What's new

How startup EM3 Agri Services is tackling farmer's distress, the Uber way

Nilgiri

BANNED
Joined
Aug 4, 2015
Messages
24,797
Reaction score
81
Country
India
Location
Canada
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...istress-the-uber-way/articleshow/53133968.cms

How startup EM3 Agri Services is tackling farmer's distress, the Uber way

Bal Kishan Meena, 54, needed little coaxing when he got an opportunity to try out what EM3 Agri Services had on offer. The startup offers farm equipment services on a payperuse basis. In 2014, when it set up its first centre called Samadhan in Meena's village Hasalpur in Hoshangabad district in Madhya Pradesh, he was among the first to try its service.

bal-meena.jpg

Meena is now a convert, using EM3’s virtually entire range of farm equipment — from the laser-levelling machine, which levels the ground with precision.

But then Meena isn't your average farmer. In India, where average farm holding is under 3 acres, he manages 100 acres of farmland, 30 acres of which is his own while the rest belongs to his brothers who work in cities.

A sanchalak (or a trained farmer) for ITC Ltd's eChoupal initiative, Meena's three children study in Bhopal. His 21yearold daughter has just finished her engineering degree and is now preparing for competitive exams. "I want us farmers to progress, try new things that could help us," he says. With EM3, Meena got a chance to try out a paddy transplanter machine, something he hadn't heard of before.

The machine could cover one acre in 35 minutes, a job that would otherwise take two farm labourers two days to complete. "Manually, the quality was not as good and uniform. It required monitoring, too. And the cost difference wasn't much," he says.

That was just the start. Meena is now a convert, using EM3's virtually entire range of farm equipment — from the laserlevelling machine, which levels the ground with precision, to the MB Plough for deep ploughing, to the power harrow to make seed beds. "Its equipment range is highend, its services are very good and the charges are reasonable," says Meena.

111.jpg


Smaller farmers, too, find EM3 services useful. Arvind Kourav, 47, owns seven acres of land on which he grows paddy, wheat, sugarcane and arhar (pigeon pea). Earlier he would hire equipment from others. "But they were not available when needed. Or were never punctual. But these people come on time and do the job well," says Kourav.

A Ray of Hope

In a country in the throes of change, farming and farmers have almost stood still. From debts to droughts, farmer suicides to crop failures, poverty to starvation, rural India's problems remain predictable and familiar. This is not for want of attention. In a democracy where agriculture employs over half the workforce, it is a constituency that carries significant political and economic weight. Unsurprisingly, policies, funds and sops from the government are in abundance.

Yet, agriculture has remained in a time warp. Despite having the second largest quantum of arable land in the world, India's crop yield is 30-60% of other developing countries. Outdated techniques, small farms, flawed government policies, poor infrastructure and high post-harvest loss are among the issues that have hobbled agriculture in India.

It is in this context that EM3 Agri's small steps gain significance. Founded two years ago by Rohtash Mal, 62, and his USeducated son Adwitiya, 33, the startup wants to change the way farming is done in India. Inspired by ridesharing firms like Uber, EM3 wants to "Uberise" farm services. "We want to bring relevant global technologies and equipment to India and make them accessible and affordable to Indian farmers with FAAS (farmingasaservice) where they pay per use," says the senior Mal.

He claims that their laserlevelling machine has cut down water usage by up to 30% and its power harrows have increased crop productivity by almost 20%. Mal's idea has investors excited. Last summer, EM3 raised its first round of equity funding of Rs 27.5 crore from Soros Economic Development Fund, via Aspada Investments, a fund that focuses on earlystage businesses in India in sectors like healthcare, agriculture and education. "Agriculture is fairly regressive in India," says Kartik Srivatsa, cofounder, Aspada Investments. "As a model, payperuse service is gaining traction. EM3 has a fairly deep understanding of how to accomplish it in the agri sector. We are very satisfied with the progress they have made," adds Srivatsa.

222.jpg


The idea occurred to Mal senior — a seasoned executive with stints at companies like Maruti Suzuki and the Bharti Group — when he was chief executive of Escorts Ltd. "We were pushing costly tractors to farmers who could ill afford them. Often indebted, benefits for them were not commensurate. Remember, it was tractorisation, not mechanisation of farmers, who had no alternative," says Mal. Buying a tractor makes sense for a farmer who has farmland of over 50 acres. An average farmer's landholding in India is under three acres. "It is not just about tractors — it's the farm implements that make the biggest difference," adds Vijay Rawal, director, Lemken India Agro Equipment. Union Agriculture Minister Radha Mohan Singh too agrees. He says that farm mechanisation will cut cultivation cost by 25% and raise productivity by 20% and will be critical in boosting farmers' income.

Inspired by Uber

There are companies like the 16yearold MachineryLink in the US with a business model similar to that of EM3. The difference, though, is that farmers in most mature markets have large land holdings and very different business dynamics. Those dynamics, for instance, allowed the American company to introduce an online platform called MachineryLink Sharing last year, which helps farmers rent out their expensive farm equipment, improve utilisation and make some money. Such a platform may be irrelevant in India, dominated as it is by small farmers and low mechanisation. However, that could be why EM3's payperuse service has tremendous potential. The tractor and farm equipment service market is estimated by analysts to be worth Rs 15,000 crore annually. Today that business is largely unorganised, dominated by solo rich farmers or governmentsubsidised custom hiring centres (CHCs) run by individuals who have limited scale and reach. Understandably, their implements are basic and the service patchy. "They don't come on time, their quality of work is unsatisfactory and they do not have highend equipment like laser levellers and paddy transplanters that EM3 has," says Uttam Meena, a farmer from Hasalpur who owns 100 acres of farm land.

333.jpg


EM3 has 10 Samadhan centres with 150 people in Madhya Pradesh and is working with potato farmers in partnership with multinational McCain Foods (India), a maker of French fries and potato specialities, in Gujarat. With some learnings and successful pilots, it is now gearing to expand aggressively pan India. In 24 months, cofounder Adwitiya hopes to have centres in 150 districts in Uttar Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan, Haryana, Gujarat, among other states, with a staff strength of over 1,500.

Farm equipment majors have taken note of the first mover in payperuse services. Early this year, Mahindra & Mahindra flagged off an agriequipment rental service with the brand Trringo with an initial corpus of Rs 10 crore. Complementing its tractor business, the venture will take the franchise route to grow and will target farmers who are not able to afford tractors or farm equipment. Trringo plans to set up 165 centres in 2016, with each centre covering 8090 villages. "We aim to make farm mechanisation accessible to all farmers, irrespective of how much land they own," says Arvind Kumar, CEO, Trringo. EM3, unlike M&M, has full control over all its Samadhan centres.

Warming Up to a New Idea

In the beginning, farmers greeted Mal's model with scepticism. He remembers how, two years ago, a farmer from a gathering of 150odd came up to him and bluntly said in front of the crowd: "Let's see how long you shahari babu (city dweller) last here with no power, drinking water." An MLA likened Mal to "seasonal frog", someone who comes to peddle their products and moves on.

Mal remained undeterred. Free demonstrations were the easiest way to both showcase his service and win over farmers. Last June, when he introduced a brand new paddy transplanter machine in Hasalpur, he did a free demonstration on 52 acres of farmland. The crop output was up over 30% and farmers didn't need much coaxing thereafter. He did something similar for laser levellers, a hitech equipment for levelling fields and which allows for efficient and even irrigation.

The cost of each Samadhan centre is currently Rs 1.5 crore (it could go up later); typically, a centre has 510 tractors and 2530 equipment pieces and would take up to two years to operationally break even. While there are government subsidies, EM3 has steered clear of them as Mal prefers to "have full control over operations"

. EM3 is slowly but surely putting in place structures and processes to enable all centres to be remotely tracked from Delhi, keeping tight control over service quality. In future, EM3 wants to turn into a fullfledged agrimarketplace, offering a comprehensive range of farmercentric services across crop lifecycles — from credit to insurance to helping farmers buy and sell crops through mobile phones. With data on farmers and their crop output, EM3 wants to use analytics to deliver other goods and services to them.

Mal is clear about a few things. All his Samadhan centres will be owned and operated by EM3, avoiding the franchise route. "That's the only way I can ensure good service," he says. Staff at the centre are locally hired, often in partnership with ICICI Foundation, which trains youth for different skills. The staff is put through regular training programmes — in house or with partners like John Deere — to upgrade and learn new skills. Preetam Verma, 35, is one of them.

He has not even passed Class 8, but for 15 years he worked as a helper in a tractor showroom in Hoshangabad in Madhya Pradesh, drawing a monthly salary of Rs 8,500. He joined EM3 in 2014 at a salary of Rs 7,000 and now draws `12,000. At EM3, he has learnt to operate machines like harvesters, cultivators, laser levellers, and has travelled to Pune, Delhi and Patiala for training. He likes the fact that this is a regular job with provident fund and insurance cover and farmers are grateful when he does a good job. "When I finish working on the farm, farmers have to fill a santushti (feedback) form," he says.

EM3 is stitching up a range of partnerships with ITC's eChoupals, Syngenta Foundation, farmers' cooperative SFAC, John Deere and Trimble. It works closely with sanchalaks of ITC eChoupals to reach out to farmers. With Syngenta Foundation, it developed an irrigation facility on a buildoperatetransfer basis for waterdeprived belt in Maharashtra for small and medium farmers. Now it is being expanded to other states and services. John Deere helps in equipment training of EM3 operators, among other things.

Waves of Change

For EM3, the timing could not have been better. Rising wages and scarce farm labour are pushing farmers to explore mechanisation. Rajeev Choudhary, director of agriculture engineering at the department of agriculture in Madhya Pradesh, says every year 34 lakh agricultural labourers in the state migrate to cities, leading to labour shortage.

With a litany of failed policies and schemes, the Centre is taking a fresh stab at how to address the agriculture crisis. In this year's budget, it set a target to double farmers' incomes. From irrigation to fertiliser subsidies, the government is overhauling some of the policies to address farmers' needs better. India is also looking overseas for help. For example, Haryana is piloting micro irrigation projects with the help of Israel, a world leader in irrigation technologies. The biggest mechanisation push is probably coming from a growing segment of private companies that are looking at India's agriculture more closely than ever before.

New players are entering the fray and old ones are scaling up operations. Beri Udyog Ltd (brand Fieldking), established in 1978, had just 10 pieces of equipment in its stable a decade back. Today, the range has risen to 75 and it also exports to 82 countries. In January, it will start its 35acre factory built at a cost of Rs 200 crore, substantially bigger than its existing 7acre plant.

"We expect demand to grow. EM3's payperuse is timely. For farmers, owning a tractor is just not sustainable," says Fieldking's MD Ravi Beri. Similarly, homegrown firm Shaktiman Farm Machinery is developing hitech implements with lower horse power, specific to Indian needs. It has launched implements like rice planters, cotton pickers and sugarcane harvesters. MD Hasmukh Gohil says aggressive pricing and locally suited products are putting pressure on global implements firms to rejig strategies. German firm Lemken is a good example.

In India since 2010, it set up its manufacturing facility in Nagpur in 2013 which helped bring down costs. For example, a 2.5 metre imported power harrow that would cost Rs 11.5 lakh could be made for Rs 3 lakh locally. Their farm implements mostly work on 50HPplus tractors, a small proportion — about 10% — sold here. With low sales, it currently exports to utilise capacity. In the future it may explore developing Indiaspecific products, says Rawal of Lemken India. Meanwhile, firms like EM3 with highend tractors could offer implements and services to customers on a payperuse basis. Israel too is looking at the space closely. "India needs affordable solutions. Israel has the answers," says Anat BernsteinReich, chairperson, IsraelIndia Chamber of Commerce. About EM3, she says that since it is a startup "it has no legacy, no old relationship to protect. Frugal and agile, it can help farming leapfrog in India".

