What's new

Idle power plants paid Tk 90b: study Only 43pc output used

Black_cats

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
-5
Idle power plants paid Tk 90b: study
Only 43pc output used
Emran Hossain | Published: 00:05, May 19,2020

https://www.newagebd.net/article/106747/idle-power-plants-paid-tk-90b-study

A new study released on Monday by the US-based Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis said that Bangladesh paid idle power plants Tk 90 billion in 2018–19 for it could use only 43 per cent of the generation capacity.

The economic downturn due to the COVID-19 crisis will cause a fall in the power demand pushing the already subsidised state-owned Power Development Board winto even deeper financial crisis, said the study.

‘Based on our own forecast of power demand growth, which takes the economic impact of COVID-19 into account, we calculate that Bangladesh is on course to have capacity that can generate 58% more power than the nation needs by 2030,’ said a press release quoting Simon Nicholas of IEEFA, the lead author of the study report.

The report published online misforecasts from Bangladesh’s power sector master plan that aimed at developing power capacity-based expensive fuels such as imported coal and LNG responsible for throwing the country into such a situation.

The state minister for power, energy and mineral resources Nasrul Hamid said that Bangladesh’s generation capacity was greater than required due to technical reasons.

‘The power demand changes cosiderably because of high seasonal variation in the country,’ said Nasrul.

He said that it is normal to have the capacity to generate 22,000 MW when the demand is about 12,000 MW.

He also said that Bangladesh could not afford to switch to renewable energy because of establishment costs and lack of available land needed for running solar power plants.

The report said that Indonesia followed a similar power sector development plan and saw a 75 per cent increase in subsidy that rose to $5 billion in 2018.

The IEEFA predicted that the Indonesian government’s subsidy would likely rise to $7.2 billion next year.

The study said that if Bangladesh continued pursuing the misleading power sector development plan with the establishment of all the planned coal-based power plants the resulting overcapacity would require the government and the consumers spend more on power.

The study said that a part of the impending power sector disorder already got manifested in the 1,320 MW Payra Power Plant, which is set to count Tk 160 crore a month as capacity payment for half its capacity not used.

The ideal reserve power margin is 10 to 20 per cent but the power sector master plan of Bangladesh has decided to keep it at 25 per cent, the study added.

Still, the master plan said, the reserve power margin would reach as high as 69 per cent in 2020, noted the study.

The study said that Bangladesh failed to achieve the power growth as forecasted in the power sector master plan and the coronavirus crisis only worsened the situation by slowing down the economic growth.

The state-owned power company of Indonesia, PLN, already predicted a 15 per cent fall in its annual revenue income because of the coronavirus crisis while Bangladesh is also faced with revenue crisis, said the study.

The IEEFA study said that in 2015–16 the power sector subsidy stood at $28 billion in Bangladesh and it kept rising ever since.

The PDB estimated that it would lose Tk 90 billion in 2020–21. Bangladesh increased power tariff eight times in last decade.

The IEEFA said that the coronavirus crisis slowing down the construction of coal-based power plants offered Bangladesh an opportunity to look back at its power policy and re-evaluate it.

It said that overcapacity became a problem in countries such as Pakistan, India, Indonesia and Egypt where the governments were showing growing interest in clean energy.

‘The COVID-19 induced delay to coal power projects gives Bangladesh an opportunity to reset energy development policy and redirect resources to support economic fundamentals and energy price stability to enable the realization of ‘Vision 2041’, said the study.
 
When I Read Economic News On Bangladesh Why Do I Feel They Are Exact Copy Of Economic Issues In Pakistan?????
It is because BD is following the misguided rules set in Pakistan time. Both countries lack good planners. As a result, without first reviewing the demand for power, the Hasina govt is building more and more power stations instead of supplying much of this fund to the private sector to build industries.

Consumption of power by industries could make the power sector economically viable. But, Hasina Bibi thinks our rich population will purchase all the power when in reality they have little extra income to pay the bills. I was personally waiting for many FDIs that has not so far materialized.

