I WONT SAY BHARAT MATA KI JAY A MUSLIM GIRL’S MESSAGE TO HINDU NATIONALISTS

[INDIAPOSITIVE]

I WONT SAY BHARAT MATA KI JAY A MUSLIM GIRL’S MESSAGE TO HINDU NATIONALISTS March 15, 2016 Amina Baig My name is Amina Baig a second year BBA student and I will not say Bharat mata ki jay or Vande mataram, it is totally my choice and I wish not to utter those words. No where in the constitution it is written that you have to say Bharat mata ki jay or sing vande mataram to be Indian. It is just the Hindutva version of India which they want to force down our throats and if anyone dares to defy it then you are a so called anti-nationalist. It has become a yardstick to prove your patriotism especially if you are a Muslim. Moreover India is no Hindu country, in fact there is no Hindu country in the universe to the grief of Hindu nationalists even Nepal is no longer a Hindu country. So if India is not a Hindu country then why a Hindu representation of Mother India i.e; Bharat Mata a fictional goddess who isn’t even there in any Hindu scripture. So if India is not a Hindu country then all the more reason not to say Bharat mata ki jay which is a hindutva representation of India. The hindu symbol of India that is bharat mata should be abolished in this country and songs like vande mataram are no longer needed in free India, in fact they are often used as a tool to target the Muslim minority. From one of the previous article that I came across on this site and all words below fit very well here and I quote “Why is India a mother, why is Bharat a Mata ? This imagery of the nation entrap women into pinjras where we are reduced to biological reproducers of its members (sons) limited to mothers, wives, sisters in need of protection and idolized into figures whose bravery is realized through self-sacrifice and judged trough the prism of their rules and morals. An autonomous woman is one who thinks, who questions, who resists. Such women defy the masculine and patriarchal script of nationalism produced by upper-caste hindu men that has been premised on silencing of women’s voices and entrapping them in a swirl of pinjras of domesticity and alienation.” I support JNU and Umar Khalid call me anti-national – Indian Feminist

Read more at:http://indianfeminists.com/i-wont-say-bharat-mata-ki-jay-a-muslim-girls-message-to-hindu-nationalists/

 

[Fireurimagination]

She can say Bharat Ammi ki Jai Jokes aside I believe these Arab ascendants can use 'Jai Hind' or they have problem with that too?

 

[Abba_Dabba_Jabba]

If this pathetic girl doesn't want to chant this words, no problem. But don't bring your views in public, otherwise be ready to face the other side of the people as well. If you have right to enjoy freedom of speech then others too have it. Such statements from muslims should stop because it provokes the Hindu extremists to take action against it and the cycle goes on and on.

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

If this pathetic girl doesn't want to chant this words, no problem. But don't bring your views in public, otherwise be ready to face the other side of the people as well. If you have right to enjoy freedom of speech then others too have it. Such statements from muslims should stop because it provokes the Hindu extremists to take action against it and the cycle goes on and on.

No justification for extremism.

Lets leave it to her choice.

The only issue i have with ppl of this mentality is That they always talk about fundamental rights but never about fundamental duties.

 

[Abba_Dabba_Jabba]

This is the problem with many Sickulars, Congi and Lefties. All of a sudden from the last 2 years they think they are not enjoying their freedom of speech, whereas if we see then during last 6 months our PM was called "coward and psycopath", people mocked him, Smriti was called "tunch" maal, JNU students raising anti-national slogans, etc etc. And even after all this, this pathetic people from second majority community in the country are crying about freedom of speech.

 

[Baby-5]

Perhaps you should chant Hindustan Zindabad, and Jai Hind. Further IndianFeminist page should concentrate more on Burqas, thrice talaqs, Polygamy etc etc.
PS just like fundamental rights, Fundamental duties too should be enforceable by law.

 

[ranjeet]

Indianfeminists fot com? This fascist website should be banned and all members must be sent to jail and made to work in the mess there.

 

[B+ Dracula]

Better for Everyone is bury the hatchet here and stop building castles in thin Air
.
Same statmemnt also comes from "Asad ud din Owaisi",.....We have some religious problem for saying these words, we never say them (as muslim) in Pakistan
.
There are Some doubtful question that can causelessly become Bone of Contention with no Apparent reason..(Baat ki Khaal utarna)
a)
Why Muslims wont say "Jai Mata Bharat"
b)
Muslims of India choose which side in case of war with Pakistan
c)
Shias of Pakistan choose which side in case of war with Iran
=
I mean what was the need to ask such useless question in first place
.
as mundane they seem to be. ...f someone Question my Patriotism by saying....Q: you love Pakistan??? ....i will definately reply him back by saying "NO"..........Are you my Uncle or Chacha to ask such petty jokes then expect truthful reply

 

[TheNoob]

Thats stupid.
It only means hail our motherland in hindi.
How is it any different than Hindustan Zindabad?

People these days.....

 

[RAMPAGE]

No justification for extremism.

Lets leave it to her choice.

Exactly. Indian Muslims should use Jai Hind instead.

 

[trident2010]

She can say or don't say what she wants to until she is a good citizen of India and working towards nation building. Nothing else matters.

 

[The Sword Of Allah]

If this pathetic girl doesn't want to chant this words, no problem. But don't bring your views in public, otherwise be ready to face the other side of the people as well. If you have right to enjoy freedom of speech then others too have it. Such statements from muslims should stop because it provokes the Hindu extremists to take action against it and the cycle goes on and on.

See this is the problem one mistake and the whole religion or nation is blamed the problem you see is not islam or hinduism it is the people they dont have any good morals i mean every religion teaches of good morals but no they take the chunk out they think suits them and leaves the rest alone until you fix yourself don't talk about others
By the way my message to you was that there should be peace and try discovering what islam really is it is a great religion but some people make it sound bad as they do everything that is prohibited in there religion and don't care about it .
So basically look over islam and you will never say something bad about it but i can accept if you say that SOME people who call themselves muslims are not worthy to be called muslims
thanks

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

Exactly. Indian Muslims should use Jai Hind instead.

Why mention the religion at all ?

Say as a citizen of a free and democratic country i prefer to say Jai Hind.

If u say it on the lines of religion dont cry when u face isolation on other issues

Give and take theory works everywhere, Mama Ji

 

[RAMPAGE]

Why mention the religion at all ?

Say as a citizen of a free and democratic country i prefer to say Jai Hind.

If u say it on the lines of religion dont cry when u face isolation on other issues

Give and take theory works everywhere, Mama Ji

Yaar if Indian Army's regiments can have varying battle cries rooted in different religions then why can't a Muslim citizen use a cry that he's more comfortable with? I mean if an institution whose very integrity is dependent on unity among its ranks can allow this kind of diversity then why cant you guys be comfortable with this?

Indians should be proud of having such diversity.

 

[takeiteasy]

"Jai Bharat" can be acceptable. Muslims some of them believes it is the worship of mother goddess Durga when you sing "Bharat Mata" or "Vande mataram". Rightwing Hindutva Ugravaadi's believes they can enforce their version of national anthem or other things so as to subjugate minorities.