IDEAS INVITED for a Drone Neutralization System

[MastanKhan]

And for that we need to change our air warfare doctrine which was based on limited defense procurement. I don't know from which prospects the set up their mind that we can't have the limited offensive capability.

Hi,

That happened when they were given total control of procurement. The air chief's after the 80's were mostly criminally negligent.

 

[Maj.Osmani]

Hi,

That happened when they were given total control of procurement. The air chief's after the 80's were mostly criminally negligent.

First part you are absolutely correct there should be some committee of all three armed forces which they should draw plans and policies and according to mutually understand findings they recommends defense procurement. Our Defense related procurements should always based on our armed forces doctrine / needs but our air force is in love with F-16.

Further on above after atomic tests US put sanctions on Pakistan and our capable Chiefs waited for a decade to decide anything in favor of air force, we should at that time move to China.

 

[sady]

What your saying now totally opposite what you have posted above. Anyways glad to know that you are aware of our armed forces capabilities.


And for that we need to change our air warfare doctrine which was based on limited defense procurement. I don't know from which prospects the set up their mind that we can't have the limited offensive capability.

You have been a day on PDF and you are assuming things already. Get to know people first.

 

[Maj.Osmani]

You have been a day on PDF and you are assuming things already. Get to know people first.

But i am on earth since 1960 no need much time to assume what i find. cheers

 

[sady]

But i have on earth since 1960 no need much time to assume what i find. cheers

mere age does not bring wisdom. not that I think of myself as wise. Anyhow this is meaningless spat. we are on the same side. cheers

 

[That Guy]

Hi,

2 sqdrn's of J10C's and 2 Sqdrn's of JH7B's would bring a change in attitude for many---.

Neither of which I would recommend Pakistan go for. There is no point in going for more fighters in the same class and generation of F-16, just save the money and go for a better option.

 

[Thorough Pro]

GPS spoofing, don't shoot them land them like Iran did

 

[MastanKhan]

Neither of which I would recommend Pakistan go for. There is no point in going for more fighters in the same class and generation of F-16, just save the money and go for a better option.

Sir,

You should give out a reason why---WITH NUMBERS----.

You are around 50---60 aircraft short in the F16 category---. Your JF17 production is not high enough to fill in the hole created by this fiasco----. The JF17's are only filling in their own position.

Yet you need 2 sqdrn's of top tier aircraft other than the full number of the F16's---.

So---if you are 50---60 F16's short---how are you going to cover that OPEN FLANK.

Plus---your relationship with the U S is teetering on an edge---what happened a couple of days ago---is nothing to build up any confidence.

So---if Karachi university needs 150 buses that can carry 100 students in each---but it has only 80 of them and the Daewoo company won't sell anymore---okay.

You are already building mann buses---that can carry 70 students each and your need is 200---but you only have 72 of them---but you are temporarily using buses than can carry 40 students each bus----but your production is in line to meet your requirements.

You also need some high end luxury buses---for your special occasions----.

Your problem now is that you are going to be short 70 buses that can carry 100 students each.

So---just because you are having problems with acquiring the F16's---does not mean that your need for a number of 140--150 F16's has gone with away with the disappearing aircraft.

 

[Khafee]

Hi,

2 sqdrn's of J10C's and 2 Sqdrn's of JH7B's would bring a change in attitude for many---.

Pakistan has a very unique relationship, they don't necessarily need to "Buy", they can also "Lease" them.

 

[Genghis khan1]

I would like to invite IDEAS of CONCEPT of development of a DRONE NEUTRALIZATION SYSTEM (DNS). A few important things to keep in mind before you share your ideas.

1. The system should have a good & quick detection capability to detect medium to large sized drones carrying weapons.

2. The system should use low weight but high speed drone neutralization techniques.

3. The missiles may be ground based or mobile.

Lets us have your ideas people!

Drones are the easiest thing to bring down. Just give EME students some funds and they can make one of these.

 

[MastanKhan]

Pakistan has a very unique relationship, they don't necessarily need to "Buy", they can also "Lease" them.

Hi,

I would like your input on my comments on the gripen NG.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

My solution is track where the drone lands and then fire a Nuclear armed missile on that base and destroy it

Use the Drone terror mentality on its user like it is used to Terrorize citizens in Pakistani border


Attack the base from where the drone flies and take out any communication towers

 

[graphican]

TTP used to hit US drones with their vintage anti-aircraft guns. It happened twice within a week. I do not think Pakistan lacks technology to detect or neutralize them, but its a matter of decision.

 

[_NOBODY_]

Sir,

You should give out a reason why---WITH NUMBERS----.

You are around 50---60 aircraft short in the F16 category---. Your JF17 production is not high enough to fill in the hole created by this fiasco----. The JF17's are only filling in their own position.

Yet you need 2 sqdrn's of top tier aircraft other than the full number of the F16's---.

So---if you are 50---60 F16's short---how are you going to cover that OPEN FLANK.

Plus---your relationship with the U S is teetering on an edge---what happened a couple of days ago---is nothing to build up any confidence.

So---if Karachi university needs 150 buses that can carry 100 students in each---but it has only 80 of them and the Daewoo company won't sell anymore---okay.

You are already building mann buses---that can carry 70 students each and your need is 200---but you only have 72 of them---but you are temporarily using buses than can carry 40 students each bus----but your production is in line to meet your requirements.

You also need some high end luxury buses---for your special occasions----.

Your problem now is that you are going to be short 70 buses that can carry 100 students each.

So---just because you are having problems with acquiring the F16's---does not mean that your need for a number of 140--150 F16's has gone with away with the disappearing aircraft.

Su-35's air superiority capabilities are greater than J-10 and it also allows deeper penetration into enemy's territory just like JH-7. China operates both Flankers and JH-7 but we don't have the same luxuriousness as China so we need a fighter which gives us deeper penetration into enemy's territory while maintaining outstanding air superiority.

 

[That Guy]

Sir,

You should give out a reason why---WITH NUMBERS----.

You are around 50---60 aircraft short in the F16 category---. Your JF17 production is not high enough to fill in the hole created by this fiasco----. The JF17's are only filling in their own position.

Yet you need 2 sqdrn's of top tier aircraft other than the full number of the F16's---.

So---if you are 50---60 F16's short---how are you going to cover that OPEN FLANK.

Plus---your relationship with the U S is teetering on an edge---what happened a couple of days ago---is nothing to build up any confidence.

So---if Karachi university needs 150 buses that can carry 100 students in each---but it has only 80 of them and the Daewoo company won't sell anymore---okay.

You are already building mann buses---that can carry 70 students each and your need is 200---but you only have 72 of them---but you are temporarily using buses than can carry 40 students each bus----but your production is in line to meet your requirements.

You also need some high end luxury buses---for your special occasions----.

Your problem now is that you are going to be short 70 buses that can carry 100 students each.

So---just because you are having problems with acquiring the F16's---does not mean that your need for a number of 140--150 F16's has gone with away with the disappearing aircraft.

We've had this exact conversation before, no point in repeating myself, you know my stance.