However, I must tell you, President Ayub Khan was a genius for national development. He planned ahead of time and did not put the cart in front of the horses. This is what both countries do always. But, I personally believe IK will do better. At least, he is not a thief. In our case, the same will happen even if Hasina is replaced.

Situation will worsen when Rooppur nuclear power station starts operating. More power but less consumption. Less production of wealth but much repayment for building many Prestige Projects by borrowing.
 
Last edited:
Look at who own those power plants. Most of them are BAL politicians. So they will keep milking it. BD economy already in deep trouble for years of mismanagement and inflated GDP.

Power consumption so low only proves BAL lying about GDP. There is no way your consumption this low and have so high economic growth.
 
When I Read Economic News On Bangladesh Why Do I Feel They Are Exact Copy Of Economic Issues In Pakistan?????

Because they are. We have got scums of leaders and bureaucrats from the same roots. Outcome is also same.
 
Look at who own those power plants. Most of them are BAL politicians. So they will keep milking it. BD economy already in deep trouble for years of mismanagement and inflated GDP.

Power consumption so low only proves BAL lying about GDP. There is no way your consumption this low and have so high economic growth.
Power consumption and GDP growth is incompatible in BD that may prove your point. However, BAL investors in power stations will not suffer due to power glut. Only the Govt owned plants will be suffering. I wonder how BD will pay back all the loan money to build Prestige Power Stations when power will not be sold.

Our govt, because of dollars earned by our hardworking women folk, forgot the proverb, "Cut your coat according to your cloth".
 
Power consumption and GDP growth is incompatible in BD that may prove your point. However, BAL investors in power stations will not suffer due to power glut. Only the Govt owned plants will be suffering. I wonder how BD will pay back all the loan money to build Prestige Power Stations when power will not be sold.

Our govt, because of dollars earned by our hardworking women folk, forgot the proverb, "Cut your coat according to your cloth".
Those days are over. Wait and see. Sending low value garments and low skilled labor to middle east can take you only that far.

Bd is one of the most exposed economy because we didnt diversity and carry out the reforms.

FDI in last fiscal year dropped by 20 percent.

There are some BAL mofo supporters here still mention about how hasina is doing so great bla bla 8 percent growth. Reality is just inflated GDP.

These white elephant projects will cost us billions in subsidies not to mention you also have to pay back for example 12 billion for that nuclear power plant alone.
 
I wonder how BD will pay back all the loan money to build Prestige Power Stations when power will not be sold.

You really want to know how? It's not pretty. It will involve external defaults if it gets bad enough. The over-leveraging of these loans (BAL govt is addicted to) already collapsed a huge deal of private market cap (well past exchange rate movement) in 2019 thanks to totally mismatched and mis-prioritized liquidity.

It is phase 1 stuff, somewhat limited to corporates/enterprises for now (phase 0 was the stagnant forex level which should have been trigger warning already given easy pie of 130 billion chinese RMG to transfer into). Its limited there (for now) simply because these folks dont have a wide enough array of mafia types protecting them and their balance sheets from the tax bureaucrat.

Phase 2 if no reforms and course correction is done is gonna metastasize to banking and public sector. You see outsiders dont accept repayments in Taka, they want the cold hard USD....the inflation simply cannot be used like BAL does for GDP tabulation.

How much buffer is available in the end for phase 2?:

https://bb.org.bd/pub/weekly/staffair/state_affairs.php?prId=9133#

Apparently about 21 billion worth. For economy claimed to be 300 billion level by BAL and harped on by BAL-brat team.

Where and who are the peers with this kind of ratio at different periods of time?...and what kind of financial tumult have they gotten themselves (inevitably by stasis) into?

All interesting questions if there was airing out of these questions early and often by a diverse enough BD intelligentsia with institutions and something much more than 5% of govt opposition level to query these hard questions effectively (and openly with as much sunlight as possible) to BD's CAG and NBR and BBS and ultimately the admin BAL too.

But instead you have what you have.

At least few more canary in coalmines are joining this subforum now. I wish them well.
 