Among the world leaders in agriculture technologies, Israeli firms are exploring areas like drip irrigation, remote soil testing, remote pest tracking and management. EM3's Mal is also exploring the possibility of bringing postharvest technologies that allow farmers to dry, pack and store grains safely, a solution that farmers in Hasalpur are eager to use. USbased Trimble Navigation, which specialises in remotesensing technologies, is in talks with EM3 to bring a handheld device called GreenSeeker. The device can take images of plants, analyse them and predict their health and vigour and then suggest inputs required in real time. The service is expensive, hence Trimble is working out a payperuse model for EM3 customers, something it is doing for the first time anywhere in the world, says its India MD Rajan Aiyer.

Despite the odds, Mal senior is clear that he is here for the long run. Investor Srivatsa too is well aware of the challenges ahead. "Even if EM3 is wildly successful, it will not be able to solve all of India's agriculture problems. Government's role is critical. One needs a constant, constructive dialogue with the government," says Srivatsa. EM3, though, is well placed to do its bit to improve farm productivity.

Kartik Srivatsa is the cofounder of Aspada Investments, which has raised funds from Soros Economic Development Fund. He has also been an investment advisor to the SONG Fund, an earlystage fund backed by Soros Economic Development Fund, Omidyar Network and Google. At Aspada Investments, he is focused on investments in earlystage businesses in healthcare, agriculture and education sectors in India. Its main focus is to look at ventures that create access, provide livelihood and market linkages for primary services like agriculture for the Indian masses. Srivatsa, an IIT alumnus who has worked with Lightspeed Venture Partners in the past, invested Rs 27.5 crore in EM3 AgriServices in 2014. He shares his rationale behind the EM3 investment and the journey so far:

Why EM3
Our fund's focus is to improve livelihood and access to market for primary services that cater to the masses. The agriculture sector with millions of farmers is of particular interest to us. EM3 has been proactively researching and exploring this space.

On agriculture
There are two major levers of change in the sector — improving inputs or boosting productivity. We are keen to explore how we can bring mechanisation that is suitable for India. India will never have large landholdings. So we need to find solutions that are viable here.

The EM3 model
Payperuse is gaining traction in so many areas. You can go to Amazon to use servers and pay per use. Agriculture in India is fairly regressive. EM3 has deep under understanding of how payperuse model can be brought to agriculture. We have worked with them to cocreate the model. FAAS (farming as a service) has big potential.

Journey so far
We have been very satisfied with the progress so far and the business model that they are evolving. They are building a platform that is scalable and can spread pan India. It is interesting that their services are more competitive than manual labour. Now we are going to scale very quickly. EM3 can be the beachhead to how agriculture will grow in India.

Its significance
This is one of the few areas in agriculture where you can offer services to farmers and be operationally and commercially viable. With time, as they collect some primary data on farmers, they can explore other products and services like offering financing etc, all of it keeping farmers at the centre.

Challenges ahead
How do you scale faster and continue to improve agricultural productivity? That's a big one. Operating in lowskill environment, they need to build systems around training, maintenance etc, that make economic sense. Agriculture has never been aspirational — how do you make it cool and reclaim its primacy? Even if EM3 is wildly successful, it will not be able to solve all of agricultural problems. It requires a constructive dialogue with the government. India has the second largest arable land in the world. EM3 can lead the way in showcasing a FAAS platform that is scalable and also viable.

@fsayed @ranjeet @Ryuzaki @Joe Shearer @magudi @Rain Man @Water Car Engineer @Levina @anant_s @PARIKRAMA @Kashmiri Pandit @proud_indian @kadamba-warrior @litefire @itachii @CorporateAffairs @Local_Legend @Star Wars @kaykay @farhan_9909 @Rajaraja Chola
@dadeechi
@Sky lord
et al.

A novel idea I think. The surplus labour it will create over time needs to be brought into more productive employment however. NREGA is not the long term solution.
 
Last edited:
.
When at the time of green revolution in India , we adopted Japanese model where we used a rope to align the place to put the seed or the paddy. So we can have more crop in the same place compare to just putting it randomly.

In my opinion , getting maximum output is not the problem . The problem is middle men who takes this crop from farmers with a cheep price . If Govt. ( state and central ) can boost the procurement policy without any interference of middle men , farmers get more from their output in the way of money.
 
.
In my opinion , getting maximum output is not the problem . The problem is middle men who takes this crop from farmers with a cheep price . If Govt. ( state and central ) can boost the procurement policy without any interference of middle men , farmers get more from their output in the way of money.

With the new e-portal policy of govt + direct sales policies, it is becoming a reality.

http://www.narendramodi.in/pm-modi-...al-agriculture-market-nam-in-new-delhi-440352

In fact the middle men are threatening strikes when the govt is not taking up their position anymore:

http://indianexpress.com/article/in...go-on-indefinite-strike-from-july-18-2894445/

Expect more of the same when more transparency and market access is available to each farmer and need for middleman is reduced (or at least they are all forced to compete with each other for time being).

Govt should totally deregulate this sector I agree.....that way farmers can take advantage of modern technology in reaching clients directly and also take advantage of India's improving logistics and transport infra.

More links, there are challenges but I believe Modi is commited to achieving it...he is rigorous and results oriented and he has made it a personal promise:

http://www.firstpost.com/india/indi...et-platform-91-6-behind-schedule-2736580.html

http://swarajyamag.com/economy/harv...ic-national-agriculture-market-10-focus-areas
 
.
A novel idea I think. The surplus labour it will create over time needs to be brought into more productive employment however. NREGA is not the long term solution.

I fear by the time India moves its agri-labourers in to industrial sector, these jobs might be replaced by robots and 3D-printers. Automation is around the corner, we might have missed the manufacturing bus too late. :(
 
.
With the new e-portal policy of govt + direct sales policies, it is becoming a reality.

http://www.narendramodi.in/pm-modi-...al-agriculture-market-nam-in-new-delhi-440352

In fact the middle men are threatening strikes when the govt is not taking up their position anymore:

http://indianexpress.com/article/in...go-on-indefinite-strike-from-july-18-2894445/

Expect more of the same when more transparency and market access is available to each farmer and need for middleman is reduced (or at least they are all forced to compete with each other for time being).

Govt should totally deregulate this sector I agree.....that way farmers can take advantage of modern technology in reaching clients directly and also take advantage of India's improving logistics and transport infra.

More links, there are challenges but I believe Modi is commited to achieving it...he is rigorous and results oriented and he has made it a personal promise:

http://www.firstpost.com/india/indi...et-platform-91-6-behind-schedule-2736580.html

http://swarajyamag.com/economy/harv...ic-national-agriculture-market-10-focus-areas



Rightly said .

It will take time to establish all this. Hope the wait will worth it .

If the system works well, the empty ,dried fields will become green again and hope to see our youth there as proud farmers as like any IT company working guy.

Also making new methods popular among farmers , such as drip irrigation and to supply the necessary equipment in an affordable price. Procurement policy does not alone can any magic.

There should be awareness about the usage of chemical fertilizers . Don't want to see the endosulfan kind of tragedy again.
 
.
I fear by the time India moves its agri-labourers in to industrial sector, these jobs might be replaced by robots and 3D-printers. Automation is around the corner, we might have missed the manufacturing bus too late. :(

They have been saying this for how long now? 50 years at least I would venture.

Automation is overrated. It will increase and augment productivity for sure...but its not like that means every single job in production can be done automatically.
 
.
What a pleasant thing to read!
I do recall about 20 years back, a group of farmers from Punjab used to bring Combined Wheat Harvester & threshers to parts of western UP and offered services in harvesting season of April. In those days, power supply was quite erratic and farmers were quite pressed for time for a period of about 6 weeks, when crop was harvested, grains threshered, packed in gunny bags and then shifted to FCI store houses.
Manual harvesters take a lot of time and effort and combined harvesters changed all that, but owing to heavy cost, not everybody could afford them.
Punjab-Combine-Harvester.jpg

So that group came in handy as they could harvest acres of land in a day and save a lot of trouble to farmers.
Therefore when we see today that new technology is available to farmers making use of internet, it indeed is heartening.
Agriculture unfortunately is the laggard sector in our economy owing to various problems like irrigation, financing and proper marketing and storage. Influx of technology is therefore of paramount importance and availability of this technology to farmers even more vital.
Hope more such efforts by individuals are seen in future too.
 
