AgNoStiC MuSliM
ADVISORS

- Joined
- Jul 11, 2007
- Messages
- 25,259
- Reaction score
- 87
- Country
- Location
How about the genocides by Timur lame and Nadir Shah for a start?
How do you think the Hindu/Budhhist culture get so totally wiped out from Afghanistan/Pakistan? Was it all without any violence/genocides?
Why are there no Zoroastrians left in Iran? Did they leave Persia and seek refuge in India voluntarily?
Almost 50% of today's Muslims had Hindu ancestors. I can tell you most of them did not convert voluntarily! Why don't people convert now in such large numbers? Because they can no longer be forced on pain of death or discrimination!
Conversions over hundreds of years would have done the same thing.
I am not saying that there may not have been genocides, but I think to argue that that genocide occurred simply because "conversions couldn't possibly have done so" is flawed.
As for conversions not occurring with the same rapidity anymore - it could be attributed to both the novelty of a new faith wearing off (its not "new" anymore). Do we have any numbers on when the conversion rate stabilized? Your argument is really quite speculative at this point.