You really want to know how? It's not pretty. It will involve external defaults if it gets bad enough. The over-leveraging of these loans (BAL govt is addicted to) already collapsed a huge deal of private market cap (well past exchange rate movement) in 2019 thanks to totally mismatched and mis-prioritized liquidity.

It is phase 1 stuff, somewhat limited to corporates/enterprises for now (phase 0 was the stagnant forex level which should have been trigger warning already given easy pie of 130 billion chinese RMG to transfer into). Its limited there (for now) simply because these folks dont have a wide enough array of mafia types protecting them and their balance sheets from the tax bureaucrat.

Phase 2 if no reforms and course correction is done is gonna metastasize to banking and public sector. You see outsiders dont accept repayments in Taka, they want the cold hard USD....the inflation simply cannot be used like BAL does for GDP tabulation.

How much buffer is available in the end for phase 2?:

https://bb.org.bd/pub/weekly/staffair/state_affairs.php?prId=9133#

Apparently about 21 billion worth. For economy claimed to be 300 billion level by BAL and harped on by BAL-brat team.

Where and who are the peers with this kind of ratio at different periods of time?...and what kind of financial tumult have they gotten themselves (inevitably by stasis) into?

All interesting questions if there was airing out of these questions early and often by a diverse enough BD intelligentsia with institutions and something much more than 5% of govt opposition level to query these hard questions effectively (and openly with as much sunlight as possible) to BD's CAG and NBR and BBS and ultimately the admin BAL too.

But instead you have what you have.

At least few more canary in coalmines are joining this subforum now. I wish them well.
Bottom line we are over leveraged?

Only if our stock market wasn't horse shit...we could have different story to raise capital and develop bond market. But BAL first thing they did is destroyed capital market back in 2010.
 
Bottom line we are over leveraged?

Only if our stock market wasn't horse shit...we could have different story to raise capital and develop bond market. But BAL first thing they did is destroyed capital market back in 2010.

They're greedy man (but its a polarised fear driven kind of greed I think, speaking at length to my best BD friend)...more than anything I seen regionally.

They want every single bit of power for themselves, every bit of control they can get. They hold every dove close to chest not letting it fly man....so maybe one day theres a flock of doves for all to enjoy watching.

Because letting that happen means loss of control...and you need to trust in your people (they will sometimes fail, and a lot, but some will also succeed and succeed big...but they wont owe you 100% for something because you held them close 100%). They are afraid of it...I have seen it all over the world, its just extra bad and cocooned in BD...that too in places it really shouldnt be...

It works for sometime, but ultimately the dove dies if you hold it this hard. But they simply can keep moving on and on to next one for very long time and repeat process....because there is so much in between them and accountability....and even more between that and say revolution.

It very easy to point at the "baddie" when you have gora british...or then a punjabi mil-establishment...or over-bearing dada....but what you got when its just you in the end?

There is a certain root somewhat unique psyche driving this (for East Bengal elite being this way) for likely a very long time but thats a much longer story (from my point of view).
 
They're greedy man (but its a polarised fear driven kind of greed I think, speaking at length to my best BD friend)...more than anything I seen regionally.

They want every single bit of power for themselves, every bit of control they can get. They hold every dove close to chest not letting it fly man....so maybe one day theres a flock of doves for all to enjoy watching.

Because letting that happen means loss of control...and you need to trust in your people (they will sometimes fail, and a lot, but some will also succeed and succeed big...but they wont owe you 100% for something because you held them close 100%). They are afraid of it...I have seen it all over the world, its just extra bad and cocooned in BD...that too in places it really shouldnt be...

It works for sometime, but ultimately the dove dies if you hold it this hard. But they simply can keep moving on and on to next one for very long time and repeat process....because there is so much in between them and accountability....and even more between that and say revolution.

It very easy to point at the "baddie" when you have gora british...or then a punjabi mil-establishment...or over-bearing dada....but what you got when its just you in the end?

There is a certain root somewhat unique psyche driving this (for East Bengal elite being this way) for likely a very long time but thats a much longer story (from my point of view).
Funny thing is dhaka stock exchange is only one in the world still closed i think.

BAL way to stop free fall of capital market ha ha. Just shut it. Problem solved.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom