What's new

How to Make India’s Railways Safer

IndoCarib

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
10,784
Reaction score
-14
Country
India
Location
Antigua And Barbuda
A fire that swept through a moving passenger train in southern India on Monday killed at least 32 people and injured dozens, according to a railway official.

One coach of the Tamil Nadu Express going from New Delhi to the southern city of Chennai caught fire as it passed through the station in the town of Nellore in Andhra Pradesh.

A spokesman for India’s railways, Anil Saxena, could not confirm the cause of the fire. Local media reported that the blaze seems to have been caused by an electrical short circuit in the coach.

India’s state-owned rail network is the main mode of long-distance travel in the country. But safety remains a pressing issue.


Between January 2007 and September 2011, more than 2,000 people died in 738 railway accidents – including collisions, derailments, fires and unprotected railway crossings – the railways minister revealed last year in response to a Right-to-Information request filed by activist Subhash Chandra Agrawal.

In recent months, railway accidents have been alarmingly common. In May, 24 passengers were killed and 25 injured when a passenger train collided with a stationary goods train in Andhra Pradesh. Later that month, four people died after a train derailed in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh.

And this month, a goods train derailed in the eastern Indian state of Bihar. Last week, a speeding passenger train rammed into 11 coaches of a Mumbai suburban train in the western state of Maharashtra, killing three people and injuring more than 50.

Experts say that although the causes for these disasters vary, together they show that just how poor India’s record is when it comes to rail safety.

Here are the key areas experts say need urgent attention to make India’s railways safer:

Fire detection systems: Most trains in India still lack effective systems to detect smoke and fire. In some trains, the fire alarm systems have been installed in air-conditioned coaches, while other compartments have been neglected. In open compartments, it is more difficult to detect smoke. The Tamil Nadu Express fire took place in the train’s non-AC coaches.

Anti-collision technologies. These are devices that automatically halt the train if it overshoots a red signal. “India, which has the world’s fourth-largest railway network after the U.S. China and Russia, still doesn’t have such safety devices,” said Vijay Kumar, a railway safety expert and former railways official.

Such technologies could have helped prevent the 32 train collisions that took place in India since 2008, according to official figures.

Improved staffing.
While speeding and skipping red signals are the main causes of concern, human error is another common cause of accidents. The reason for this is partly that there is a shortage of staff, meaning that workers are often overworked, said Mr. Kumar. According to official figures, there were 18 train accidents last year due to faults of drivers and other railway staff.

New tracks. A significant number of accidents that take place in India are caused by derailments. For this, “derelict tracks are to blame,” Mr. Kumar said.

There were 273 train derailments in India since 2008, 28 of which took place last year, according to official figures.

A report submitted in February by a panel of experts appointed by the Indian government said there was an “urgent need to modernize the key revenue generating assets of the railways such as tracks and bridges.” It suggested modernization of 19,000 kilometers of existing tracks.

Manned railway crossings. There are more than 50,000 crossings along India’s railway tracks of which 15,000 are unmanned. This is where accidents are more likely to occur “primarily due to inadequate precautions by road users failing to observe mandatory sign boards, signals and basic traffic safety rules,” the ministry of railways said in a recent statement. “The cost of maintaining these [crossings] is huge. But work is underway,” it said.

According to government records, nearly 10,000 people died during the last three years in accidents on unprotected crossings. Mr. Kumar said the government should provide “easy options” such as “improved fencing, flyovers and overpass bridges” so that people don’t just rush across the railway tracks.


How to Make India’s Railways Safer - India Real Time - WSJ

How about privatizing ?? Infra companies like Reliance, GMR, GVK can make Indian railways world class
 
The fire in the Tamil Nadu express was probably caused due to a mobile charger while it was charging, wonder which make was the charger of or from which country?? my guess is as good as anybody's.
 
The fire in the Tamil Nadu express was probably caused due to a mobile charger while it was charging, wonder which make was the charger of or from which country?? my guess is as good as anybody's.
How can mobile charger burn down the whole compartment? The main issue is still lack of fire safety equipments.
 
dont forget Tata, L&T, Mahindras

Do you think the general population in India has the ability to pay for increased fare which will be the direct result of privatization ? Also--In places like bihar--people dont even bother to get platform tickets--let alone--train tickets. How will the private firms make money ?

Private companies are not philanthropists like the government--despite its many faults. They will cut their losses and scuttle operations at the first sign of trouble.

And besides--we are not mature enough to respect public property. Private parties will not be willing to entertain any damage to their property.
 
when the previous railway minister asked for a 2 ps increase per KM . his party asked him to resign, saying the aam admi could not afford it . he was asking for the hike so he could use the money to implement safety measures.
 
How can mobile charger burn down the whole compartment? The main issue is still lack of fire safety equipments.

Nowadays railways provide charging outlets so most probably a faulty charger caused the electric system to catch fire.
 
Nowadays railways provide charging outlets so most probably a faulty charger caused the electric system to catch fire.
A faulty charger may catch fire, but I dont think it can burn down a whole coach unless the coach is unsafe. Also, why could it not stop when the fire started, some people must have pulled the chain.
 
Do you think the general population in India has the ability to pay for increased fare which will be the direct result of privatization ? Also--In places like bihar--people dont even bother to get platform tickets--let alone--train tickets. How will the private firms make money ?

Private companies are not philanthropists like the government--despite its many faults. They will cut their losses and scuttle operations at the first sign of trouble.

And besides--we are not mature enough to respect public property. Private parties will not be willing to entertain any damage to their property.

So if the Bihari is not paying for it - who is? Me! Because I pay my taxes. It is a pretty nasty scenario.
 
A faulty charger may catch fire, but I dont think it can burn down a whole coach unless the coach is unsafe. Also, why could it not stop when the fire started, some people must have pulled the chain.

fire spreads through electric cables quite fast, if the electric cables are burnt - i doubt the chain pulling would have worked and it was a moving train with all the passengers asleep - due to the speed of the train the fire would have crept up faster.
 
When Laloo prasad was the rail minister he gave 2 brilliant idea which could had really increased the security of railways:

1. He told that there should be a ban on relatives of the passenger entering the platform (same as an airport), so only those person could have entered the platform which have a rail ticket, considerably reducing the rush on platforms & making them much safer.

2. He told that private company can sponsor a train, for example if Reliance decide to sponsor a train from delhi to mumbai than they have to take all the financial burden of the train & in return the name of the train would be changed to "Reliance Delhi-Mumbai express" & this same name will be taken in announcements also, hence giving considerable money supply to railways to make it more safer.

STILL WONDER WHY ANY OF THE IDEAS DIN'T GET MATERIALIZED
 
when the previous railway minister asked for a 2 ps increase per KM . his party asked him to resign, saying the aam admi could not afford it . he was asking for the hike so he could use the money to implement safety measures.

But I think its okay if aam aadmi is burned to death.
 
first step: kick that railway minister out from the cabinet....
Shuffling ministers like pack of cards wont solve any problem. Its a institutional issue, even a good raiway minister cant change it in 5 years.
We need massive investment in railways for few years (like highway projects) with focus on safety. Problem is passenger fare is artificially kept low (political issue) which bleeds railways. The users of railways should contribute to it instead of looking at taxpayers all the time.
 
Back
Top Bottom