.
I do recall about 20 years back, a group of farmers from Punjab used to bring Combined Wheat Harvester & threshers to parts of western UP and offered services in harvesting season of April.

Yah the concept is known in TN for some time now as well with leasing of various equipment when not in use (esp with the loss of cheap agro labour compared to before and quite low rural fertility rates and high urbanisation)....but I don't think anyone integrated it quite this way by EM3 and actually actively went out to give demos and show the increase in productivity and lowered costs as a trial (i.e actively enabling and growing the overall demand by pooling resources rather than just using spare existing capacity) with all sorts of technology.

For long time in school (outside India) I would always read how India is behind the curve in incorporating modern technology and increasing productivity and yield etc.. to even that of fellow developing countries. One book specifically talked about how in Sri Lanka, the mini japanese tractors were very popular and instrumental in increasing productivity...compared to India where it was go big or go home philosophy (and most could simply not afford the go big). I always thought to myself why cant there be better pooling of resources through renting etc...it even made me appreciate the leftist concept of communes in Israel (kibbutz) or just co-operatives in general...but I guess the versatility and flexibility is just not there in such systems for a dynamic landscape like India, one that is increasingly becoming more free-market oriented and leapfrogging through it with technology.

We need to borrow the best of what the IT and mobile telecoms revolution taught us (both were sectors the govt did not over-regulate since they are not a traditional industry of the old industrial revolution and sort of took them by surprise but thankfully lined up well with the post cold war reforms)...and implement appropriately and thoroughly in every sector of human activity in India.

Agriculture has to be on the forefront of this, since it employs 50 - 60% of our people still and we need to bring productivity to get this down in the long term and increase production as well. For that we simply cannot afford to have state-sponsored logjams and inefficiencies...all extracting from the farmer at every stage. It is why I am glad someone was able to implement such an idea without govt support or finance and is now growing it organically from the financial success. This is the perfect synthesis of wealth creation through knowledge and the power it invests in the hands of the farmer (to parallelise with the 3 main Hindu goddesses)....a testament to the free market. I hope such ideas keep popping up in the enabling environment that is finally being created by the govt (mostly by stepping back and resetting interference to 0 or near 0). I am chuffed!
 
Last edited:
.
I think Science is yet to be used in its full potential .

1. Prediction of weather .
If there is a system to deliver the weather prediction though mobile app or any other mean , they can plan the farming date or harvesting date .

2. Need more Soil testing centers .
With the accurate soil testing results we can understand the pH level and use the fertilizers just for the right quantity and type. It will help the soil to remain more " Natural and Original " .

3.Relaxed terms and conditions for loan.
Even though there are so many circulars , our banks still hesitates to give loans to Farmers and always pressure them to get the repayment . One of the reason for suicides. If there is an initiative to start a Bank or Co-Operative society just to deal with agriculture. It will be a game changer. So there might not be a need to push commercial banks to do the things they don't want. All the financial help of state and central govt can be channeled though it .

4. Modernization of equipment .
There is a shortage of labour in agriculture sector. That can be filled with machinery . As @anant_s said , it might be costlier to buy but they can take it on a rent . I have seen group of farmers taking Harvesting Machine on rent for a day and finish the entire field . With the creation of the group , they can afford the rent as a whole. They made it possible by planning things in the beginning . They seeded at the same date , bought fertilizers and other services in a wholesale terms. Saved lots of money compared to the rates when they used buy it alone .
harvester-arjun.jpg
 
.
In short they are doing what NABARD and RRB does only more efficiently.
When at the time of green revolution in India , we adopted Japanese model where we used a rope to align the place to put the seed or the paddy. So we can have more crop in the same place compare to just putting it randomly.

In my opinion , getting maximum output is not the problem . The problem is middle men who takes this crop from farmers with a cheep price . If Govt. ( state and central ) can boost the procurement policy without any interference of middle men , farmers get more from their output in the way of money.
There is a nexus between the middlemens and the govt officials which makes it more difficult for the govt to take action. Plus the govt cannot just take the middlemens out of the supply chain as it will make more people unemployed in the country.
 
.
In short they are doing what NABARD and RRB does only more efficiently.

There is a nexus between the middlemens and the govt officials which makes it more difficult for the govt to take action. Plus the govt cannot just take the middlemens out of the supply chain as it will make more people unemployed in the country.


I was talking about the rural area where they are not exposed to a free marked and always end up with some monopoly vendor.

The unholy relationship between Govt employees and others will there as always . What we need is a system where they not only announcements but also follow ups to find if the system is reaching the lowest tier as imagined.

There is no need to take out the middle men . But the state and Central govt should insist a price for every corp and it should be updated.

For eg: for rice , govt says the minimum price for buying rice from farmers , per metric ton is 700 USD . So no buyer can quote below from the farmer . The profit for the middle men will be there but in lower level and the farmer get more .

 
.
I was talking about the rural area where they are not exposed to a free marked and always end up with some monopoly vendor.

The unholy relationship between Govt employees and others will there as always . What we need is a system where they not only announcements but also follow ups to find if the system is reaching the lowest tier as imagined.

There is no need to take out the middle men . But the state and Central govt should insist a price for every corp and it should be updated.

For eg: for rice , govt says the minimum price for buying rice from farmers , per metric ton is 700 USD . So no buyer can quote below from the farmer . The profit for the middle men will be there but in lower level and the farmer get more .

Even if they sell their product in the local market it is very dirt cheap during the harvesting season.
It is not economically viable for a farmer to take their output in a tier two-three cities to sell. The middlemen is their to facilitate the process unfortunately in India the middlemens works more as a wholesaler who earns many times more by hoarding.
What you are saying is already there as the Minimum Support Price(MMP). But that works only during the bumper production.
 
.
When at the time of green revolution in India , we adopted Japanese model where we used a rope to align the place to put the seed or the paddy. So we can have more crop in the same place compare to just putting it randomly.

In my opinion , getting maximum output is not the problem . The problem is middle men who takes this crop from farmers with a cheep price . If Govt. ( state and central ) can boost the procurement policy without any interference of middle men , farmers get more from their output in the way of money.

This is where the NAM(National Agriculture Market) plays a big role where the farmers can sell their products anywhere in India through their mobile without the involvement of Middleman . I hope GOI comes up with a robust policy on this regard as Namo has shown keen interest to this
 
.
Even if they sell their product in the local market it is very dirt cheap during the harvesting season.
It is not economically viable for a farmer to take their output in a tier two-three cities to sell. The middlemen is their to facilitate the process unfortunately in India the middlemens works more as a wholesaler who earns many times more by hoarding.
What you are saying is already there as the Minimum Support Price(MMP). But that works only during the bumper production.


I know about MMP. Commodities like natural Rubber breaths because of it . It is to help farmers from the falling price of the commodity.

I am saying to have a govt. fixed rate for the specified class and grade of all type of corps. Just like the circle rate in land deals.

This is where the NAM(National Agriculture Market) plays a big role where the farmers can sell their products anywhere in India through their mobile without the involvement of Middleman . I hope GOI comes up with a robust policy on this regard as Namo has shown keen interest to this


Yes. @Nilgiri shared the link at #3 , where we can see only 8 states has been involved in it . Many of them are not active.

http://www.enam.gov.in/NAM/home/dashboard3.html

So this is a platform in growing stage ( hopefully ) . When we are shifting all market to internet, we should remember that there are many places where electricity is yet to come . What if there is no one to help farmers to set up the profile and help them to bid ? I am talking about rural areas .
4a9c429b-4d5e-422b-98ad-5a0b7a18ae9fHiRes.JPG


The poor farmers are mostly illiterate and dose not knows how to operate the apps and internet . If Central Govt is creating a new market online , they should push all state govt to participate in it actively and start more kisan seva kendras all around the country . Especially in rural areas.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom