IAF strikes Balakot. Wins and Wins

[VCheng]

It most certainly would have especially in light of Pakistan's tight embrace of China and in terms of american accusations against Pakistan for supportung terrorists in afghanistan.

You may think so, o course.

 

[Champion_Usmani]

@Irfan Baloch I am asking a question all day.

Alright it took some time for PAF CAP to reach LOC, but we have Sams at LOC, that can target enemy aircrafts 40 to 50 KMs inside their own territory, so why didn't we used them???

IAF aircrafts were for 4 minutes inside our air space, why didn't we used SAMs. OK once they (Sam System) lock the target aircraft, they themselves can be targeted by anti radiation missiles, but then so be it, they are there for deterrence, so use them.

Your thoughts?

 

[Solomon2]

IF the indians DID what they claimed to have done, footage would have MOST definitely been released by now.

I doubt nations will release the footage they've released themselves but commercial satellite services will for a price. I would guess these will be in the news tomorrow.

 

[aliyusuf]

ISPR guy says Indians should have waited for 21 minute was he going to snap attack Indian Mirages with his Iphone he was charging ?
why Indian jets should wait


View attachment 542129View attachment 542129

please stay with me

IAF was given a task to do a symbolic strike deep inside Pakistan and it succeeded
dont hate me for saying this but its acceptable outcome for both

Indians can claim revenge. Modi can claim election victory
and Pakistanis can claim that nothing was targeted and Indians fled and all

but the fact is.. they managed to go deep inside Pakistan and escaped without trouble
and there is no other way to look at it so credit IAF

here are two sides of me as Indian and Pakistani


as a Pakistani
75% of me wants to believe the claim that incursion didnt achieve its goal and the IAF jets had to revert back once they saw the incoming intercept.
25% of me thinks. No, they achieved their mission because the mission as to make a mark inside Pakistan and leave unopposed. irrespective of bombs/ fuelpods falling on target or on the fields.

as an Indian
75% of me wants to believe that IAF claim is correct. they really killed over 300 terrorists. IAF is awesome and India has achieved air superiority and set the precedence for future air domination in the sub continent (yes including against China too)
25% of me still wonders what if Pakistanis are correct. the incursion was just symbolic for Modi's election sake and Indian public morale and IAF just retreated as planned on the first sign of PAF jets




Now over to you guys please discussion

without insulting each other

remember all of you are normal, peace loving people with parents and kids and friends.. none of you or other you argue with are involved in any atrocity inside India or Pakistan. so keeping that in mind.

debate and fire away your opinions

Apart from the statement deep inside Pakistan, I fully agree with your assessment. Great post sir.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

I doubt nations will release the footage they've released themselves but commercial satellite services will for a price. I would guess these will be in the news tomorrow.

A bit like the indian surgical strikes 1.0...........are we to believe the same people who claimed to have been using the internet 5,000 years ago.......:

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/04/india-ancient-internet/558725/

 

[YeBeWarned]

I am sorry to say , but lots of senior members here are acting like Chickens .. Indian media is literally abusing Pakistan , its Ideology , its Founding Fathers, and last night they intrude and yet our Media and some Senior members are asking for not escalating situation . If Army didn't response this means Army only Care about their own losses not the civilians , if any one of those bombs dropped on any house or farm, people would have been blown to bits, if that is not enough for Pakistan Army to respond than I am sorry to say , it remind of a Dialog from Indian Movie " Pakistan ne India se larne ke liye Hijroon ki fauj banai hai " .

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

Can this incursion change the facts on the ground - 700K IA troops are bogged down by <1K Mujahidin inside the IOK?????

I am sorry to say , but lots of senior members here are acting like Chickens .. Indian media is literally abusing Pakistan , its Ideology , its Founding Fathers, and last night they intrude and yet our Media and some Senior members are asking for not escalating situation . If Army didn't response this means Army only Care about their own losses not the civilians , if any one of those bombs dropped on any house or farm, people would have been blown to bits, if that is not enough for Pakistan Army to respond than I am sorry to say , it remind of a Dialog from Indian Movie " Pakistan ne India se larne ke liye Hijroon ki fauj banai hai " .

Arkadashim!!! He who stands up with anger sits down with a loss!!!! India is your next door neighbor, she' not moving anywhere else soon....

 

[Army research]

ISPR guy says Indians should have waited for 21 minute was he going to snap attack Indian Mirages with his Iphone he was charging ?
why Indian jets should wait


View attachment 542129View attachment 542129

please stay with me

IAF was given a task to do a symbolic strike deep inside Pakistan and it succeeded
dont hate me for saying this but its acceptable outcome for both

Indians can claim revenge. Modi can claim election victory
and Pakistanis can claim that nothing was targeted and Indians fled and all

but the fact is.. they managed to go deep inside Pakistan and escaped without trouble
and there is no other way to look at it so credit IAF

here are two sides of me as Indian and Pakistani


as a Pakistani
75% of me wants to believe the claim that incursion didnt achieve its goal and the IAF jets had to revert back once they saw the incoming intercept.
25% of me thinks. No, they achieved their mission because the mission as to make a mark inside Pakistan and leave unopposed. irrespective of bombs/ fuelpods falling on target or on the fields.

as an Indian
75% of me wants to believe that IAF claim is correct. they really killed over 300 terrorists. IAF is awesome and India has achieved air superiority and set the precedence for future air domination in the sub continent (yes including against China too)
25% of me still wonders what if Pakistanis are correct. the incursion was just symbolic for Modi's election sake and Indian public morale and IAF just retreated as planned on the first sign of PAF jets




Now over to you guys please discussion

without insulting each other

remember all of you are normal, peace loving people with parents and kids and friends.. none of you or other you argue with are involved in any atrocity inside India or Pakistan. so keeping that in mind.

debate and fire away your opinions

Spot on sir , spot on

 

[Irfan Baloch]

@Irfan Baloch I am asking a question all day.

Alright it took some time for PAF CAP to reach LOC, but we have Sams at LOC, that can target enemy aircrafts 40 to 50 KMs inside their own territory, so why didn't we used them???

IAF aircrafts were for 4 minutes inside our air space, why didn't we used SAMs. OK once they (Sam System) lock the target aircraft, they themselves can be targeted by anti radiation missiles, but then so be it, they are there for deterrence, so use them.

Your thoughts?

valid question brother
there are layered defenses and early warnings. not sure why they chose not to intercept them inside. had the debis fallen inside Pakistan it would have been a justified kill

 

[Wrath]

I don’t believe 300 dead. There is no official confirmation either side

Yes . No confirmation . What's your ethnicity. You seem a sensible person

 

[hussain0216]

I don’t believe 300 dead. There is no official confirmation either side

Its not about confirmation

Its about idiot indian public, throw them a bone then watch them go crazy

 

[VCheng]

valid question brother
there are layered defenses and early warnings. not sure why they chose not to intercept them inside. had the debis fallen inside Pakistan it would have been a justified kill

It depends on what was detected and what was conveyed to and from the decision makers.

 

[ziaulislam]

Its not about if people died or not its the fact they penetrated your airspace and dropped whatever projectile on your land and left without being challenged. That is the issue why weren't they challenged in the hottest border on earth?

So should we do this too. Because it dead easy no side can prevent this

@Irfan Baloch I am asking a question all day.

Alright it took some time for PAF CAP to reach LOC, but we have Sams at LOC, that can target enemy aircrafts 40 to 50 KMs inside their own territory, so why didn't we used them???

IAF aircrafts were for 4 minutes inside our air space, why didn't we used SAMs. OK once they (Sam System) lock the target aircraft, they themselves can be targeted by anti radiation missiles, but then so be it, they are there for deterrence, so use them.

Your thoughts?

I doubt we have 70+ km SAMs

 

[RPK]

Its not about confirmation

Its about idiot indian public, throw them a bone then watch them go crazy

Goi never confirmed or denied 300 dead on air strike. I don’t speculate

 

[ziaulislam]

But India media is cooled down and happy and now wants to talk peace very weird...are appreciating Pakistan calm response ..

Redline were violated more severely when we allowed rampant drone attacks