Imran Khan rectified his statement to make Atif Mian as Finance Minister

[Patriots]

 

[Norwegian]

IK is a total idiot when it comes to his views on Qadianis. Was it OK if that prominent world known economist was a Hindu Pakistani or Christian Pakistani? Would he then accept him as his foreign minister?

 

[faisal6309]

Stupid politicians hating people for what they want to be and then we talk about Democracy in Pakistan. Shit!!!

 

[Norwegian]

Stupid politicians hating people for what they want to be and then we talk about Democracy in Pakistan. Shit!!!

I agree with IK on everything except his stupid and biased views regarding Qadianis.

 

[faisal6309]

I agree with IK on everything except his stupid and biased views regarding Qadianis.

I am not Qadiani. I don't have problem with Qadianis. I have Qadiani friends. They are all Pakistani citizens and that is what we should see. Such people should read about Abdul Salam Wikipedia page and his contribution for Pakistan. We should encourage them and not kick out of Pakistan. It will be bad for country. They are as much patriotic as us (so called real Muslims).

 

[mr42O]

What IK said is noting wrong.

Any one who does not believe in Prophet Muhammad (SAW) as last prophet is against basics of islam.


Most important ting is what he said at the end. EVERY ONE IS EQUAL IN ISLAMIC TEACHING. Does not matter what his believe is.

And plz remember its not as simple issue its very sensitive. @Norwegian I know few of ur friend in Norway still support Imran Khan.

 

[jericho]

Lol, this was reported about a week ago I think, don't tell me we are gonna have this discussion again. Well, IK only said he doesn't consider Qadianis as muslim, then he said that everyone is equal under the law, clearly he meant Qadianis too. I think that should tell that even if he doesn't think Qadianis are Muslim, he still wont discriminate them. I watched this video a few days ago, but if I remember correctly he didn't really say he wont let Atif Mian become his finance minister.

 

[Green Arrow]

Another U Turn

 

[Norwegian]

Any one who does not believe in Prophet Muhammad (SAW) as last prophet is against basics of islam.

It could be, still if someone considers himself Muslim, state or government has no business enforcing him to declare himself non-Muslim. Other Muslims may see Qadianis as heretics, non-Muslims but state has no say in this matter according to the basic principle of freedom of religion.

Most important ting is what he said at the end. EVERY ONE IS EQUAL IN ISLAMIC TEACHING. Does not matter what his believe is.

Qadianis and other religious minorities are treated unequally in Pakistani constitution. IK must remove these unjust paragraphs once he comes to power.

And plz remember its not as simple issue its very sensitive. @Norwegian I know few of ur friend in Norway still support Imran Khan.

I am not a supporter of Qadianism. I am for all religious minorities in Pakistan treated fairly and equally as we see in Norway where state do not interfere with people's religious affairs.

 

[khawaja07]

Those who are saying that believing in the Muhammad S.A.W(PBUH) as the Last Prophet of ALLAH is not necessary to be a Muslim are out of their damn minds and need to read the Quran. IK is correct here whether you like it or not.

 

[Norwegian]

Those who are saying that believing in the Muhammad S.A.W(PBUH) as the Last Prophet of ALLAH is not necessary to be a Muslim are out of their damn minds and need to read the Quran. IK is correct here whether you like it or not.

Its not the question of belief but enforcement. There are some Sunni sects that do not believe other Shiite sects to be Muslim. Also there are some Shiite sects that accuse Sunnis for apostasy. Takfiris of ISIS follow similar ideology where they brand all those who do not follow their strict Wahhabi form of Islam for being Kuffars. Kharijites in Islam also considered other mainstream Muslims for abandoning "true" teachings Islam and thus massacred many of them in the past for "apostasy":
Takfir - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

So you can see that its a very dangerous trend among Muslims where they label other dissimilar and unorthodox sects of Islam for being non-Muslims. In turn, they themselves are regarded as apostates by the same sect. Intolerance in Islam is very common practice.

 

[Hiptullha]

Qadianis and other religious minorities are treated unequally in Pakistani constitution. IK must remove these unjust paragraphs once he comes to power

Its not the question of belief but enforcement. There are some Sunni sects that do not believe other Shiite sects to be Muslim. Also there are some Shiite sects that accuse Sunnis for apostasy. Takfiris of ISIS follow similar ideology where they brand all those who do not follow their strict Wahhabi form of Islam for being Kuffars. Kharijites in Islam also considered other mainstream Muslims for abandoning "true" teachings Islam and thus massacred many of them in the past for "apostasy":
Takfir - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

So you can see that its a very dangerous trend among Muslims where they label other dissimilar and unorthodox sects of Islam for being non-Muslims. In turn, they themselves are regarded as apostates by the same sect. Intolerance in Islam is very common practice.

I understand what you are saying and I agree to some extent.
The constitution should not be dealing with who is Muslim or not and neither should the state be involved in trying to persecute Ahmedis. But at the end of the day, just like how Ahmedis consider other sects non-Muslims, I think it is the consensus of the entire community that they are not Muslim either. Denying it is impossible.

 

[Norwegian]

But at the end of the day, just like how Ahmedis consider other sects non-Muslims, I think it is the consensus of the entire community that they are not Muslim either. Denying it is impossible.

Qadianis may consider other Muslim sects non-Muslims, same goes for other sects claiming Qadianis are not Muslim. But state has no business taking the side of those Muslim sects who seek to penalize Qadianis for following their faith as Islam.

 

[khalidahmad]

1974 was year when we lost the spirit of the creation of Pakistan. That should be remembered as the blackest year in the history of Pakistan. Pakistan was never created for this reason, that we start hating each other. Ahmadis contributed more towards the creation of Pakistan followed by Shias than any other sect. Time to define Muslim was before the creation of Pakistan so that Ahmadis had known that once they Vote for Pakistan they would be declared NON-MUSLIMS. No, When we needed their money, Vote & leaders they were Muslims. Many Maulvies went to Qaid to expel Ahmadis from Muslim League but he refused. He new very well that for Political Unity of Muslims it will be suicidal. But unfortunately that suicidal decision was made by our Nation Assembly under Saudi pressure. We all know very well that Saudis not go to Bathroom with the permission of USA. Pakistan Nation Assembly foolishly played the game of West that let Muslims keep on Fighting each other. Ahmadis were the easiest target so we picked on them. Ahmadis were the most Educated Community of Pakistan & Pakistan had benefitted a lot from them. But most this Community is contributing towards the progress of their host countries where we forced them to seek refuge. Who lost? PAKISTAN.

1974 was year when we lost the spirit of the creation of Pakistan. That should be remembered as the blackest year in the history of Pakistan. Pakistan was never created for this reason, that we start hating each other. Ahmadis contributed more towards the creation of Pakistan followed by Shias than any other sect. Time to define Muslim was before the creation of Pakistan so that Ahmadis had known that once they Vote for Pakistan they would be declared NON-MUSLIMS. No, When we needed their money, Vote & leaders they were Muslims. Many Maulvies went to Qaid to expel Ahmadis from Muslim League but he refused. He new very well that for Political Unity of Muslims it will be suicidal. But unfortunately that suicidal decision was made by our Nation Assembly under Saudi pressure. We all know very well that Saudis do not go to Bathroom without the permission of USA. Pakistan Nation Assembly foolishly played the game of the West. West wants Muslims to keep on Fighting each other. Ahmadis were the easiest target so we picked on them. Ahmadis were the most Educated Community of Pakistan & Pakistan could have benefitted a lot from them. But now most of this Community is contributing towards the progress of their host countries where they we forced them to seek refuge. Who lost? PAKISTAN.

Source: https://defence.pk/threads/imran-khan-rectified-his-statement-to-make-atif-mian-as-finance-minister.339197/#ixzz3HT5qEMgP