What's new

In 2014, Ukraine withdrew from<Alma-Ata Protocol>. The Ukrainian war should belong to the Soviet civil war rather than the war of aggression.

MH.Yang

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 21, 2021
Messages
6,679
Reaction score
2
Country
China
Location
China
<Alma-Ata Protocol> is the legal basis for former Soviet Union member states to declare their separation from the Soviet Union and mutually confirm their territories.

In 2014, Ukraine withdrew. This means that Ukraine has abandoned the declaration of secession from the Soviet Union, and it remains a part of the Soviet Union. And the territorial agreement between it and Russia has also been voluntarily abandoned and invalidated by the Ukrainian govt.

In that case, the Ukrainian war has become a civil war among Soviet members.
 
<Alma-Ata Protocol> is the legal basis for former Soviet Union member states to declare their separation from the Soviet Union and mutually confirm their territories.

In 2014, Ukraine withdrew. This means that Ukraine has abandoned the declaration of secession from the Soviet Union, and it remains a part of the Soviet Union. And the territorial agreement between it and Russia has also been voluntarily abandoned and invalidated by the Ukrainian govt.

In that case, the Ukrainian war has become a civil war among Soviet members.
Are you for real? What next? Kosovo is just a part of Yugoslavia Civil war?

One major thing you are missing, there are NO MORE SOVIET UNION. How can you start a civil war with an entity no longer exist?

Dude, your posting quality went down the hill, not that it was great but I still respect you back in the days, it's almost all gone now......
 
<Alma-Ata Protocol> is the legal basis for former Soviet Union member states to declare their separation from the Soviet Union and mutually confirm their territories.

In 2014, Ukraine withdrew. This means that Ukraine has abandoned the declaration of secession from the Soviet Union, and it remains a part of the Soviet Union. And the territorial agreement between it and Russia has also been voluntarily abandoned and invalidated by the Ukrainian govt.

In that case, the Ukrainian war has become a civil war among Soviet members.
The Soviet Union no longer exists, so your argument is stupid.
 
Are you for real? What next? Kosovo is just a part of Yugoslavia Civil war?

One major thing you are missing, there are NO MORE SOVIET UNION. How can you start a civil war with an entity no longer exist?

Dude, your posting quality went down the hill, not that it was great but I still respect you back in the days, it's almost all gone now......

The Soviet Union no longer exists, so your argument is stupid.

Even with what he said, Ukraine never formally withdrew, so his point is mute.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom