that person is a scientist, criminal or a destitute person escaping conflict

Refugees are poor people and very vulnerable and often end up taking a life of crime like below to make ends meet
Characteristics of group-based child sexual exploitation in the community: literature review (accessible version)

they found that the offenders in these cases were often Pakistani, Bangladeshi, Afghani and White

or even worse become national security issue-
Shonor convicted in NYC subway bombing

India took some war refuges in the past and now they are swelling up red light districts in India
Shonors held for running prostitution racket


Solution to this problem is pressurizing Myanmar to tackle the issue, Junta is never going to budge, a democratic regime most likely will

You would have millions more Hindus to house if Muslim countries like Malaysia followed Hinduvta examples.

You are free to wish for operation searchlight in Malaysia, but I doubt it would happen

 

[Black_cats]

Problem is not that simple

Refugee influx is serious problem and often can destabilize a nation.

When a refugee crosses into your nation's border you have no idea if that person is a scientist, criminal or a destitute person escaping conflict

Refugees are poor people and very vulnerable and often end up taking a life of crime like below to make ends meet
Characteristics of group-based child sexual exploitation in the community: literature review (accessible version)



or even worse become national security issue-
Shonor convicted in NYC subway bombing

India took some war refuges in the past and now they are swelling up red light districts in India
Shonors held for running prostitution racket


Solution to this problem is pressurizing Myanmar to tackle the issue, Junta is never going to budge, a democratic regime most likely will


You are free to wish for operation searchlight in Malaysia, but I doubt it would happen

There are no refugee influx as it’s stabilized years back to 40000 and now decreasing. They live in a monitored refugee camp not freely that they can go around and commit crime.

Only now India’s threat to them to put in a detention center until being deported to Myanmar prompted the Rohingyas try to cross to Bangladesh even as far as from refugee camp of Kashmir.

This is one of the most inhuman act and anti Muslim bigotry by the radical Bhakt government people.

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

There are no refugee influx as it’s stabilized years back to 40000 and now decreasing. They live in a monitored refugee camp not freely that they can go around and commit crime.

Only now India’s threat to them to put in a detention center until being deported to Myanmar prompted the Rohingyas try to cross to Bangladesh even as far as from refugee camp of Kashmir.

This is one of the most inhuman act and anti Muslim bigotry by the radical Bhakt government people.

Learning is an incremental process

Indian Govt learnt from previous experience of handling refugees, had India built detention centers then, operation pushback would have not been necessary

 

[lightoftruth]

India remains a Kasai country throughout its history independent of Muslim and British power lacking all kinds of human qualities. India is guided by its anti-Muslim stance. And this is why it can expel destitute people.

The UN General Assembly should discuss the matter of Rohingya being expelled by India and condemn India.

If India is a kasai government since long back, why should any illegal immigrant even want to be here ?

Just to be butchered ?

India is helping these poor rohingyas reaching to their prosperous higher GDP per capita motherland of bangladesh,

Whereas India is starving, poor and hell for Muslims, they deserve permanent settlement in Bangladesh.

 

[Black_cats]

Learning is an incremental process

Indian Govt learnt from previous experience of handling refugees, had India built detention centers then, operation pushback would have not been necessary

No it’s nothing to do with learning from past regarding refugees but radical Hindus anti Muslim bigotry.

Change the country name from secular democratic to Hinduva autocratic country. As in secular democratic countries these acts are not permissible.

If India is a kasai government since long back, why should any illegal immigrant even want to be here ?

Just to be butchered ?

India is helping these poor rohingyas reaching to their prosperous higher GDP per capita motherland of bangladesh,

Whereas India is starving, poor and hell for Muslims, they deserve permanent settlement in Bangladesh.

Go to school and learn difference between refugee and illegal immigrant. Finding no other legal means these Hindu radicals are trying to use fear monger if tactics towards these helpless stateless groups of people.

So much for the worlds largest democracy.

 

[lightoftruth]

Go to school and learn difference between refugee and illegal immigrant. Finding no other legal means these Hindu radicals are trying to use fear monger if tactics towards these helpless stateless groups of people.

So much for the worlds largest democracy.

Can you google whether India has signed refugee convention or not ?

We have no concept of refugees they are all illegal immigrants for us.

Our democracy is for Indians ,not for anybody pole vaulting our borders illegaly.

If your heart bleeds for your Rohingya islamic brothers ,why not accept few lakh more ? is ummah dead ?

 

[my2cents]

Should have done it much sooner. I am glad it is happening now.

We have to be more accommodating and show sympathy to their suffering.

 

[Black_cats]

Can you google whether India has signed refugee convention or not ?

We have no concept of refugees they are all illegal immigrants for us.

Our democracy is for Indians ,not for anybody pole vaulting our borders illegaly.

If your heart bleeds for your Rohingya islamic brothers ,why not accept few lakh more ? is ummah dead ?

Whoever came directly from Myanmar Bangladesh accepted it. Now housing 1.5 million of them despite geographically small country.

However Bangladesh can not accept them from India when it is trying to expel them branding illegal migrant as they are not Bangladeshi citizen. It will give incentive to Myanmar that they are Bangladeshi saying them Bengali in case they are taken.

If India has nothing to do with refugees why it’s encouraging Hindus from Bangladesh, Pakistan to go there as refugees when none has any means to prove any persecution?

For so called worlds largest democracy acting like this to refugees who carry UN refugee card and who are world’s most persecuted population, using fear mongering tactics by saying will put them in detention center and will throw them to death is indeed reflect the true nature of it and what kind of shining super power they are!

If India omit secular and democracy and change to Hindutva autocracy it would be ok but not the other way around.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Bangladesh and it's citizens are extremely important for India in terms of economics. But illegal immigration is not. Both are two different things and I am for the benefit of both nations and law abiding people from both countries in favor of extreme measures taken to counter illegal immigration.

India has no right to deport Rohingyas into Bangladesh who have gone there by crossing India-Myanmar border or those who are not registered in Bangladeshi refugee camps. This article says, these rohingyas gone to India in 2012, not related to 2017 mass exodus into Bangladesh. Just because Bangladesh host the largest number of Rohingyas do not mean it is responsible for each and every Rohingya in the world. Your govt. should contact with UNHCR and give them refugee status and put them in refugee camps until Myanmar situation improve and they can be repatriated in that country.

 

[lightoftruth]

Whoever came directly from Myanmar Bangladesh accepted it. Now housing 1.5 million of them despite geographically small country.

However Bangladesh can not accept them from India when it is trying to expel them branding illegal migrant as they are not Bangladeshi citizen. It will give incentive to Myanmar that they are Bangladeshi saying them Bengali in case they are taken.

If India has nothing to do with refugees why it’s encouraging Hindus from Bangladesh, Pakistan to go there as refugees when none has any means to prove any persecution?

For so called worlds largest democracy acting like this to refugees who carry UN refugee card and who are world’s most persecuted population, using fear mongering tactics by saying will put them in detention center and will throw them to death is indeed reflect the true nature of it and what kind of shining super power they are!

If India omit secular and democracy and change to Hindutva autocracy it would be ok but not the other way around.

We don't care what myanmar thinks ,these rohingyas wants to settle in balgladesh and we are helping them reach a better place.

Immigrants (Hindus) from bangladesh & pakistan too are not refugees ,they will be receiving citizenship under CAA (which is a specific law for them ).

We don't recognize UN refugee card ,since you guys do accept them in your country just welcome these islamic brothers of yours ,for us they are illegal immigrants who are creating nuisance in our country and deserve to be put in detention centers or thrown out.

Don't bother about our preamble/constitution ,it is for we the people of India not for any retarded pole vaulter.

 

[Black_cats]

We don't care what myanmar thinks ,these rohingyas wants to settle in balgladesh and we are helping them reach a better place.

Immigrants (Hindus) from bangladesh & pakistan too are not refugees ,they will be receiving citizenship under CAA (which is a specific law for them ).

We don't recognize UN refugee card ,since you guys do accept them in your country just welcome these islamic brothers of yours ,for us they are illegal immigrants who are creating nuisance in our country and deserve to be put in detention centers or thrown out.

Don't bother about our preamble/constitution ,it is for we the people of India not for any retarded pole vaulter.

CAA gave citizenship only to persecuted Hindus and refugees but no way to prove that and is discriminatory towards Muslims and against so called secular nature of India.

Rohingyas are living in refugee camp and have not done any issues. It’s only the radical Hindu organizations like BJP, RSS which is creating the propaganda.

Are you illiterate or what? Bangladesh has already accepted 1.5 million of them who came directly to Bangladesh but it can not take them from any other country as they are citizen of Myanmar but what they try to deny.

As I said before change constitution from secular democratic to hindutva autocratic and after that no one will have any problem.

 

[Fireurimagination]

Damn why would rohingya want to come to Hindu India, wouldn't they feel at home in muslim countries like Bangladesh and Pakistan? Bangladesh, Pakistan, Indonesia should accommodate their brethren in name of ummah

 

[Bilal9]

Whoever came directly from Myanmar Bangladesh accepted it. Now housing 1.5 million of them despite geographically small country.

However Bangladesh can not accept them from India when it is trying to expel them branding illegal migrant as they are not Bangladeshi citizen. It will give incentive to Myanmar that they are Bangladeshi saying them Bengali in case they are taken.

If India has nothing to do with refugees why it’s encouraging Hindus from Bangladesh, Pakistan to go there as refugees when none has any means to prove any persecution?

For so called worlds largest democracy acting like this to refugees who carry UN refugee card and who are world’s most persecuted population, using fear mongering tactics by saying will put them in detention center and will throw them to death is indeed reflect the true nature of it and what kind of shining super power they are!

If India omit secular and democracy and change to Hindutva autocracy it would be ok but not the other way around.

They act all high and mighty driving away refugees, and these people are themselves the largest bhikharee (beggar) nation in the globe and a source of the largest number of illegal migrants the world over. Even now H1B's in the US are crying to Biden to let their over-21 kids stay in the US who will be deported. Compare this to China whose citizens travel and tour the world and always return to China...

Sanghi Hypocrites !

Tech companies urge U.S. to let the kids of visa holders stay past the age of 21

Tech companies including Amazon, Google, Salesforce and Uber are urging the government to revise aging out policies for children of high-skilled visa holders.

www.cnbc.com

CAA gave citizenship only to persecuted Hindus and refugees but no way to prove that and is discriminatory towards Muslims and against so called secular nature of India.

Rohingyas are living in refugee camp and have not done any issues. It’s only the radical Hindu organizations like BJP, RSS which is creating the propaganda.

Are you illiterate or what? Bangladesh has already accepted 1.5 million of them who came directly to Bangladesh but it can not take them from any other country as they are citizen of Myanmar but what they try to deny.

As I said before change constitution from secular democratic to hindutva autocratic and after that no one will have any problem.

You are arguing with an eight pass idiot with zero clue on international law, ethics or morality....waste of time really.